45 of 46 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Oate's Returns With Another Provocative Family Drama, September 15, 2009
With "We Were the Mulvaneys" and "The Gravedigger's Daughter," Joyce Carol Oates mined the intense emotional battlefields that can arise within families. Similar in theme and seriousness is her latest--"Little Bird of Heaven." In small town Sparta, New York, a young mother is found murdered. The primary suspects are her estranged husband and a married man with whom she was having an affair. But this is not a mystery or a thriller, it is a study of how such a tragedy can affect the families involved. The central characters are the children of the suspects--Krista who had no idea her father was involved with the victim and Aaron who actually finds the body of his mother. Virtual strangers, Aaron and Krista are now eternally linked by the crime and are infatuated with each other even as they struggle with the rage of being on opposing sides.
Perhaps the most intriguing aspect of "Little Bird of Heaven" is its narrative device. The first half of the novel is told from Krista's point of view. A little girl who idolizes and idealizes her father even as the town, her mother, and her brother turn away--her naiveté and stubbornness keep the harsh realities at bay. The second half of the novel is told from Aaron's perspective. Less vocal and introspective, Aaron struggles with his mother's death and what might be his father's involvement. The underlying themes of prejudice permeate every page as the town of Sparta casts its shadows over all the participants. Both Krista and Aaron must confront silent accusations as the more they support their fathers, the more they distance themselves from their previous lives.
"Little Bird of Heaven" is both intimate, yet surprisingly aloof. By telling most of the story through Krista eyes, the complexities of the situation are filtered through someone who doesn't fully understand what's going on. Aaron's story lacks some insight as well as he remains emotionally distant throughout. It's an intriguing set-up that does work on its own terms. Some may wish this were a slightly different novel, however, I believe this is exactly what Oate's intended. Ultimately, "Little Bird of Heaven" is about a lot of things--almost least of which is the murder itself. When Aaron and Krista meet later in life, it gives them both a chance at closure--but how important is closure when you've already lived your life?
"Little Bird of Heaven" is an adult story about loss, faith, guilt and ultimately need. And it's about growing up when you have no choice but to endure the hardships life sends your way. Oate's latest novel is a challenging and rewarding story that doesn't offer up easy answers for anything. Recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Inimitably Oates, September 15, 2009
Little Bird of Heaven is inimitably Oates. It has all her signatures - -the stylization of her writing, the focus on family narrative as destiny, and the mixture of pain and love. The stylized writing in this book is more pronounced than in some of her others. She repeats some things multiple times for emphasis and for varied affect. Initially, this bothered me but as the book progressed, I was so caught up in the narrative that nothing could deter me from wanting to turn to the next page.
As in her other books, love is closely mixed with pain, sexual and emotional longing, cruelty and betrayal. The family narrative is examined as destiny. She explores the theme of wanting to rewrite our narratives with the hope that this time it can turn out differently. The characters are drawn to people and events that remind them of their pasts, painful as they were. However, they hope that by reliving the past, they can change the outcome. Oates asks the reader, `Can we really change our destinies?' She acknowledges the fact that life is ever-changing but people are caught up in the current of family destinies.
This novel is about the murder of a young woman named Zoe Kruller. She is a singer in a local band, mother of Aaron and estranged wife of Delray. There are two persons of interest, suspects in this murder - - Delray Kruller, Zoe's estranged husband, and Eddie Diehl, Zoe's lover. Eddie is the father of Krista and he has been having an affair with Zoe for quite some time. Once the murder occurs he is shunned by his wife and made to leave their home.
The story is told in two parts, from two viewpoints. The first half of the book is told from the vantage point of Krista Diehl, Eddie's daughter. She is close to her father and loves him unconditionally. She believes with all her heart that he could not have murdered Zoe. She believes that Delray Kruller is the murderer. Krista becomes obsessed with Aaron Kruller though at the time of the murder she is in grade school and he is a middle school student, about four years Krista's senior. She believes she loves him and begins to shadow him, appearing at places he is known to go.
Aaron's story is the second half of this novel. He is the one who finds the murdered Zoe and this breaks a part of him. He is aware of Krista but has no idea why she is appearing at places he frequents. He believes that Eddie Diehl, Krista's father, murdered his mother. Aaron and Krista come from different sides of the track. Aaron is part Seneca Indian and there is a lot of prejudice against his people in their small town of Sparta, N.Y. There is one scene where Aaron finds himself Krista's savior and the profundity of love, cruelty and pain is described in a poignant and almost revolting manner.
Oates does a wonderful job of describing the pain that children endure when they grow up in addicted families. Both Eddie Diehl, Zoe and Delray Kruller are alcoholics and drug addicts and their children live with shame, secrecy and silence as they harbor a loyalty to their parents - - no one must know what goes on inside the home. At the same time, they become what is known as `parental children', children who parent the adults. As Aaron says "He'd been an adult for as long as he could remember, before even Zoe had died. Only vaguely could Krull recall a boy - - a little boy named `Aaron' - - on the far side of Zoe's death as in a shadowy corner of the house on Quarry Road". (p.357) . Not only do Aaron and Krista lose their childhoods to the ravages of addiction, Aaron feels that this has become his legacy.
"Headed to hell after her. Drinking beer till his head buzzed and his gut
was bloated like something dead and swollen in the water thinking how
it was so, Zoe had plunged into hell and was pulling them after her like
dirty water swirling down a drain. The kind of family situation, you
could call it an inheritance, you'd naturally need to get high and stay
high as long as you could." (p. 364)
This is a powerful book, not a light read. It is a book about despair, pain, longing, betrayal, addiction and cruelty. It is a book about life on the edges of the precipice where the characters are holding on by the mere strength of their fingertips. It is a book with brilliant insight and a riveting narrative.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wow!, October 2, 2009
OK I admit it. I read everything by Joyce Carol Oates. That being said this is once again a marvel written by a writer who continues to outdo herself. In terms of nuanced phrasing, intriguing plot, subtlety of language, never revealing too much, and pulling the reader along in a magnetic aura of a dream, Oates is a master. If you have read nothing else of hers, you can start here and learn to love her artistry in a genre she has taken as her own territory. If you have liked or loved or even hated other books of hers (because admit it, she is versatile and varied) read this one. She is the real thing.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No