Customer Reviews

Live from Palestine: International and Palestinian Direct Action Against the Israeli Occupation

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

The primary function of the ISM is to participate with Palestinians in locally organized non-violence resistance to Israeli occupation, and to bear witness to the ongoing humanitarian, political, and social crises of the region. Membership in this organization is composed of an international array of activists concerned with the Palestinian crisis, and the achievement of equity and justice in the area.

Some of the activities that ISM volunteers regularly participate includes: Monitoring and documenting human rights abuses at some of the many dozens of military checkpoints;
Participate in the removal of roadblocks that restrict Palestinian movement;
Participate in nonviolent marches, demonstrations, etc.; Media work - informing international media of what is occurring in the Occupied territories and put them in touch with those who may speak to them; Participate in the annual Olive harvest with Palestinian farmers who are at high risk of injury due to violent attacks by Israeli settlers; And work with communities that are being affected by the building of the so-called "security wall" and are seeking creative ways to bring attention to and to resist the stealing of their land and means of livelihood. Moreover, ISM volunteers get involved with numerous other emergency situations from accompanying children through checkpoints to school in an effort to prevent them from being tear gassed for defying orders to return to their homes; to accompanying and making sure that ambulances are able to get through check points, to bringing food and supplies to families whose houses have been taken over by soldiers for military purposes and in which they are unable to leave; to the very important monitoring and documenting the unreported late night military invasions and the destruction such caused.

First, the ISM has been extremely influential in organizing and supporting various forms of non-violent resistance in Palestine. While Palestinians have a history of nonviolent resistance, the Israeli government considers all forms of resistance as dangerous and illegal. Thus it is not surprising that it is common to have Palestinians involved in actions that, say in the united states would be protected - like demonstrations - is met with incredible violence and arrests. ISM volunteers have come to participate in such nonviolent forms of resistance and as such, hopes that they will less dangerous for Palestinians to engage in and thus keeping such a form viable.

These non-violent forms of protest clearly do not receive anywhere the amount of attention by the media or others, as do violent forms of resistance, such as suicide bombings. Thus, left undiscussed is the structural and implicit violence that shapes everyday life for ordinarily Palestinians; this violence is not of a "spectacular" nature but, rather, hinges on repeated and routine forms of harassment (such as road checks, curfews over entire regions for many weeks, house searches, arrests without charges, verification and seizure of identification papers, obstacles to travel, and school and work closures) carried out by Israeli soldiers and settlers in the name of state security. However, nonviolent practices, besides the fact that they are the preferred method by ordinary Palestinians, they also exercise an important counter-effect to the relentless neo-Zionist position that all Arab others are "by nature" unruly, disorderly, and violent. It is through such rhetoric that Israel repeatedly casts itself as the civilized "first world" to the unruly "third world" -- even when that so-called and self identified "first world" is in the one who is in the process of barbarically colonizing the territory of that of the barbaric third world. This is one of the most fundamental problems in the media representation and popular understandings of the Arab-Israeli conflict. Perceiving that Israel - exercising a rote, disciplined, and routine form of violence is a "civilized" state, precisely because its use of violence in its everyday forms is so routine. Counter to that is the perception that the Arabs are fundamentally uncivilized because they use "barbaric" and sporadic methods of violence and intimidation. The problem with this perception is that it leaves unquestioned the Israeli state's use of everyday and ritualistic violence. Non-violent forms of protest trump both of the above options and, since these forms of protest come from the Palestinian side, they very importantly undermine the prevailing ideology concerning "unruly" Palestinians from which the Israeli state has gained so much mileage.

Second, the presence of ISM activists in the occupied territories brings a level of understanding to the conflict that would be completely impossible otherwise. Were it not for the information that activists bring to the outside world - through their writing, formal, and informal talks, the only news sources would be the media and strictly partisan viewpoints. It is the sustained and daily presence of activists in the daily life of Palestinians which allows participants to bring perspective and an in-depth knowledge of the ritual forms of harassment which these people must endure - everything from the constant crossing of borders and barricades, to the displacement of people due to the building of the "security wall", to the shooting of rubber bullets at children who maybe ignoring orders to return home just in order to go to school, or the effects of twenty-four hour curfews. Given the tendency of the American media at least to present a picture of the conflict that favors Israeli interests, it is absolutely indispensable to have a perspective which provides some balance to common representations. This is an important, though less obvious, form of resistance as well in the sense that it disrupts the continual flow of ideologically driven and one-sided representations.

Perhaps even more importantly and in a direct and tangible way, ISM activists can continue to counter the repeated acts of violence, harassment, and human rights violations which are such an ingrained aspect of daily life for Palestinians in the Occupied territories. These are state-generated techniques of violence and intimidation, which can only be countered by non-state generated and NGO supported forms of non-violent resistance.

For too long the public has been denied access to the truth about a place that touches deeply many of us, though in different ways: The Holy Land. World peace movement seems to draw towards centre stage only to provide an alternative to institutionalised human rights bodies that have lost focus as they became increasingly politicised. The legacy of our fellow citizens of the world, such as Rachel Cory, who put their lives on the line for the sake of truth, is quite gratifying. Live From Palestine is the voice of those truth lovers- their work is a promised land where the future may hold hope for those devastated by hostilities for so long. The book includes essays from a divers group of Israelis, Palestinians, and internationals who perhaps have not met in person but most certainly have on the level of consciousness. Live From Palestine intimately tells many stories, but one truth. It "documents the voices of Palestinian non-violent activists who have too often been censored from US mainstream media."

Also recommended: Image And Reality Of The Israel-Palestine Conflict, Norman Finkelstein; The Holocaust Against the Palestinians, Michael Hoffman and Moshe Lieberman.

Live From Palestine is an honest account of peace activists who devoted their energy to find the truth and bring it back home to us. They risked their lives to tell the story that our media will never tell. The book is also a valuable account of Palestinians and internationals, but more significantly of Israelis who are bound by their belief in the Palestinian cause, disbelief in the brutal occupation, and who wish to contribute to a just solution to the longest standing conflict. Live From Palestine brought a new dimension to my understanding of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, a well-balanced one. Please invest in this publication.

I read the book after I attended a Peace in the Middle East group discussion at a Boulder CO. where I met Ms. Nancy. She showed great honesty and intellectual spirit through total subjectivity in her thoughts during the meeting and in the book. It is a wonderful read for subjective intellects.

Do you want to do something destructive and immoral? Then this book may be for you!

It is about people who are doing their part to make a big mess out of human civilization. And it praises them!

Of course, human civilization will probably survive attacks on it. And those who are now so proud to fight against it will be forgotten, or at best, despised.

This book is racist propaganda that favors arbitrary discrimination against Asian Jews. The claim is that doing so will somehow help some Arabs, but I see no reason to believe that such an attack on human rights will help Arabs.

Want some facts? Then simply avoid this book. It starts by giving a little background information. "Zionist forces launched assualts" against Arabs in December, 1947, it proclaims. Wow. In real life, it was the other way around, with the Arabs launching attacks on the Jews. And the book continues to make hash of history and reality. Many of the contributors are infamous for their hatred of truth on this subject, including Noam Chomsky, Mustafa Barghouti, Ed Said, Adam Shapiro, Rachel Corrie, and the Wicked Witch of the Middle East herself, Hanan Ashrawi.

Starhawk is one of the contributors, proving that being a Pagan does not give one immunity from supporting thugs. She argues that the fence that Israel has been putting up to try to save civilian lives from terrorist bombers is a bad thing.

Now I agree with Starhawk that we ought not fence people off from each other unnecessarily. We need peace in the area, and we need both Jews and Arabs to be able to live in all the nations of the Middle East. And this fence may look like a step in the wrong direction in that respect.

In fact, the fence is there simply to save some lives. If we keep letting bombers kill civilians, we'll have even less cooperation in the region. The real argument against the fence is that it may help save Jewish lives. And Starhawk is to be condemned for giving her voice in support of that. She's not doing any Pagans any favors by siding with the forces of tyrannical and arbitrary monotheist fanaticism.

I do not recommend this book.

Live from Palestine: International and Palestinian Direct Action Against the Occupation is quite similar to the book Bethlehem Besieged, in that it is a very one-sided and biased view of things happening in the middle east.

The author's premise is akin to a boy who kills both his parents and then asks the judge for mercy since he is an orphan.

Much of the calamity the people of Bethlehem and Palestine face is due to their own shortsightedness and lack of true leadership.