Customer Reviews

Live Recordings 1956-1969: Off the Record Volume 1

5 star:		(10)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

A treasure trove of rare Monroe performances, from various folk fests and concerts. For the most part these live renditions don't capture the full intensity of Monroe's music, but there's certainly not a bad cut on this album. The best bit, though, is a track called "Monroe Family Segment," which consists of Q&A dialogs with fans and festival moderators asking Monroe to explain his techniques and how he learned them from various family members... Interesting in and of itself, but also a great glimpse at Bill's rapport with his fans.

I knew I liked the bluegrass sound, but I didn't own any... so on a whim I found this CD in a store. I bought it because I thought I recognized the name, and it did have more songs than most. That was four years ago and I still think of it as one of the best purchases I've ever made. If you like the mandolin and high old time sound... then you must have this CD!! It's over an hour of the best bluegrass ever recorded, and the information in the cover/recorded interview with Bill (#27. Monroe Family Segment) really let you get a chance to know the man.

I have gotten myself into bluegrass lately even though I'm not new to it either. I grew up hearing bluegrass music on television like the Beverly Hillbillies, Hee Haw and the Dukes of Hazzard. However, I always wanted to learn more about Bill Monroe and his music. The music on this CD is of course authentic, traditional bluegrass. I highly recommend this to any bluegrass and even non-bluegrass listener. I would like to see America get back to its music roots. We are losing it with the non substance music we hear today.

It is pretty hard for me to think that there would be a Bill Montroe recording of any kind that isn't worth ten stars on these ratings. To be sure, if you dont already have a lot of his music and don't know much, you are not sure what to get, if you cannot afford all of it.

However, this is must-have music. The recording studio has captured Bill's greatness to be sure. Yet, Bluegrass is like many other musics, it is never the same live as it is recorded. Monroe's mandolin playing, in particular, is frequently responsive to and often quite competitive with, what other players are doing, so that even on songs you may have recorded, even on standards like Rawhide, there are surprises on this record for even the most seasoned Monroe fan. Likewise, Bluegrass is an improvisational music, a half sister to jazz. So the freedom to pick on stage until the picking has been done to Big Mon's satisfaction brings more music by all, but particularly by Monroe than what happens when the music has to be fit into a three-minute recording.

Ralph Rinzler whose labor of love to traditional music brought us Tom Ashley and Dock Watson and who took over management of the Bluegrass Boys and became one for a time, put together these recordings. He is careful not to simply repeat recordings, but at the same time to give you unique versions of standard tunes. He also gives you Monroe in different settings over the years. We hear him doing a live show in a small Southern town in the 1950s, we hear him at the first Bluegrass festival ever, we hear him sitting around a living room with ace players in all-night picking party featuring a duel with Hazel Dickens. He also presents a recording of Bill playing, talking, and singing with his brothers, Birch and Charlie, something that was rare became there was so much antagonism between the brothers over the years. As an amateur musician what impresses me besides the great music that I expect from Monroe is the quality and tightness of the bands that he kept over the years, the way he was able to keep getting an infusion of greatly talented musicians and singers, but continued to develop his own sound, such a unique blend of the ancient tones of Black and white traditional music with new ideas that came from professional country music and even jazz.

The problem with Monroe is that he is too good and too important, it is just too hard to play his music, because then you don't want to hear anything else.

This one is a must -- live recordings that show Monroe and the various Blue Grass Boys at their best. You will not be disappointed.

The music is fabulous, with that extra edge that live performance gives. What makes this disc a must for every Bill Monroe fan is the wonderful stage chatter and the interviews which reveal so much about the personality and history of one of the true genius' of 20th century music. This disc was produced with loving care by Ralph Rinzler, one of Bill's greatest fans and, later, his manager. Put on your reading glasses for some of the best album notes ever. Bill Monroe fans will love this disc, and initiates will find it easy to access and deeply revealing.

History was truly in the making with this album. It features what I believe to be the first recording of Walls of Time, co-written by Monroe and Peter Rowan. It also features a spine-tingling, hauntingly beautiful rendering of Poor Wayfaring Stranger - the most powerful recordings of this song I have ever heard. A special treat at the end is a question and answer session that included Birch Monroe and Bill, in which they talk about their lives and childhoods. I recommend this album highly, a potent mix of fast, hard-driving bluegrass with exquisite gospel tunes and Monroe classics.

Very traditional, but also very off the cuff. If you are more of a contemporary bluegrass fan and you don't like the high tenor of Bill Monroe, this isn't for you, but if you are a traditional bluegrass fan, this is it. The liner notes are as comprehensive and impressive as the music.

No one artist will ever be missed more by me than Bill Monroe. As a teenager back in the early 80's, before the corporate mentality took over bluegrass, Bill was out there burning things up. Nothing in this world will ever mean as much to me as watching Bill perform "My Last Days On Earth" live at Bean Blossom in 1983. His name is synonymous with people like Louis Armstrong, Robert Johnson, Elvis and Roy Acuff due to his guiding influence.

What is found on this disc are two phases of Bill's career. The first is the mid to late 50's when rock n roll was gaining popularity and country artists were plugging in to keep pace. Bill, ever the purist to what he'd created and being his typical hard headed self, refused to put any band on the road that carried an electirc instrument. It was during this era that gigs were hard to come by for "hillbilly" music. That doesn't in any way take awy from these perfomances however. Bill and crew were at the top of thier respective game and the delivery is completely flawless. Ed Mayfield is the guitarist and lead singer on several of these cuts. The toure de force he turns in on Blue Yodel # 5 alone is jaw dropping. Also included is a guest spot with Don Reno playing banjo on Bluegrass Stomp, with Bill providing some of the spookiest, blusiest playing ever to be heard.

The second phase is equally impressive featuring the likes of Richard Greene, Pete Rowan, Bill Kieth (introduced as Brad because Monroe was to be the only Bill on stage) and Tex Logan. It was at this time that Ralph Rinzler had begun managing Monroe's career and a resulting rennisance was underway, which in no small way helped Bill attract younger, more progressive pickers. The most amazing cut from this period would have to be "Wayfaring Stranger" with a completely impromtu instrumental call-and-answer on Bill's break.

This disc, along with the Doc Watson duet (also on Smithsonian Folkway) and the Bear Family box sets of Monroe's Decca recordings are about all a bluegrass fan will ever need for a complete catalog of The Father of Bluegrass' genius.

This is really great stuff - Bill Monroe in his prime, singing and playing with passion and doing it well. This is good, traditional bluegrass played the way it was meant to be heard - live - and sounds far removed from the homogenized contemporary sound of nowadays. Every song is a keeper. Recommended highly.