22 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Succinct and ecumenical, January 1, 2003
Lives of the Saints
Richard McBrien
McBrien's compilation of saints for each day covers a multitude of canonized and non-canonized people. He also offers saints who are recognized by the Anglican/Episcopalian, Lutheran and Greek Orthodox churches. His descriptions are short, comparatively with Butler's descriptions, but non-devotional. He includes in his short essays references to history, legend and myth. This book can exist along side other longer works and can offer some perspectives that others do not.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
62 of 82 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Once again, McBrien disappoints, June 19, 2001
Fr. Richard McBrien, a well-known dissenter in the Church he serves has, from the perspective of this reviewer, written yet another disappointment.
The book purports to be a "Lives of the Saints" -- an ever popular genre for many centuries. However, McBrien uses this book (as he did his previous "Lives of the Popes") to further his own agenda as a representative of the Catholic far left.
In the section devoted to explaining the history of "saints" and the process by which persons are declared "saints" in the Catholic Church, he manages to wave the banner of radical feminism, liberation theology, etc., citing almost exclusively representatives from the far left. This is his privilege -- but it detracts from the alleged purpose of the book.
In the section devoted to working through the Church Year, McBrien includes in his list of saints persons not affiliated with the Catholic Church, and in some cases, persons not affiliated with Christianity at all. (Mahatma Ghandi? A good and worthy man, to be sure, but his inclusion (as a Hindu mystic) in a book of Christian saints?) McBrien also manages to defame the memory of those saints with whom he personally disagrees, the most noteworthy example being St. Pius X. Further, he repeats the same tired anti-Catholic attacks against Pope Pius XII and his alleged "complicity" and "silence" during the Second World War.
I grudgingly gave this book 2 stars because of McBrien's recognition of other religious bodies who have a Calendar of Saints and his inclusion of some of those in his list. However, he is inconsistent in his mention of these, which I found troubling. (Either discuss/include all or none).
A warning to Catholic readers (and I am not a Roman Catholic): As previously stated, the book DOES contain biographies of Orthodox, Anglican, and Lutheran saints -- some of whom would not be considered saints by Catholics. This book does NOT represent biographical sketches of the saints in the Roman Calendar -- a fact which, considering its Catholic author, should have been made more clear.
To summarize, McBrien has taken a familiar religious genre, and used it to further his agitations against his own faith tradition. To me, not the most honest of approaches.
I was quite disappointed with this effort.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
40 of 54 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Flashy presentation - but a huge disappointment, January 9, 2002
By A Customer
Disappointing is the only way to describe this book. Despite its potential - fine quality pages, saints for every day of the year, plus additional information on Church history and spiritual movements within the Church -this book simple failed to deliver for what I was looking for - daily readings on the saints that might be interesting, provoking, and inspiring.
Instead I found this to be yet another in a long list of saint books that provides for the most part a very dry and hurried account of dates and accomplishments - squeezed into a paragraph or two for many saints. Worse is reading a whole page on a saint without finding anything remotely interesting. After awhile you guess what is going to be written. I.E. "spent time helping the poor, reforming prostitutes..."
Spare yourself these boring accounts that I found quite biased and inaccurate at times. (This is not a shot at the author - I just happen to be familiar with much literature on a few saints and can easily spot inaccuracies).
For an exceptional book on saints, check out on amazon 'Voices of the Saints'.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No