Most Helpful Customer Reviews
21 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Another View of Life in the Universe, December 23, 2007
This review is from: The Living Cosmos: Our Search for Life in the Universe (Hardcover)
As a professional biologist (for what that is worth) I am reasonably certain that earth is not the only abode of life. Earth is, however, the only example we have at present. Unfortunately, a number of writers, both scientific and non-scientific, have waxed enthusiastic about not only life on other planets, but technologically advanced life (the stuff of science fiction), which is much more problematic. Still, although I am highly skeptical about advanced technological civilizations within hailing distance (Ward and Brownlee in their book "Rare Earth" added to that skepticism), the thought of alien biological systems has certainly intrigued me.
Now Chris Impey has written a bit more optimistic tome in "Living Cosmos" and, while he has not totally convinced me (I am now somewhere in between Ward and Brownlee and Impey on this issue), the book is certainly fascinating. Impey also has a good sense of humor and does not take himself as seriously as some writers on the subject.
Based on the two books (and a few others) that I have read on the subject I think that the main problem is that civilizations may not be as long-lived as we would like. Thus we have not only a spatial problem (the nearest star is over 4 light years away and it is not a good candidate for a planet with life on it, as is true of most of the stars within several hundred light years), but a temporal one as well. First the technological civilization has to arise and then it has to stay in existence long enough for us to pick up its electromagnetic output and at a point when we can do so. Messages beamed at us that arrived in 1066 (or even in 1946)would not be readable by us. Also if such civilizations were a dime a dozen (something Impey does not imply) we would have heard from them by now.
Still there must be earth-like planets with multi-cellular carbon-based life, or even non earth-like planets with life that we might not even recognize. These would be fascinating for a biologist to study. Life on earth is weird enough and it would be very interesting to find out how it had evolved on other planets! Impey has elegantly presented the history of and evidence for and against the idea of extra-terrestrial life, including all the blind alleys like Lowell's illusions about Mars and the "face" on Mars, as well as the "cells" in a Martian meteorite. He has done this I think without getting too attached to his own ideas. I think that I can agree with most, if not all, of his conclusions. I especially like his statement in the last chapter that science cannot give us meaning for existence. I wish more writers on science (as well as religion) were as open about this humbling fact - we don't know everything and it is unlikely that we ever will! Literal religions that adhere to such nonsense generally turn into oppression, but corrupted science may well do the same. The problem is not religion or science (they both have their functions) but the fact that most humans can become corrupted if given unlimited power and faith in the rightness of their world view.
A great book for anyone interested in the subject of life away from this ball of dirt on which we live!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Fascinating Journey Through Astrobiology, February 5, 2008
This review is from: The Living Cosmos: Our Search for Life in the Universe (Hardcover)
This book encompasses an absolute wealth of wide-ranging information, all centering on life in the universe. Starting with an overview of ancient Greek thought on the nature of the cosmos, the author presents a brief historical overview of astronomy and cosmology. Next, the evolution of the universe, including our galaxy, our solar system and our planet, is discussed leading to how life began and evolved on Earth. Since it is important to comprehend the nature and evolution of life on this planet to better understand life elsewhere, more than half of the book is devoted to the above issues. Past, present and possible future attempts to discover evidence of life in our solar system, the search for earthlike planets in other solar systems, the likelihood of intelligent life elsewhere in our galaxy and efforts to seek it out comprise just a subset of the vast number of exciting (astrobiology-related) topics covered in this fabulous book. The writing style is clear, authoritative, friendly and quite engaging. Although the material in this book is accessible to anyone, it may appeal the most to science buffs. One thing is certain: anyone reading this book is in for a treat!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Fine Introduction to Astrobiology, March 4, 2008
This review is from: The Living Cosmos: Our Search for Life in the Universe (Hardcover)
It used to be that we were pretty smug about how special we humans were - we were at the center of the universe with everything else circling us, and we were also lords of creation, far removed from all the animal kingdom. We are still special, no doubt, but just how special is harder to assess. That doesn't keep astrobiologists from trying. Astrobiology is the study of life in space, and has been criticized for being all about stuff we don't even know exists. Life seems to crowd into just about every niche in our own world, but elsewhere, it's just too hard to say right now, but it is not too early to ask good questions and think about how to get answers. In _The Living Cosmos: Our Search for Life in the Universe_ (Random House), Chris Impey, a professor of astronomy, has laid out the history of our understanding of cosmology, and has summarized the intelligent speculation that scientists have brought on a peculiar realm of inquiry. His book is clearly written, covering even difficult cosmology in jocular, vivid analogies.
Guesswork about extraterrestrial life has continued for centuries, but we do now have evidence from different fields that the existence of extraterrestrial life may not simply be speculation. For one thing, we know that there are indeed planets orbiting other suns. Impey spends a chapter describing just how astronomers have spotted these planets. There is looking outside the solar system, and then there is looking at our own planet with a view to seeing what life on it is really like. We take for granted the plants that get energy from the sun, and the animals like ourselves that get energy from those plants, but only recently has it become clear that even on Earth, things don't always have to be that way. "Extremophiles" is the term we use for microbes that can live in extreme environments, though as Impey points out, that's an anthropocentric term, because these "extreme" environments are normal for those microbes, and our own environment would be extreme to them; and anyway, given the original microbes that started life billions of years ago, we ourselves are descendants of microbes that thrived in inferno-type heat. Extreme living situations we know from our own Earth can be just the place for certain microbes to live, but can it be (as in our case) that on other worlds they can be a foundation for evolution to build more complicated animals? And if those more complicated animals have evolved intelligence, Where Are They? This is the great question posed by Enrico Fermi. If there are plenty of other worlds which have evolved intelligence, and plenty of time during which the intelligent beings could have visited us or sent us a message, what does it mean that this has yet to happen? Impey proceeds from considering the Fermi paradox to an overview of the famous Drake Equation, which calculates the possibility of intelligent life elsewhere, and would give an accurate percentage chance, if we just knew all the variables. We are learning some of them, but there are still too many mysteries. No one knows.
Nonetheless, we cannot help thinking about life out there, and hunting for it, especially via the SETI project looking for radio signals from extraterrestrial broadcasters. Buckminster Fuller wrote, "Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're not. In either case, the thought is staggering." The ancient Greeks speculated about life in other parts of the universe, and so do we, only we are doing it though our culture's scientific lenses. "Is there a God?" used to be the great philosophical question, to which almost everyone has an answer and no one can prove that the answer is correct. "Is there life elsewhere?" has become in some ways more pertinent to our times, because at least to that profound question there might someday be a scientific answer. In the continuing silence, however, we have only our questions, questions which, as Impey reminds us, tell us more about ourselves than about any other life forms out there.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|