From Publishers Weekly
Manfred's latest chronicle of the prairie territory called Siouxland (after No Fun on Sunday ) is an earthy, epic novel focusing on an Iowa farm family from 1884 to 1966. The initial chapters are slow going, not for lack of incident, but because the reader is bombarded with too much detail. The story does not develop narrative momentum until the marriage of Tunis Freyling and Clara Shortridge, each of whom keeps a secret from the other: in his case, a violent temper; in hers, a family history of incest. Their secrets turn out to be their legacy. Manfred's strength is his dialogue. His ear for natural and archaic speech is employed to good effect since the Freylings are a family of raconteurs, relentlessly digging up their pasts in a hermetic milieu. Outside events rarely intrude; two world wars and the Great Depression hardly affect them. The lengthy narrative could have benefited with some pruning. The dialogue is often verbose and the style clunky ("She smiled funny at him"). But readers who persevere eventually will find themselves caught up in the individual and collective struggles of the Freyling clan.
Copyright 1992 Reed Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
From Library Journal
Manfred's offering is a highly unsatisfying, episodic tale of four generations of dysfunctional family life in the American Midwest. Tunis and Clara Freyling started married life keeping secrets. His was that he had once killed a man in a fit of anger; hers was that incest and asthma ran in her family. They spend their marriage, and the reader spends the novel, looking for these traits in their eight children. And finding them. As the eight children reach adulthood, they're each given their own turn as central character, but nothing holds these diverse tales together. Some of the individual stories have potential, but Manfred's storytelling never really engages the reader. Not recommended.
- Debbie Bogenschutz, Cincinnati Technical Coll.Copyright 1992 Reed Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.