Customer Reviews

Lizzie Bright and the Buckminster Boy (Newbery Honor Book)

5 star:		(37)
4 star:		(8)
3 star:		(5)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

"From so simple a beginning endless forms most beautiful and most wonderful have been, and are being evolved."
--Charles Darwin, THE ORIGIN OF SPECIES

"Like angels appearing in the sky,
whales are proof of God."
--Cynthia Rylant, THE WHALES

Because it is based upon a series of true, race-related events in Maine during the early 1900s, LIZZIE BRIGHT AND THE BUCKMINSTER BOY might make you think of Karen Hesse's WITNESS. Several of the "good guy" characters--Mrs. Carr and the elder Mrs. Hurd, for example--have a charm reminiscent of the idiosyncratic folk in BECAUSE OF WINN-DIXIE. But, because of the depth of the evil behind the tragic real events upon which the fictional story of Lizzie and Turner is built, the feelings of despair and anger with which we're left evoke memories of such books as MISSISSIPPI TRIAL, 1955 and TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD.

The enchanting Lizzie Bright Griffin, a girl of great strength and few words, belongs to the youngest of many generations of African Americans who have called Malaga Island home.

"Lizzie held close against her grandfather as the people of Malaga Island came out from the pine woods, gathered around their preacher on the shore to hear what had been said. Before they turned, Lizzie felt her grandfather ebb as though his soul were passing out of him, the way the last waves of a falling tide pass into still air and are gone. "She took a deep breath, and she wasn't just breathing in the air. She breathed in the waves, the sea grass, the pines, the pale lichens on the granite, the sweet shimmering of the pebbles dragged back and forth in the surf, the fish hawk diving to the waves, the dolphin jumping out of them.
"She would not ebb.
"Then she turned with her grandfather to tell the gathering people of Malaga that times had moved on, and they would have to leave their homes."

Across the water, on the mainland, Turner is the new kid in town. And even worse--from his perspective--he's the new minister's son.

"Turner Buckminster had lived in Phippsburg, Maine, for almost six whole hours.
"He didn't know how much longer he could stand it."

Here, as with the fight over the towers in Elaine Konigsburg's THE OUTCASTS OF 19 SCHUYLER PLACE, the root of conflict involves money and property values. Phippsburg's shipbuilding industry is dying, and the local "boys with the bucks" reckon that tourism may be the source of future prosperity if only the "less desirable" portion of the community can be run out of town.

" 'Would you look at that monkey go? Look at her go. She climbing down or falling?' Deacon Hurd watched the last leap to the ground. 'Sheriff Elwell, I believe she thought you might shoot her.'
" 'Wouldn't have been any trouble, Mr. Hurd. One less colored in the world.' "

The character who is most difficult to decipher in this story of Turner's coming of age is his father. Reverend Buckminster was hired by the church leadership and is supposed to be serving God. However, he is being pulled in various directions: by the white community, by his own knowledge and conscience (or sometimes lack thereof), and by the beliefs of the maturing son he apparently loves, albeit in a stiff, 1912 Congregationalist ministerial fashion.

"And suddenly, Turner had a thought that had never occurred to him before: he wondered if his father really believed a single thing he was saying.
"And suddenly, Turner had a second thought that had never occurred to him before: he wondered if he believed a single thing his father was saying."

Reverend Buckminster is but one of several characters who end up throwing Turner a curveball.

The innocent, against-all-odds friendship that develops between Turner and Lizzie repeatedly caused me shivers, delight, and despair. It is first among the many reasons why LIZZIE BRIGHT AND THE BUCKMINSTER BOY is an entertaining and important piece of YA historic fiction. (...)

Having finally finished, "Lizzie Bright and the Buckminster Boy", I see now that the 2005 Newbery year was one filled with books for older child readers. Whether those readers are into racism or autism, the subject matter of the winners was particularly complex and mature. And in none of these winners is the subject more mature than in "Lizzie Bright". Basing this tale on the true events that occurred on Malaga Island, just off the coast of Maine, the story is a thoughtful look at the meaning of racism, friendship, human connection, and loss. It's not going to strike the kids who read it as a cheery devil-may-care book. But its magnificent writing keeps it from becoming another "Kira-kira" sob-fest. In any case, it's the kind of story that'll give you reason enough to stop, think, and consider.

According to Turner Buckminster's calculations, he was in his new home of Phippsburg, Maine for approximately fifteen minutes shy of six hours when he realized that, "he didn't know how much longer he could stand it". For one thing, he's the son of the town's new minister. And when you're the minister's son you're expected to be the soul of virtue. Turner's not a bad kid, but he has a heck of a way of getting into trouble. It's only when he escapes to the seacoast and meets Lizzie Bright Griffin that things start to look up. Lizzie's one of the black people living on the tiny island of Malaga, just off the coast of Phippsburg. It's a poor community (this is 1912, after all), but they get by. Unfortunately, the town's been losing money and it seems the Buckminsters have been hired by the city's fathers to help them in their goal of ridding Malaga of its inhabitants so as to set it up as a tourism site. That means throwing Lizzie and all her neighbors off the only home they've ever known. As Turner comes to terms with what it means to shrug off the scandalized eyes of the townspeople, as well as his parents' disapproval, he learns that for all the sorrows life may hand you, there can sometimes be salvation in the blink of a whale's mysterious eye.

Now there's some pretty heavy-handed subject matter going on here. You have perfectly nice little old ladies and young lively black kids being carted off to insane asylums (1912 insane asylums at that). You have several major characters die, usually off-camera, without so much as a howdy-doo. You have evil presented as godliness (topical considering the times in which we live), and the good of the almighty dollar aligned with God's supposed will. And that's not even touching on the racism issues, the human rights issues, and the rights children have in the eyes of the law. This is a book about bullies and how one stands up to them. I think what I really loved about "Lizzie Bright" was that Schmidt never took the easy road out. There aren't any miracles here or unexpected changes of heart (save one, but it's believable). People in this book are a set of contradictions, but for all that they do bad things they may not always be bad people per say. Bad things happen to good people, and they happen a lot. If you don't want your kids to know this, then you may as well grab the nearest Dick and Jane compendium and pretend that history never happened. But if you want to give them a well-informed, sometimes dark, but always interesting novel to peruse, this is it.

Now I did have some qualms here and there. There's nothing I hate more than an author/filmmaker/playwright/etc. who relies on that old "magical-black-friend" motif. You know the one I'm talking about. You'll find it in any story where an uptight white person meets someone of a different race and suddenly gets in touch with the earth/their feelings/what's really important/and so on. And there is a bit of that here. There's also the fact that there's rarely a black person in this book who comes off as anything but saintly. I like my characters to have a little depth to them. A little good and bad. But here the blacks sort of fall under the "victim" banner and never leave it. I wish they had as much complexity as, say, Turner's preacher father, but there doesn't seem to be much chance of that. Still, Lizzie's okay. She's kind of a likable version of that gawdawful "Ida B" (another children's book that came out in 2004 and that you should avoid at all costs). Lizzie gets mad at inappropriate times and she's never as nice to Turner as she should be, so when I say that the African-Americans in this tale never show enough depth, I'm excluding the title character. Lizzie's a fascinating character, and one that you wish you saw more of.

This is a book to spark some highly hepped up debates. You may well find yourself shaking with anger on one page and sighing with infinite relief on the next. Schmidt really defines himself here as one of the finest children's authors living today. When you read the line of a character who asks, "So, Turner Buckminster III, when you look through the number at the end of your name, does it seem like you're looking through prison bars?", you cannot help but smile. Perhaps this book will not be remembered as Schmidt's best, though. I have a feeling that as an author he'll have a lot more to say to the children of the world. Let's hope they're bright enough to listen.

Turner Buckminster, late of Boston, is the son of First Congregational's new pastor and doesn't feel welcome in Phippsburg, Maine. When the townies taunt him for his poor batting skills at an impromptu baseball game, he fantasizes about "lighting out for the Territories." Then he meets Lizzie Bright Griffin, an independent Malaga Island girl who improves his baseball, takes him rowing on the bay, and introduces him to the wonders of her island and its natural surroundings. Just off the coast of Phippsburg, her island is an historically black community that the town citizens plan to forcibly remove-in order to make way for the tourist trade.

The geographical (the wild Maine coast) and historical (circa 1910) settings of this novel are integral components of the story; Turner and his father discuss Darwin's Origin of the Species, while Lizzie shares her island refuge with her friend. As a punishment for fighting with local bullies, Turner is forced to play the organ for Mrs. Cobb, a crotchety old neighbor. Later, he and Lizzie form an unusual friendship with her. The inhabitants of Malaga Island are forced to leave, and things become desperate for Lizzie when her grandfather dies-she is sent to an institution for the feeble-minded in faraway Pownal. (Anyone who doesn't "fit in" is sent there by the Phippsburg deacons.) When Turner inherits the old woman's house and attempts to move Lizzie into it, tensions escalate, climaxing in a Buckminster family tragedy. In the background of this turmoil, there is the beauty of the natural world, illustrated by the majesty of the gray whales that cruise offshore, the wheeling gulls overhead, and the bracing fragrance of the coastal pines.

Schmidt creates sensitive and believable characters that are capable of unexpected acts. He weaves a story rich in historical detail, moral complexity, and regional character that will cause readers to consider the interrelationships between man and nature, young and old, tradition and change. This is a book written for children and young adults about love, loss, and transcendence, and the evolution of natural history and human compassion. It is well-deserving of its Newbery and Printz Honors for 2005. Schmidt reminds us that as nature evolves, so do human beings, emotionally , spiritually, and intellectually.

I teach both children's lit and young adult lit at my university, so I read hundreds of children's books a year. This is the best book to come along for older children in quite awhile; I simply can't fault any aspect of it--style, character development, pacing, plot, honesty--it's all here.

As has been pointed out by a couple of other reviewers, it is simply shocking that Kira Kira won the Newbery while this book was a runner-up. When I was grousing about that fact to a librarian, she told me that the Newbery is often won by a compromise book, because the better books have such passionate devotees on the committee that they cancel each other out. I can't help but think that's what happened this year with Lizzie Bright and Al Capone Does My Shirts, both of which are far superior to Kira Kira.

The worst thing about Kira Kira is its irritating writer's-workshop postmodern minimalist style--that and I don't think actual children will like the book at all. At my own public library it has languished on the shelf for months, checked out only once--by me. Lizzie Bright, on the other hand, is not only always out, but has a waiting list of potential child readers.

If you are a parent or a teacher, order this book immediately. It is destined to be a classic, a real jewel in a sea of mediocrity.

This book is clearly a quiet winner. It is one that slowly catches your attention, and then it will not let it go. The word that keeps entering my mind is quiet. There is racism, religion, and other "ugly" elements to this book yet all of these issues seem somehow quiet to me.

I would have liked the friendship of the boy and Lizzie to unravel a bit longer, but I did find it believable. The more I read, the desire to read more became louder. I definately think this is a book that is meant more for older adolescents, but even sixth graders could enjoy it with minimal guidance. Overall, I want to read more from this author and I hope to see more books like this one out.

Gary Schmidt has created one of the best young adult books to hit the market in the last several years. Recognized with the Prinz Award for Young Adult Literature and a Newberry Honor Book, the story is not only engaging and serious, but also extremely well written.

The story revolves around a friendship relationship between a white boy and a black girl. The white boy has never talked to a black person before, but he recognized some very special qualities in Lizzie Bright and they befriend each other.

Unfortunately, the boy was the new Minister's son, and in this setting in Maine, there was not much tolerance for the interaction of blacks and whites. In fact, the white attitude in the village is such that it reaches levels of pure prejudice and hurtful actions to many in the town, not just to blacks.

The story is truly wondrous in its use of the landscape and its incisive look inside the minds of two young people trying to deal with a prejudice they really do not understand. It is truly a wonderful read and shows a lot about out society today. It is recommended for all readers over the age of 13.

Mr. Schmidt has created a true gem in 'Lizzie Bright and the Buckminster Boy'. This book should take its place on the shelf of classics for young adults.

The story of the friendship of Turner and Lizzie is so well crafted. The reader may be reminded of the friendship between Jim Burden and Antonia Shimerda in Willa Cather's 'My Antonia'. The sense of endearment between the two main characters does reach this quality level. The characterizations of Turner's parents, Lizzie's grandfather and others are believable and effective. Even the behavior of the town fathers of Phippsburg is convincing, especially that of Mr. Stonecrop, although so shocking and reprehensible. Through those characters, the reader is invited to inhabit the perverse sensibilities of a different time.

Mr. Schmidt also excels in setting descriptions. One feels a part of the Maine backdrop, even to the point of almost feeling those salty ocean breezes that appeal so much to Turner.

This book would make a wonderful gift for any older child and discussion of the story's elements could be the subject of many great dinner table conversations. Enjoy!

LIZZIE BRIGHT AND THE BUCKMINSTER BOY will be many things to its readers: a contemplation on racism, religion, and evolution, all mixed up in a story about friendship between two young teenagers, that had they been older, would be a romance, one forbidden in 1912 Maine (and not looked on too kindly in 2005, either).

Based on a true incident, in which the lily-white town fathers of Phippsburg pushed out the poor blacks from adjoining Malaga Island, in hopes of bringing tourism to the area, this is a powerful book. Not only does it illuminate history, it raises questions in children's minds about the so-called wisdom of their elders. As Turner learns to think for and stand up for himself and what is right, so all children must.

Gary D. Schmidt is a fine writer (I particularly enjoyed the wind in this book, a living creature). I hope to read many more of his books.

I thought the book was good though I have read better. It was easy to be pulled into the book and was a quick read. I liked how Turner was able to accept Lizzie for who she was instead of being influenced by the church's view of the Malagan people. The fact that he stood up for their protection which endangered his father's job proved that he knew what was right. Turner learned some valuable lessons from the people of Phippsburg, Maine. The ending was abrupt but there really would not have been a better way to end it without going on and on. It allowed you to think and imagine what may have happened if it would have continued. The metaphores used in the course of the book were also easy to understand. Over all, the book was well writen.

This book is a very well-written, very entertaining book set in 1912 about a minister's son who moves to Phippsburg, a small town in Massachusetts, when his dad is asked to pastor the church in that small seaside town. When he arrives, our 13 year old protagonist doesn't get along with any of the other kids from that town and ends up befriending a young girl who lives on a nearby island called Malaga.

The problem is that the people of Phippsburg are trying to evict all persons living on that island because they're black. They quickly convince their new pastor to back them despite his weak protests. The protagonist stands up against the town's people and his father and supports the inhabitants of Malaga. How well-written is the book? It won the Newberry Honor and it's not hard to see why EXCEPT for the consistently negative portrayal of Christians in this book. Almost all of the people of the church, especially the corrupt deacons, support the removal of the Malaga denizens. While it's true that Turner's father in a weak way does not want to back the rich, powerful people of the town in their eviction of the inhabitants of Malaga, it almost seems in spite of his Christianity and not because of his Christianity.

Add to this the surreptitious reading by our protagonist and his father of Darwin's Origin of Species which they agree with each other would anger the church's deacons and you have another well-written story in which the bad guys are those close-minded, hypocritical Christians and the good guys are those who question the status quo.

I will acknowledge that the author does not seem to say the church members are bad because of their beliefs, but he also doesn't seem to say that our protagonist and a few other people make the right choices because of their beliefs either. In fact, church going just seems to be some kind of custom rather than an exercise that helps one to learn what's right and what's wrong. Jesus clearly taught us that we are to love our neighbors as ourselves and that everyone is our neighbor regardless of what they look like and where they come from. It would have been nice if the author had put that in.