Amazon.com
A shy 9-year-old farm boy in rural America, Stephen Cline is walking near his house and happens upon the fresh scene of a crime. His older brother is apparently involved and is immediately suspected by the local sheriff, but young Stephen covers for him. And soon Stephen, apparently traumatized, refuses to speak at all. His family is puzzled, his mother cares enough to take him to visit psychiatrists, yet somehow no one ever makes the connection between the recent tragic news in the neighborhood and Stephen's total aversion to talking. Even at school, Stephen's refusal to talk is somehow taken in stride by both teachers and students.
Despite some glaring flaws in logic and other puzzling aspects to the plot (which is said to be based on a true story), there are some commendable aspects to this film. Bonnie Bedelia turns in a credible performance as Stephen's aching mother, and Dan Hedaya strikes the right notes as a stern but helpful psychiatrist. Young Marc Donato has a very expressive face and curly hair, and while he occasionally resembles a juvenile Harpo Marx, he is able to generate both pathos and mirth. But despite performances that make the family tension at the heart of the story seem realistic, the story itself doesn't always live up to the individual performances. --Robert J. McNamara