Most Helpful Customer Reviews
36 of 37 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
It's very orange!, October 22, 2009
= Fun:5.0 out of 5 stars
This review is from: Logitech Xbox 360 Wireless Guitar Controller (Accessory)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
That was my first thought upon unboxing Logitech's Xbox 360 Wireless Guitar Controller. The second thing I noted, as I lifted it out, was that it is very heavy. This is no cheap plastic toy! This is a solid, well-constructed, replica guitar. And the quality shows.
Inside the box, the guitar is well protected for shipping with bubble wrap and cardboard spacers. Of note is the fact that this is a one piece unit. This completely eliminates the connectivity issues between the neck and body, as sometimes seen in guitar controllers that come boxed as two pieces. The guitar measures 33.75 inches from tip to base, with a slightly larger body than my Guitar Hero World Tour guitar, which measures only 31.25 inches in length (see the photo I posted with this review). This extra length pushes the fret buttons up a little bit, but I did not find this to be an issue. I store my guitars on a stand, but if you use a guitar bag or case, be aware that it might not fit. Rounding out the included accessories are a user manual, a quality strap, some batteries to get you up and playing fast, and an adapter for older style Xbox 360 headsets.
IMPRESSIONS
The guitar itself is modeled after Guitar Hero guitars, with the raised fret buttons and the neck slider feature. Keep this in mind if you are someone who prefers the look of the Rock Band guitars, with their in-line fret buttons. The chrome detailing, including tuning pegs and bridge, and use of real screws in the white pick guard lends an authentic look, effectively disguising the Start (bridge) and Star Power buttons (pickups) while keeping them functional. There is even an authentic looking nut between the headstock and the neck. The Star Power button sits right under the ball of your hand, so it's easy to press down on while strumming (you can also still rock Star Power with a neck tilt). The strum bar is the best I have ever seen on a guitar controller. It has exactly the right tactile feel, and is responsive yet quiet. One of my fret buttons makes a bit of a clickety-clack when I hit it, but I am hoping this goes away as it wears in. Overall, this is a quiet guitar, allowing for more enjoyment of the music.
COMPATIBILITY
I have tested this guitar with the following Xbox 360 games that I own:
* Band Hero: Yes
* Guitar Hero Van Halen: Yes
* Guitar Hero 5: Yes
* Guitar Hero World Tour: Yes
* Guitar Hero III: Yes
* Guitar Hero II: Yes
* Rock Band The Beatles: Yes
* Rock Band 2: Yes
* Rock Band: Yes
CONCLUSION
This is a quality guitar controller that I would recommend to any serious gamer who wants to add authenticity to their music games. It is a joy to play.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
34 of 37 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A love affair that didn't last..., October 1, 2009
= Fun:4.0 out of 5 stars
This review is from: Logitech Xbox 360 Wireless Guitar Controller (Accessory)
I love Rock Band (RB) and play it with my friends often. We're very happy with MadCatz wireless 2-strum bass, but haven't found a nice upgrade replacement for the guitar. With an entry price of $200 and no chance to test it out in a store (and no reviews), I took a chance & pulled the trigger on this beaut.
First, it's a gorgeous, balanced and a substantial piece of equipment. I was wary not to dent the walls or my friends while walking around with it. The strum bar is perfect! (no noise, quick spring-back) I also love the hidden and easy location of hitting the back button with your strum hand (something RB guitars have never done well), as well as the hidden start button below the whammy bar. It's not full-size, but is substantially larger than the regular plastic guitars that come with Guitar Hero (GH). In fact, I fell in love with everything about this guitar... except the actual fret buttons.
The fret buttons are the exact same size as those that come on standard GH guitars, but they're further up, so your fingers are at more of an angle to hit them. The wood fret board is much wider/larger than the plastic versions, so it's also much harder to reach around to connect with the actual buttons. This is where RB buttons are much easer to hit, though I personally prefer the protruding GH buttons in general, for this piece, they don't work. In fact, several times, without removing my finger from the buttons, it would not register a chord depending on which part of the button was being pressed. Instead of my scores getting better over time, they were always lower. It may be something others can learn to adapt to, but it was a deal-breaker for me (after 7 hours experience) and I have to send it back. My friends had the same problem - we all loved the look, feel, strum & design of this guitar, but the fret buttons failed us.
So, what could have been so wonderful (a 5-star love affair), is being sent back (down to 3-stars). I'll patiently wait for the next upgrade installment (deep purple color, please!) and continue to play on my multitude of puny plastic toy guitars until then.
[For background as we all have personal preferences, my current favorite controller is the GH-3 guitar (got it with Aerosmith). The RB standard controllers are good for bass, but their strum bar & back button locations don't compare. I played GH 5 & RB Beatles while testing this controller.]
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Rock Out, November 19, 2009
= Fun:5.0 out of 5 stars
This review is from: Logitech Xbox 360 Wireless Guitar Controller (Accessory)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
200 bucks for a fake guitar? What!
That was my first thought (one that I think can be easily overcome by how nice this guitar is) but the next hurdle is a tough one (it's orange, no, it's bright orange, I'm overcome by the sheer orangeness of it).
That said, the important question is... is it worth it?
Short answer? It depends.
It is easily the best fake guitar you can get right now (if you can overlook the orangeness!)
Also (one huge plus) I must mention the battery life, I've used this guitar for possibly 60-80 hours and still using the same battery.
I have a real guitar (ESP Kirk Hammit) and the fact that this is a real weight and real feeling guitar, I could not be happier with this aspect (though it may turn some off).
If this were a real guitar, I would say "It plays fast", meaning the fret notes are very easy to hit, smooth like butter. Easily the best feeling you can get with a fake guitar.
The strum bar is nice (but NOT silent), and the whammy rocks.
Cons:
It's somewhat of an indulgence due to its price (but if you play 10 hours a month, it comes out to about 2 dollars an hour for the fun, if that's worth it to you, than sure, grab it).
If you play 10 hours a week, that's over 500 hours a year and less than 50 cents an hour (which means you SHOULD buy it). We all know how bad a fake plastic guitar is and how long they last (if you have kids good luck having it last over a year or two).
The BIGGEST con of course is that the xbox version is BRIGHT ORANGE! BRIGHT ORANGE! lol
You'll get over it (somewhat).
Pros:
Best Fake guitar. I even put a real guitar strap on it (Planet Waves Rock Star).
Feels real (the weight of it is to be appreciated).
Responsive (rarely do I miss a note with this thing, it is just so smooth, and very hard to go back to using the super light fake plastic guitar (GHWT or RB2).
Looks Amazing (aside from the ORANGENESS) from the nice maple neck to the very nicely done bridge. this thing just looks real. I also love the d-pad.
This thing just makes playing these games all the better. If something happened to mine I'd buy it again (and hope and pray a black version comes out or someone figures out a way to get rid of the orangeness!)
What Would Be Cool? If the buttons had an option where you could work on building your calluses while playing guitar hero (so you can play your real guitar).
Also (as an aside) yes this guitar works on guitar hero and rock band (I've played every game quite thoroughly with this guitar and they all work flawlessly).
Do check it out (obviously if you only play rock band or guitar hero 3 hours every 3 months, this is not for you, but if you play every weekend or a couple hours a day, do get it, it makes it that much more fun.)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|