Customer Reviews

London Labour and the London Poor, Vol. 3

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Henry Mayhew, founder of Punch magazine, wrote this four-volume sociological classic during the 1850's. If you are at all interested in the Victorian era, in British history, in London, or in urban history in general, this is a must-read. The Penguin version is abridged and is a distillation of the "best" of the multiple-volume set. This distillation is itself over 500 pages, so imagine the impact of the entire set! The utter destitution of the London poor is set out in such vivid detail than one cannot help being shocked at the conditions human beings were forced to live in in the greatest city of its time. The only fault I find with this book is Mayhew's occasional lapses into preaching. Otherwise a fine book

Henry Mayhew, having created this delightful encyclopoedia of humanity, has probably been ripped off more frequently than any writer since Shakespeare. His characters are so animated they have jumped full-fleshed from the pages of his books into the works of many another humorist or novelist, and we all owe more to him than we can know.

While the living conditions suffered by the poor were truly deplorable, Mayhew might have enjoyed the company of street people more than that of his peers. He put so much life into his characters we can see them, hear them, smell them. I only wonder what the street people thought about Mr. Mayhew, the journalist who bought them beers,inveigled invitations to tea, listened tirelessly to their stories. Mayhew is neither sentimental nor brutal, but rather a true and tolerant humourist, and I believe that, for all the misery depicted, his work was undertaken with great, and contagious, joy.

This review refers to the Penguin Classics edition of Henry Mayhew's 'London Labour and the London Poor' which is an abridged version of the original four volume version published in 1851-52.

Though Henry Mayhew wrote several novels, his name is primarily remembered as the author/complier of this journalistic work 'London Labour and the London Poor.' The present selection gives the best part of the original four volume book, which captures exactly what the title says -- London labour and the poverty-stricken people living there.

The selction includes some figures or statistics about the working class people, such as the estimated amount of money these workers gain every day (and meagre one), but the most interesting part is the first-hand records about the ways of life of various lines of works in London, directly taken from the people engaged in these works.

The jobs (and some of them hardly deserve the name 'jobs') recorded here are, to name a few, street-sellers such as fried fish, watercresses, matches, baked potatoes, etc.; street-buyers such as old clothes or 'dust'; street-performers like 'conjurors,' musicians, or fire-eaters (with his own descriptions about how to eat fire), but the most fascinating is the records about boys (and some girls) who run away from parents, and lives in the street of London, who literally lives by begging or stealing.

Many interesting facts are recorded by Mayhew (or his assistants), directly from the persons the book deals with, and the original words spoken by there labourers are preserved as much as possible. To read, or to listen to them is one of the greatest merits of the book, for the languages of the interviewees retain the peculiar speeches you find in many Dickensian characters, and in fact you will realize that Dickens didn't exaggerate when he created Sam Weller.

And the London you see here is the London Charles Dickens knew. What did Jo in 'Bleak House' was sweeping in the street? Who gave that permission? What is the nature of 'the dust' you hear in 'Our Mutual Friend'? What was the regulations of the 'workhouse'? All these thing are answered in this vividly realized collections of the Victorian working class portraits.

This book is still a valuable source for anyone who is interested in Victorian period, and will be. Buy one now.

This review does not refer to the contents or substance of this abridgment of Henry Mayhew's classic study of the living conditions of the working classes in 19th Century London. This review refers entirely to the design and format of this new Bibliolife edition. Buyer beware - unless your eyesight is substantially better than 20/20, the book is literally unreadable. Although it claims to be an "enlarged print" reproduction of the original first edition typeface, it is simply a large, and expensive, paperback with font so small it is difficult to imagine that the font used in the original publication could possibly have been any smaller.

Knowing that other available copies were published by Penguin, which uses what I find to be an uncomfortably small font, I compared the size and weight of the Bibliolife edition to the Penguin version. The Bibliolife measured substantially larger in page size and was twice the weight. When I received the book, however, it turned out that approximately 40% of each page was blank bordering. To make matters worse, the page copy looked like it was badly mimeographed at Kinko's. The print was light and at times portions of letters were simply missing. The contrast between type and paper was also poor. All in all, any reader would find the average Penguin paperback a paragon of readability, and considerably less expensive.

To add insult to injury, Bibliolife, in a preface introducing its edition, claims to have undertaken an "important mission" in the "difficult task of re-creating" this work as an "attractive, readable, and affordable" book, and calls it's edition an "enlarged print" version. The publisher goes on to note, however, that "because of font variation" in the original book, it may not "technically qualify as 'large print'." Indeed.

What the reader is left with is a poorly printed, cheaply-produced publication which is in the public domain and exempt from copyright royalty fees. The savings in copyright fees has apparently not been passed on to the reader. In fact, the book retails for at least twice the cost of the average public domain paperback.

Save your money, your time, and your temper and look for a good used copy of the abridged paperback edition of this book by another publisher. Maybe then you'll get something approximating your money's worth. At the very least you will be able to actually read the text.

First of all, the subject matter is very engaging. The issue is that the pages are barely readable. This edition is a photocopy of the original and the actual image size is much smaller than the size of the book. Add to this that some pages are blurry and reading becomes a challenge. Every now and then, one page is blank, which shows the level of care which went into this edition. Mayhew deserves better treatment.

An old work that holds up -- Mayhew's a nonfiction Dickens historian. This seminal work really offers a glimpse into the past and paints how hard the poor had it back then.

When I was 12 I was browsing in old Leary's books in Phila and I came across the 4 volume addition of this as published by Dover. I bought it on a whim.This has become one of my favorite books. A true time machine.