Customer Reviews

Lonely Planet Southeast Asia: On a Shoestring (Shoestring Travel Guide)

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

I am currently (Oct 2010) travelling through Thailand with this book and I am very displeased with it - for reasons that are not Lonely Planet's fault, but you should be aware of anyway. Wherever I go (or NOT go due to lack of travel information), I feel that I know significantly less about the travel destiation than my fellow travellers. This book also does not put enough emphasis on some of the climate phenomenons around here (monsoon) with climate diagrams for example. For first-timers to the region, this can be a big problem.

This book is a compromise in so many ways, it has become really useless. I suggest to get the LP country guides instead, they tend to be excellent. I have the Thailand country guide on my Kindle and it is perfect for reading (and really light). The Kindle has its own set of problems though, like the legibility of maps.

What I suggest to do is to get the paperback version of the first country you travel to, then buy the next one in a bookstore in the country of visit (LP guides sell everywhere in Thailand), so you only carry around one book at a time. Or swap books with fellow travellers. Or get a Kindle and the electronic LP books, and get paper maps of the respective cities you travel to (tourist maps tend to be free everywhere). But stay away from this south-east asia guide.

I used to think that LP could do no wrong, but am definitely disappointed in this book. In full disclosure, I haven't even left for my trip yet but bought this book mostly for the planning aspect. I was hoping to find some suggested itineraries and good advice about what to cut out if you're short on time. Unfortunately this book is definitely lacking those qualities and is instead basically a list of the cheapest guest houses/ dorm hostels in each town in South East Asia.

The maps are also very confusing and not very helpful. There is one full page map of each country with EVERY possible city/ location marked on it (making it very difficult to find the noteworthy places, especially since almost everywhere has very similar names) and then very zoomed-in close up of individual cities. What's left out is probably what would be most useful-- maps of the various regions showing how these places relate to each other.

Most discouragingly, there is also no advice on what places/ side trips are most worthy of taking. All the other LP guides I've used have had sections including tips on "if you have 2 weeks, go ____ or ____, if you have 3 weeks try ________, for 6 weeks you can fit in ______, etc". I feel like this information is most useful for a book that covers all of SE Asia, rather than just listing every possible location as this one seems to do.

As the title says, relatively speaking LP have done a great job at fitting in ample info on so many places into a, relatively speaking, small book (the book is huge compared to a normal book, but compared to everything it has in it,it is small).

We found most of the information that we needed, plus more and the brief history of each place was actually really helpful as well as the customs etc section of each country. Most people assume they are the same in all of these countries, and while there certainly was a lot of repetition there are key differences that are very important and LP makes a good point of these.

The only complaints I have are that with it being written by different authors, some sections are 100x more useful than others. For example some of the authors had amazing information on transport which helped with budgeting and getting an idea of our different options and routes. Others had lists of companies to contact- most only by phone, which I am sure is more than useful when in the country, but was useless for pre planning with, which is what we were primarily using the book for. This was the same with sights covered- some authors focused on museums etc., others on outdoor things which meant we have had to supplement our reading with online research too (this would have been done anyway, but doing it while reading made it easy to see which authors were the history/museum buffs and which were the more adventurous). While this is one of the benefits of using LP in this case it was a definite downside for us more than it has been when using other LP books. It might sound like a small complaint, but if you're using it for pre planning as we are then it wont be too helpful for finer details. and you might not want to carry this huge thing around with you in your backpack to have the numbers etc provided when in the country when you can find these vendors quite easily when on the ground.

The other complaint is that, like with any large book, with extensive reading and fingering of pages sections begin to fall out. As I read through our list of countries sections from each country became loose. After 2 days of having a look through the book looked like it was years old. Again, not too much of a problem for us as we're only using it for pre-planning, but a big problem for someone who wants to carry it around for a few weeks/months in their backpack.

I was also surprised at how inaccurate some of the prices were, yes it was published last year, however with an increase of 100 - 150USD in some of the prices quoted in the book (and this is the official advertised prices through the same websites mentioned in the book) our original budgeting was WAY off. We always expect a slight difference as things are always changing, but we were shocked by a few that had big differences.

All in all, it is a good book for pre planning, but probably more useful for having with you on the road, but it is a bit of a brick to carry around if doing longer journeys like us.

definitely worth the money if you're visiting more than one country in the areas, otherwise get one of the country specific guides which is half the size and has triple the info.

I'm currently travelling through Indonesia with a few friends and we have found that prices for Indonesia are well out of date. We've had to add on 10,000-20,000rph to the prices of homestays, transport and restaurants especially in Bali and Lombok. Hopefully it will be more helpful throughout the rest of the southeast.

Great book very informative. It appears like the information was not updated from the last series. Just a few large color pictures were added.
If you want to save a few bucks buy the slightly older edition.

China Williams, et.al.'s SOUTHEAST ASIA ON A SHOESTRING is a 'must' take-along for any independent budget-minded traveler planning a trip to Southeast Asia. It covers everything from sightseeing and shopping to current events, provides itineraries for easy travel, and is a top reference packed with maps and specific detail.

As far as guidebooks to an entire region go, this is one of the best I've used. It was concise, well-organized, and up-to-date. That said, information about each city was limited due to the scope of the book, so don't make the mistake of feeling too dependent on it. Often the best guesthouses and restaurants I found were ones that weren't even mentioned!

This is just a great book, in fact it is amazing and anyone that want to travel to southeast asia should get it!
Awesome!

I bought Southeast Asia on a Shoestring by Lonely Planet to plan an upcoming trip. The book covers Thailand, Laos, Vietnam, Mynamar (Burma),East Timor, Cambodia, Singapore, Malaysia, Indonesia, and the Philippines in about 1004 pages. This book has very good information and specifics about each country such as a brief history and overview of each country, best time to travel, when popular holidays are, shopping and restarant suggestions, safety precauions, must-see sites, getting around town, etc. This book is better than the Frommer Southeast Asia book. They eahc have good country descriptions, but the Lonely Planet gudie has more information that the Frommer book (Frommers is about 654 pages long and does not include as many countries). A traveler can easily plan an itinerary of places to go and things to try to get a great experience. The Lonely Planet book features many hotels, which is nice(Frommers features costly resorts). The reader would assume that the hotels are inexpensive, but the Lonely Planet book does not offer prices. The hotels in the major cities seem to list their websites, so that the traveler can contact the email the hotel or preview the hotel on the Internet. I guess thta was the biggest drawback for me- the Lonely Planet book is very inconsistent in publishing the prices of what the listed hotels, restarants, taxis, etc. will likely be. Sometimes the price of something is mentioned but often the prices were omitted. This was the most disappointing thing about this book - I can't really make a budget of expenses.

i'm planning a trip to se asia in a few months, and this guide is very complete and informational. it is not a picture book - more of an almanac highlighting everything there is to see in most se asian countries. just a heads up in case you are expecting something different. i plan on taking a highlighter to this baby well before my trip to figure out all the places i need to visit before my trip is over.