Most Helpful Customer Reviews
45 of 53 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Crime and Punishment, May 31, 2001
This review is from: The Long Prison Journey of Leslie van Houten: Life Beyond the Cult (Northeastern Series on Gender, Crime, and Law) (Hardcover)
Writing a biography of a personal friend must be a very tricky business. Karlene Faith met famous Manson murderess Leslie Van Houten almost thirty years ago, and has proven an effective advocate for her eventual release. The relationship between the teacher and the reformed cult member is touching and very real, but it undermines this book as a chronicle of a criminal's transformation from delusional disciple to remorseful, decent soul. Rather than focus on Van Houten's thoughts and feelings during her three decades behind bars, Faith uses the book as an apologia and rationalization for the prisoner's choices and behavior when a very young woman. The author seems to have only a vague realization of the monstrousness of the crimes committed, and lays the blame squarely on the mastermind, exonerating her subject and casting her as a victim in the same mold as those who lost their lives. Van Houten herself seems to have a clearer view of her own culpability, and it would have been interesting to hear more about this from her own mouth. The book does cast a disturbing light on the inequity and gross politicization of the justice system. Van Houten's crimes, and her admitted participation in them, should allow for the imposition of a true life term, and so far the system seems intent on doing so. It's shocking to read, then, that all of the other prisoners on death row with Van Houten when the death penalty was suspended were released from prison within a few years. It seems that when no one is watching, the justice system plays by some very inept and unfair rules. Certainly Van Houten poses no further threat to society, while the prison system routinely ejects predators with murderous histories and no sign of reformation. Though thick with pages full of psychobabble and research into cult psychology, there are enough anecdotes in the book to humanize the subject and make it an interesting read. Van Houten does come across as an obvious candidate for legitimate parole. But Karelene Faith's blind approach to this polarizing subject may be the last thing Van Houten needs.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
19 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Where's the responsibility?, June 1, 2007
This review is from: The Long Prison Journey of Leslie van Houten: Life Beyond the Cult (Northeastern Series on Gender, Crime, and Law) (Hardcover)
I was pretty disappointed in this book. Karlene Faith relies on an overabundance of clichés and a meager sprinkling of insight into the character of Leslie Van Houten and Van Houten's involvement in the Manson murders. Although published in 2001, the book reads as if it might have been written thirty years ago, at the beginning of the feminist movement. Leslie and her fellow murderesses are given every consideration: they were victims of "cultivated femininity", they "never lost their innocence", they were so brainwashed they relinquished all control and thought; however, Faith contradicts herself when excusing Leslie's involvement in the Manson Family as, "...Although part of his inner circle, Leslie was never part of Manson's inner, INNER circle. She would lapse into thinking for herself...". So in one fell swoop, the author denies Leslie's culpability and recognizes it.
In spite of that, one gets the feeling that Leslie herself has taken on more responsibility for her involvement than the author gives credit for. What Leslie seems to recognize, which the author does not, is that the Manson murders branded themselves on the American psyche, and society demands a price be paid. The author becomes downright offensive when she coyly alludes to other murders and murderers since then who have not received the notoriety of the Manson girls, suggesting perhaps that we are being a tad unfair in having the audacity to remember the shock and horror of the Tate-LaBianca deaths.
The author spends much time on Charles Manson and his responsibility as leader of the "cult." What she forgets is that members were free to come and go, and various people DID walk away from Manson and his personality. Faith also takes pains to mark how the Manson girls are exceptional in their good behavior in prison, apparently without noting the irony that they were exceptional members of Manson's inner circle, and before that Van Houten was an exceptional student and twice prom queen. It makes me wonder if these women's ability to get along in the unnatural atmosphere of prison is linked to their ability to have gotten along in the bizarre world of Manson's philosophy...and just how well they would be able to integrate themselves outside of the rigidly controlled environment of prison should any of them meet another guru.
In the end, this book gives more insight into the author's embrace of victim ideology, and quite a bit less into the mindset and maturity of a major participant in the crime of the century. I cannot imagine this book helped Leslie Van Houten's case for parole.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
38 of 50 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
The Long Diatribe of Karlene Faith, August 23, 2003
This review is from: The Long Prison Journey of Leslie van Houten: Life Beyond the Cult (Northeastern Series on Gender, Crime, and Law) (Hardcover)
Two themes not touched on in the book: justice and individual responsibility.
"The parole board has shown a clear unwillingness to move beyond the crimes (Van Houten stabbed Mrs. La Bianca 14 times--feeling like a 'shark with it prey')" of Ms. Van Houten is the typical, absurd refrain throughout the book. The author, Ms. Faith, wonders if Van Houten "had actually been involved in the murders at all." She asserts that Van Houten is a "friend" (at one point Ms. Faith brings banana splits to the "charming" convicted murderers.) She goes on to state that the Manson girls were "generous gift givers: 'I was the recipient of the complete collection of Charles Manson's song lyrics.'" According to this book, what happened to Leslie Van Houten "could have happened to any trusting young woman." I could go on, but you get the idea.
A further absurdity in the book is the author's typical refrain that the real causes of crime are "poverty, racism and low wages" while (unwittingly?) stressing the nurturing, supportive, middle class background of all the killers involved.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|