Most Helpful Customer Reviews
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Now that the full series is published..., June 29, 2004
This review is from: The Lord of Castle Black (Viscount of Adrilankha, Book 2) (Hardcover)
The full VofA series (Paths of the Dead, Lord of Castle Black, and Sethra Lavode) has now been published. So I am submitting a new review. There is one thing you must know about this book: it is incomplete. If you buy this thinking it is one book of a trilogy, you will find it disappointing. Dozens of characters are brought in unintroduced and then left unresolved, and almost all of the plot threads are left hanging. But ... if you get the whole VofA series and read it as though it is one novel, you will probably not mind any of this. Because all the flaws have to do with this book being nothing but the middle section of a single story. And if you actually get the full story by reading the other books, that works. No one would read "The Two Towers" and attempt to treat it as a work in isolation from rest of The Lord Of The Rings. The same should be true of this book. This part of the full novel deals mainly with the the reunion of the four guardsmen and the backstory of Morrolan (who comes off as much more complex than the inscrutable and testy warrior-wizard of the Vlad books).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A true delight for fans of Paarfi, August 16, 2003
This review is from: The Lord of Castle Black (Viscount of Adrilankha, Book 2) (Hardcover)
Indeed, this is perhaps Paarfi's best one yet. The previous book, The Paths of the Dead, introduced the series, got us acquainted with the cast of characters, and pretty much stopped there. The Lord of Castle Black brings on the action and plot twists that many complained were lacking in the first book of the series. While I sympathize with these complaints, it must be kept in mind that Paths was merely the first act of this particular "play". I have been a huge fan of Brust since To Reign in Hell, and find his Paarfi novels as good as any of the Vlad series. I enjoy the sheer wordplay involved in the descriptions of both scene and action, and find the dialogue to be laugh-out-loud funny in parts. The Lord of Castle Black is a veritable feast of amusing asides, gripping action, and wonderful dialogue-all hallmarks of The Phoenix Guards and Five Hundred Years After. I do not wish to give any of the plot away, so I will merely say that it performs satisfactory twists throughout, and the end of the book finds the Viscount and the rest of the remarkable cast in situations that have me eagerly awaiting the next installment. I am sure that it would be a bit confusing to be thrown into the maelstrom of intrigues and power struggles contained in Lord without having read Paths. However, for those who wish to read a top-notch fantasy novelist at the top of his form, I can make no higher recommendation than The Lord of Castle Black.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Book 4 of the Khaavren series-the plot thickens!, November 4, 2004
As others have mentioned, this may be Book 2 of the Viscount trilogy, but it's actually book 4 of a series, and you DO need to read the previous 3 in order to appreciate this one.
I have noticed, as time goes by, that there is a pattern to opinions about the Khaavren series: those who started reading Steven Brust's Vlad Taltos series first, and bought one of the Khaavren books because it was by Brust, don't seem to appreciate the Khaavren books as much. Those of us, on the other hand, who started on Brust with this series, or with some of Brust's other fantasies entirely, seem to enjoy the Khaavren books more. I believe it's a question both of writing style, and of one's definition of action. Thus, if you really, really like the Vlad Taltos books, and you expect these to be similar, it may be that you will be less than enchanted with these.
I believe that those who have read a lot of older literature - Dumas, as many have mentioned, and definitely Shakespeare - will enjoy this book, and the Khaavren series, more than the Vlad Taltos fans will, on average. (Of course, every reader has a unique background and a unique perspective - don't let me stop you from reading!!) Certainly a background of the Three Musketeers (and not the movie, people!) helps one appreciate what's going on here - but a knowledge of, say, the battles in Shakespeare's Richard and Henry plays, does not come at all amiss. And a comfort level with the intricate language of Shakespeare, as well as the overwrought prose of Dumas, gives one the stamina to follow Paarfi's extensive perorations.
Let me also mention that there's a dash of Romeo and Juliet in here, with lovers from different houses and their disapproving families. Those who feel that there is not enough action in this book, apparently do not consider a good heartbreaking love story to be action. But it is! So is the evolution of the magic taking place - if moving hundreds of warriors via magic/mental powers, over hundreds of miles, which has never been done before in this world, is not action, then what is? There are no slow moments if one is interested in emotion and magic as well as in swords and battle; there is always something happening between people.
As with previous books in the series, if you do like it, it has an effect on you: you talk funny for days afterward, if not weeks! Hey, if you are planning on taking the GREs or GMATs, this series is a terrific vocabulary builder!! There will be nothing in the verbal section that you can't handle, if you enjoy and appreciate Paarfi!
In short - if you already like this series, this volume is a must; if you like Dumas and Shakespeare, you'll like this; if you like Vlad Taltos, then start in on this series in cautious, easy steps.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|