Gill, a columnist for the New Orleans Times-Picayune
, covers a wealth of little-known history in this chronicle of the recent battle to desegregate Mardi Gras parade groups, or krewes. Mardi Gras is more than this saturnalian city's most famous celebration; it's a crystallization of its unique and volatile cultural mix and its arrogant tradition of formalized prejudice. As Gill documents every city council debate on this sensitive subject since the first desegregation order in 1991 instructed krewes to abide by the civil rights amendment in their membership policies, he traces the lineage of all-white male krewes intent on preserving their elitist status back before the Civil War. African Americans, the city's majority, also have long-standing krewes, and Gill vividly describes their splendid presentations inspired by artful interpretations of American Indian warriors. Mardi Gras history is fascinating, involving, as it does, religion, politics, potent personalities, the blatant abuse of power, all manner of debauchery, and the destructive consequences of an elaborate racial caste system that discriminates against blacks, Italian Americans, and Jews. This is one spicy slice of American life. Donna Seaman
From Kirkus Reviews
Less a history of Mardi Gras than a view of New Orleans through the lens of that all-consuming celebration of social hierarchy that shows how intertwined are carnival's charms with the misdeeds of the ruling class that invented it. ``New Orleans's pride is that it is unlike any other American city, which is also its undoing,'' writes Gill, a columnist for the New Orleans Times-Picayune. The evolution of America's most promising and industrious antebellum port into a seedy, second-rate city notable primarily for the flamboyant means by which it has flouted conventional morality (through legal prostitution, corrupt and defiant governments, and a closed social order that holds racial and ethnic exclusion more dear than economic prosperity) presents a decadent legacy rivaling the drunken riot of Mardi Gras itself. Though he frames the book with firsthand reporting of Councilwoman Dorothy Mae Taylor's 1991 attempt to adopt an ordinance mandating the integration of the private clubs that stage carnival parades, Gill devotes three-quarters of his text to exploring how members of the secretive old-line krewes, formed in the years surrounding the Civil War, directed that evolution. In the process, he sketches the intricate schematics underlying what he aptly dubs ``the annual reaffirmation of social eminence over merit.'' What looks to outsiders like a chaotic street party is in fact a highly orchestrated social dance allowing the upper crust to establish their pecking order in public (albeit at masked balls hosted by secret societies) while spreading a little pre-Lenten cheer to the common folk. Relying mostly on old newspaper accounts, Gill forges a double-edged portrayal of Mardi Gras that, on one hand, captures the drama and romance of carnivals past and, on the other, unflinchingly details the bitter racial division it still fosters. Scrupulously evenhanded--a lively, irony-loving illumination of the politics and history of America's rowdiest street celebration. (30 b&w illustrations, not seen) -- Copyright ©1996, Kirkus Associates, LP. All rights reserved.