Customer Reviews

Lost in America

5 star:		(11)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

First, let me say that I am a huge Edwin fan, and have been so since I first heard Solitude. I've been to about 10 shows and have every CD. Having said that, this CD isn't really doing it for me. It doesn't have the same Bluesy, soul, southern rock feel that most of their other work has had. To me, it'a more of a rock CD, verging, at times, on being very heavy. I still plan on seeing Edwin here in KC,MO on 5/9, but probably won't be looking forward to hearing too many songs off this disc. Hopefully with the next CD, Edwin and the guys will get back to their roots.

I first became interested in Edwin Mc Cain's music after purchasing the "Austin Sessions". A very intimate and quite different body of work from this CD although both are equally compelling. "Lost in America" is quality rock with a superb blend of driving beats and intelligent lyrics. The title song and "Gramercy Park Hotel" exemplify this in particular; but there is not a weak song in the entire collection.

I believe Mr.Mc Cain stays true to his fans by staying true to his self. That is captured in the obvious enthusiasm of the music. I am eager to discover where he goes from hear. Much praise for a fine piece of work. The band and production are also superb.

Is this a different than the other Edwin CD's? Yes. But if you realllly look at the previous ones, they are always a little different. I have to say that following the path Edwin takes with this awesome band of his has always been a treat. Waiting in anticipation of each new CD has been such fun. NEVER does this guy... this band... disappoint.

So very glad to finally get a great version of My Mystery on this one! LOVE it. Some may say that song isn't a typical EM song, but then what IS typical? IF you want I'LL BE and/or I COULD NOT ASK FOR MORE... no, it isn't the same. But we HAVE those songs. You will LOVE these, too.

While it's true that Edwin didn't write every one of these songs, I have to say that of the ones he co-wrote and the ones by his band mates... they are "sooooo Edwin!" I think that's a compliment to the members of EMB who are writing with and for Edwin. It shows they are so perfectly matched. Maybe it's also that talent he as for making any song his own. As you know, we all tend to love the original of songs... no matter what. But I'd say most people that have ever heard Edwin's version of Romeo and Juliet will say that isn't true of Edwin McCain. He can take ANYone's song and put that EMB spin on it and it's better than the original! Not many musicians can do that.

I'd have to say my favorite is TRULY BELIEVE. There goes that songwriting again. The lyrics just can't help but make you smile every time you hear them! ANDDDDDD the music is just the amazing. When we saw him do this song at HOB in Chicago, he was singing with all his might... veins sticking out of his neck... WOW! I told my husband, "Edwin's singing it just like I do in the car ... ALONE." :) THE KISS is another one of my favorites. And BLACK & BLUE is amazing. How do you not mention them all? They are the perfect mix of all sides of EMB. Each one shows off the talent of a different member of the band... Larry, Craig, Dave, Pete, Lee... I remember my husband turning it up and saying, "Listen to Lee's bass on this one!" And then it's, "Listen to Craig right here!" He really shows out on a couple of these. Larry??? OMG!!! THis rock stuff is right down his alley! Go, Larry!!! Pete... yes, the guitar... but really, it's his harmony that I love when he sings LIVE with the band. So perfectly matched to Edwin's voice. Dave???? I have to say always that he is the ONLY drummer in my estimation that is soo much more than a drummer. I mean, who ever notices a drummer, unless he's BAD? Well, Dave has something extra that I've never witnessed elsewhere. Wonder how someone could pick out each band member and recognize such talent? Here's how:

All I can say is get it... get in a nice quiet room with a refreshing beverage, dim the lights and just sit back for a great treat! Yes, this one has a 2 songs that are what I call REAL ROCK; along with it is a perfect blending of what >>>I<<< call typical Edwin music... the kind that makes you stop and think! I actually think that once you listen to WELCOME TO STRUGGLEVILLE and BABYLON, you may wonder if the heart of Edwin may really BE rock and the other stuff is atypical! :] Better yet, watch him do Struggleville or Babylon on stage LIVE and then tell me this guy doesn't know Rock 'n Roll! Yessssss!

Go Edwin!

Enjoy it... you'll like it the first time, and by the 3rd or 4th, you'll be trying to smack yourself 'cause you can't get the bloody lyrics out of your head!!!!! :)

I think that this album is one of is best. All of his music is superb, but this one to me is great. I'm currently in the Army stationed in Iraq, but when I listen to this album, I feel as if I'm at home, even if it is for a short time.

Accessories to this album should be a hot grill with burgers and hot dogs, a cold beverage, and lots of friends.

Great cd....Great band...They have been making quality music for years. See them live if you get the chance. Buy the cd. Support one of finest bands still working hard and making great music.

Love this CD!!! Every song on it is fantastic, you won't hit the skip button once, I promise!!!

LOVE Edwin McCain. I have been going to his concerts since he was a no name and love him just as much now as I did back then. He is a wonderful person on and off stage.

The album and the content are both lyrically and musically superb. If I were to have a complaint it would be that the recording was pushed to, and in some cases past the point of clipping. Listener fatigue was present. Other that that, I hope this collection of great music surpassed the bands' expectations. Great job guys!

This is a grand CD. Of course, the title song is the best. But there are many other memorable and wonderful songs here. The band really shines, and the songwriting does too. Buy it. You won't be dissapointed.

I was very much looking forward to this release. I was very disappointed. The only 2 new songs, of the 8 new ones, Gramercy Park Hotel and My Mystery are previously released, that I liked were Lost In America and Black and Blue. The other 6 were just a different sound that I did not expect. I wish Edwin would stick to his soulful side instead of trying to rock out. I would say this is his worst effort so far and I have everything he has done. I will still go see him in concert, because his shows are very enjoyable, but at least I know when I'll take a bathroom break. During the new songs.