Customer Reviews

Lost Over Laos: A True Story of Tragedy, Mystery, and Friendship

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

For those of us born too late to be part of the generation that was, in the words of Richard Pyle, "educated, molded, and aged by the Vietnam experience," our second-hand knowledge of this war has been limited largely to the negative: the horrors of the battlefield, the mental anguish of the young soldiers being asked to sacrifice their lives for goals that were far from clear, and the deeply divisive debates over the agony of continued warfare vs. the humiliation of abandoning the cause. Yet this book is about journalists who VOLUNTEERED to go into the jungle. What would make an otherwise sane person want to do this? As Pyle explores the lives and deaths of the four killed photojournalists, various answers to this question surface, making the journalist's motives comprehensible even to outsiders such as myself--the lure of the exotic setting, the sense of regret that one might have felt if excluded from the most important event of the decade, and the sense of obligation to "compel the world to see Vietnam," to see it "through a camera lens that illuminated, explained, told truths of what the war looked like and how it felt to be there." As for coping with the drawbacks of death and dismemberment, there was always denial. As Richard writes: "It was part of the war correspondent psyche to recognize the possibility of the worst, but to worry or even think much about that was to invite oneself to look for work in another field"; and "there was a sense among members of the Saigon media that journalists who reached celebrity status through repeated stellar performance could become exempt from ordinary danger, passing into a realm of immunity where the worst simply could not happen to them--as if North Vietnamese gunners tracking a helicopter would receive a last-second order: 'Don't shoot. That's Larry Burrows up there.'"

As summarized in the reviews of others, the primary focus of this book is on (1) the lives of Larry Burrows, Henri Huet, Kent Potter, and Keisaburo Shimamoto; and (2) the difficult search for the details of a crash that took place behind enemy lines (details which, for almost thirty years, were limited to little more than "helicopter shot down over the Ho Chi Minh Trail, apparently killing all aboard"). Yet it's the tangent themes that I found the most affecting, perhaps none more than Pyle's search for meaning in the tragic loss of his colleagues and friends. These four civilian photographers went to Vietnam to share the images of war with the rest of the world, and it seems to double the tragedy "that the only monument to their commitment, their skill, and their courage should be a few bone shards and bits of metal, left out in the rain on a nameless, forgotten hillside." Five stars.

This book describes the world of photojournalists in the Vietnam work and focuses on the death of four photojournalists in a battle over the Ho Chi Minh Trail in Laos during a the US government's semi-covert war against the North Vietnamese in that country (the pilots of their aircraft were South Vietnamese and their death occurred during a South Vietnamese attack against NVA supply lines). The book also describes the effort to find their remains and the authors' attempt to give meaning to their loss. The photojournalists who died included two of the most celebrated of the war and two younger men of great skill. In a relatively short text, the book manages to tell their stories and the story of Vietnam War photojournalism in a manner that is reverent without being professionally aggrandizing. By coincidence, I visited the village where the search for remains took place a few months before the authors and their time in that place was particularly evocative for me. The authors offer a perspective on the war that is complex and, in some ways, more hawkish than other first-hand retrospective war accounts, although too skeptical to really fit the conceptualizations of hawk and dove that characterized the times. Given the many parallels that some have drawn between Vietnam and our own era, this is a book that thoughtful critics and partisans of the Iraqi conflict should read. My only complaint is that book does not include enough of the award winning pictures of Larry Burrows and his fallen colleagues.

Collaboratively written by foreign correspondent Richard Pyle and Associated Press photographer and photo editor Horst Faas, Lost Over Laos: A True Story Of Tragedy, Mystery, And Friendship is an historical and memorial testimony showcasing four combat photographers who died in Indochina: Larry Burrows of "Life" magazine; Henri Huet of the Associated Press; Kent Potter of United Press International; and Keisaburo Shimamoto of "Newsweek". Twenty seven years later, a recovery team was able to visit the site of the helicopter crash that took the lives of these remarkable men, recover evidence, and bring closure to the tragedy. Lost Over Laos is a powerful and poignant narration, and especially recommended reading for students of journalism.

I throughly enjoyed this book. I love history and this book gave a good insight into the press of Saigon including their risks and misfortunes. I enjoyed reading about the relationships developed at a personal level between the press core and the military. I would highly recommend this book.

Before picking up this book I had just finished Requiem by Horst Faas and Tim Page, The Best and the Brightest by David Halberstam, A Bright Shining Lie by Neil Sheehan (all of which I loved), A Rumor of War by Philip Caputo, and Street Without Joy by Bernard Fall. I have to say that Richard Pyle is not in the same league (except maybe with Caputo). A dramatic, tragic story, but it just wasn't captivating in Pyle's hands. Also, he seemed to be stretching to create a book out of this story. Would have been better as an article in Atlantic Monthly rather than a complete book.

I thought this a good read about the loss of four photographers in the Vietnam War. I had seen many of Burrow's and Huet's photos of the war, but really didn't know their personal history. This book shares their history along with Potter and Shimamoto's history. South Vietnam invaded Laos to disrupt the North Vietnamese supply routes to South Vietnam. North Vietnam had made a mockery of Laos and Cambodia's neutrality, and basically was undermining these country's governments. South Vietnam with the U.S. help was trying to disrupt the supply trail. These photographers were flying to see the end result of the invasion when their helicopter was shot down with another by a North Vietnamese gun crew. This book is about their collective histories and the aftermath of discovering the shot down helicopter in Laos. The two authors were friends of both Burrows and Huet.

This is a good read about the dying days of the Vietnam War. I enjoyed the personal history of each of the dead photographers. One comment, there were many South Vietnamese soldiers that were killed when these two helicopters were shot down, and there is little mention in the book about this. Four Westerners are not worth more than a dozen South Vietnames soldiers. Other than that, this was a good read.

In today's news of Afghanistan and Iraq...sometime we forget the 58,000 US lives lost in Vietnam and over 250,000 wounded with life changing dire circumstances. The book follows the war through the photojournalist eyes of the likes of Larry Burrows and his comrades as the risk their lives to bring the true face of war to the homefront. On that fateful day with operations into Laos/1971, four acclaimed journalist and photographers lost their lives...this is their story brought by one of their own.

Some will say...Vietnam..why! Many will also say Iraq...why!

Good reading for those who experience the Vietnam War..

"Lost Over Laos" offers a rare glimpse and so a compelling read into the world of the OTHER heroes of Vietnam -- the truly intrepid reporters and photographers who sent the news home to us. The story is straightforward, as one might expect from wire service veterans, but it is also poignant. Along the way, it gives us a detailed account of the intersection of the military effort, which we all feel we know, and the wire service get-it-right-and-get-right-now camaraderie that few know and that we all wish we could share if we only had the opportunity and the courage to be there. Richard Pyle and Horst Faas aren't well-known, but they should be, and their outstanding effort then, and now, shows why.