Customer Reviews

A Lost Wife's Tale: A Novel

5 star:		(5)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Edith Lutz has run away. She obtains work as a housekeeper to publisher Adam Davenport by lying about her background. However, Edith seems to always look back as if she expects someone to come up to her and say gotcha.

As Edith and Adam become better acquainted they are attracted to one another. However, though she wants more, Edith never stays around for relationships of the heart as she learned as a child they always lead to misery. Still she wants to stay as Adam loves her, but her lies are catching up to her as her past has too, which means it is time to run again before she is hurt if he unmasks the real Edith.

Edith holds the tale together as the viewpoints are mostly seen through her eyes and the story line rotates between her present and her past. She is a fascinating protagonist though in spite of her abusive childhood never fully garners reader empathy and loses that when a relative arrives searching for her. Interestingly the other key cast members even to a degree Adam in the present but especially her family in the past are predominantly seen through Edith's filter so the latter cannot "defend" themselves. Readers who relish a strong character study will want to understand Edie's tale.

Harriet Klausner

First of all, I'm shocked by the 1-star review. Normally I don't read anyone else's reviews before writing my own so as not to be influenced, but I nearly fell out of my chair that anyone would give this book a one-star I had to see why. I completely disagree with the statement that it needs an editor or that the writing is in anyway sub-par. In fact, I liked the book so much that we named it a top pick for Book End Babes national book club for April. The author is an incredible writer.

Yes, Edith is a complicated character and the story is dark. It's women's fiction at its finest, nuanced with all kinds of emotions. We aren't sure we like Edith yet we desperately want to know her secrets. We may not agree with her decisions, but to me this makes it all the more "real." People are complicated and the author does deliver on staying true to the character throughout.

I LOVED IT AND HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS READ.

A woman creates a false identity, leaving her past behind. Once Agnes, she becomes the widow Edith Lutz. Edith takes a job as a housekeeper for Adam Davenport, a wealthy divorced publisher. Adam knows nothing of her past and yet he finds himself attracted to Edith. Without even trying, Edith insinuates herself into Adam's life and yet, the closer they become, the more her past threatens to catch up with her. And what about Adam's past? At first, his divorce seems a distant reality but the status stated in the job interview changes. Will the stories Edith makes up about her identity catch up with her? Will Adam find out the truth about her? What about the husband Frank whom she claims died? With so many lies behind her, what are Edith's intentions? When the world outside Edith and Adam's isolated domestic bliss comes crashing into their lives, Edith's past comes back in a way she never could have imagined.

Marion McGilvary's debut novel A LOST WIFE'S TALE is page-turning suspense with an emotional, psychological richness that builds alongside the action. Gradually revealing the psychology hiding behind Edith's cover identity, Marion McGilvray uses the literary form of the narrative to give additional insights into Edith. From the beginning, the reader knows Edith's identity is false. Her motives are suspect, her actions odd and her character untrustworthy and even unlikable. Narratives of her past break into the present first person narrative, creating even more mystery. As Edith's romance with Adam grows, however, the reader's perspective changes. One hopes with her that somehow against all odds the happy domestic scene will become permanent yet in the back of one's mind, a reader waits for past to catch up with Edith and the odd, almost fairy tale romance to come to an end. Even knowing a twist awaits, several surprises await the reader as the past comes into focus with shocking truth upon dark truth. Layer by layer, the narrative moves from the surface of Edith's cover identity to an inner vision of the character. As Edith tells her story, the reader moves from outsider to insider. The story itself changes Edith.

A LOST WIFE'S TALE works on multiple levels. As pure story, the suspense mesmerizes. The more I read, the more I wanted to read. The more I thought I knew, the less I knew. Yet by the end, the reader's vision becomes fuller than plot alone. How exciting for a fiction and suspense lover! I expected a kind of dark twist on FATAL ATTRACTION and/or REBECCA, but what I got was different and much richer for that, not only in terms of the story but how the author uses the form of the narrative to move the reader, changing one's expectations alongside the narrator's. A LOST WIFE'S TALE is an exceptional mixture of women's fiction, suspense, and literary fiction all in one. Brilliant!

Courtesy of Book Illuminations

I finished this book just because I wanted to find out what happened in the end. The writing was good- except for the metaphors and similes, which became extremely annoying by about 20 pages in..

The problem I have with this book is that NONE of the characters were likable. I didn't even think Agnes was a very nice, likable or even humorous person. Despite the book being all about Agnes and how she came to be a woman on the run, I don't feel like I connected with her AT ALL. I think most of the book was about the past and very little to do with the present. Maybe that's what the author intended..

I HATED Cheryl. Could there BE a more annoying, obnoxious character?? I felt bad for her in the beginning, then I almost wanted to put out a restraining order on her.

I would not call this book "mesmorizing" and I had to force myself to get through the first 80 or so pages. I only continued because I skipped ahead & miraculously struck a gold nugget (dinner part scene) which finally whetted my appetite. Yes, I wanted to know more, but at the same time I wanted to slap Agnes silly for never learning from her mistakes even after therapy. The ending is so incredibly weak, my first thought was the writer had a deadline and simply stopped writing! Then I realized its supposed to be "real literature". It left me regretting the time I spent reading the book. Better than 1 star, but certainly not 4 or 5!

A Lost Wife's Tale was a delicious read for me. I don't review books and their author's often, but when I find one like this, I feel neglectful if I don't. Poor Edith/Agnes with so many lies upon lies it's a wonder she knows who she is at all. She takes the blame for all regardless of whether it's deserved or not. I enjoyed seeing Edie come through it all and end up where I'm sure I'm not the only one who's read this hopes she will end up. I love Ms. McGilvary's humor, a dry wit with plenty of sarcasm even when it's done in our heroine's head. I hope the author will be writing more for us to enjoy in the very near future. I say "Bravo"...it's a Keeper!!

This book was a real page turner.....I stayed up til 3:30 a.m. to finish it....Excellent literary style and with a dark humor to boot.....One star, NO WAY....this is an excellent read..

Who edited this book? He or she needs to be reassigned to the typing pool. This was bad writing all the way through. The book is chock full of cliche, and reads like a first year writing assignment in two year college. Should be nominated for the Bulwer-Lytton contest for the worst dark-and-stormy night writing. It would no doubt win.

Very interesting concept for a book. Once I started I kept on reading despite it not being my favorite kind of book.

I picked this book up at a Tag Sale for $1.00! I consider it a great find! Loved this book and the author! I am recommending it for my Ya Yas Book for January!