Most Helpful Customer Reviews
24 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
What is love really?, September 6, 2006
However normal she might appear Ellen Simpson is a fairly psychologically abnormal heroine hiding in an everyday romance.
As the book opens Ellen is married to Captain Charles 'Charlie' Simpson and we have several chapters of them emphasizing how in love they are. In fact she overemphasizes it a time or two showing that she recognizes that she is attracted to their frined Lieutenant Lord Eden (Dominic). As a red herring she is the 25 year old stepmother of Jennifer, a young miss similar in some ways to other young ladies that Dominic has fancied himself in love with in the past.
In one hundred pages of buildup various characters are introduced and bundled off and the two soldiers are sent off to Waterloo. Charlie is killed and Dominic is seriously wounded. In confusion and under the urge to tell Ellen her husband is dead he directs his rescuers to take him to her house where she receives the news and takes him in.
After he become stronger Dominic and Ellen fall into a 6-day affair, which blows up in their faces and she states that she never wants to see him again. This is where all the confusion about how could she love so soon, etc. etc. comes about. But this is a 350 page book and there's plenty of time for the two main characters to agonize about things and develop further psychologically.
Discerning readers will notice that Dominic has strange notions about love and thinks he can decide whether or not he can fall into love with another young miss apparently for the fun of being in love.
Ellen also has strange ideas although she appears to be a normal loving wife. She met Charlie when she was 15 - in short, having lost the support of all the adults in her life, she is rescued by Charlie who was 30 at that point. She tells Dominic later on that Charlie wanted to send her off to his sister but Ellen convinced him to marry her. Her love is a desparate attachment to the only solid point in her life.
Only on her husband's death, and likely inevitably on her husband's death, Ellen realizes that she is strong and that there are other lovable human beings in the world, even though they might not be as strong or perfect as a child would imagine.
This is a good story and an interesting story, with two other subplots filling in the spaces. My main complain is that many of the characters are overdrawn to make the points the author wants to make and it makes the realism of the book suffer.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Another excellent reissue of a Balogh story, July 11, 2007
Mary Balogh is one of the most consistent authors of historical romances writing today and "Web of Love," a re-issue of a title originally published in 1990, shows this. It is the second in the "Web" series following "The Gilded Web" (reissued last year) which follows the three Raine siblings, Edmund, Earl of Amberley ("The Gilded Web"), Dominic, Lord Eden ("Web of Love") and Madeleine Raine ("The Devil's Web", to be reissued in December 2007).
Mary Balogh's books often have similar themes and this is no different. The Battle of Waterloo and its aftermath plays a significant part in this story (rather like "Slightly Sinful") when Lord Eden is wounded and is tended by the widow of his friend, Charlie Simpson. Charlie's widow Ellen has been following the drum for ten years and in her matter-of-fact, comfortable nature is rather like Sophie in "Irresistible". There is also a disfigured and wounded character who begins to learn about his new limitations and yet new possibilities, particularly in art (like Sydnam Butler in "Simply Love"). And yet although there are some similarities of themes within her books, overall they always seem to work well as standalone novels with far more to them then just romance.
Ellen Simpson and her husband Charlie are deeply in love. And yet as the book starts, she begins to notice Dominic, Lord Eden, as slightly more than her husband's best friend. She ignores this, of course, and sees them both off into battle whilst looking after her stepdaughter, Jennifer. The build-up to the battle is well written as the characters in the story try not to think too much about the possible death and injury and live each day at a time. We also meet the hero and heroine from the first book in this series, the Earl and Countess of Amberley, three years after that story ends and with two children. Amberley's family take Jennifer back to England before the outbreak of the war but Ellen stays with her husband, as always, in Brussels - as does Madeleine, Lord Eden's twin, staying with a friend elsewhere. As reports of the fighting come in Ellen and Madeleine prepare to treat the wounded. Eventually Eden is returned to Ellen's house dangerously wounded and with the news that Charlie has been killed. Ellen nurses him with great care and Madeleine finds herself nursing Lieutenant Allan Penworth who has lost a leg and an eye in the battle. Yet Ellen's time with Dominic, Lord Eden, leads to rather more than they both initially expect before guilt causes Ellen to ask him to keep away from her.
On returning to England, however, Ellen finds herself occasionally in company with Lord Eden. And there's a rather important piece of information she needs to give him but she cannot bring herself to. She ends up staying at Amberley with Jennifer and the Earl and Countess, as well as Madeleine and Lieutenant Penworth and several other people, and learns that she cannot keep all her own secrets as other people are involved.
In some ways the romantic element is less important in this story than some of the others. The focus is a little more on the war and how it can affect families, changing them not only by deaths but also by injury. Dominic appeared as a rather shallow person in the first book in this series and in this novel he sometimes seems rather carefree, acknowledging to himself that he tumbles into love rather readily. Ellen is a very different character, one of steadiness and deep emotion, and yet it wasn't always easy to get into her mind. Neither person's character particularly changes or grows in this story, it is more a case of Dominic finally finding what he has been looking for and Ellen understanding that it is possible to love more than one man in a lifetime. This was, however, an excellent read and will no doubt be much enjoyed by Mary Balogh's fans.
Originally published for Curled Up With A Good Book, www.curledup.com. © Helen Hancox 2007
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An Excellent Historical, A Sad Woman, and Redemption, May 8, 2008
I have read all three books of this trilogy and I must say they were sometimes intense psychological pictures of characters you would think to meet in any romance novel. But there is just more to them, the author makes these character richer, deeper and left me thinking about them well after starting some other book.
Both these characters seem to be in some dream world of there own creating, mostly to deal with how they thing life SHOULD be. Dominic and carefree doing only one responsible thing in his life and that was to join the military. Our heroine, runs after her real father, following the drum, when she learns the father she thought she had wasn't. Her father dies in that war and she takes up with the first or only man kind to her at 15, proposing marriage and doing her best to make it the best marriage to a man 15 years her elder. (It is overdone how much they love each other that makes it all the sadder to know when her husband dies.)
Then in her ability to care for the wounded while denying her own needs and fears, is just another example of her ability to adjust her world so she can cope. This goes too far as bestfriend of her husband, family friend, and wounded officer as he gets better then becomes lover in 6 days out of 3 weeks recuperating. Then finally reality sets in and the pain and denial. But Ellen grows she returns to the Father she thought was her's and tells him her woes, he accepts her again as he always has. Their is healing and maturity and finally acceptance of the truth on her part. And a seriousness in Dominic as more responsibility is dumped on him and he demands to be able to be accountable for them.
Also, the desciption of Waterloo is so good I found myself looking up places and people that are mentioned in the book. The author does her research exceptionally well. I found the near site on maps of that time online. Well Done!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
