Most Helpful Customer Reviews
16 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
I'm afraid I can't recommend it, May 27, 2009
This review is from: How to Buy a Love of Reading (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
I think the notion of hiring someone to write your story or having your parents obsessed with finding you a passion is an enjoyable idea to play with. And while the book is interesting enough, I am disappointed with the characters behaviors overall. The writing is fine if you dig super long sentences (I'm not a fan but I know readers who are). But the characters, they are awful people, and not in a tongue and cheek fun way, and not kids who really have reason for angst and are on a path to redemption for either the reader or themselves. They come across as over privilged whiners that I sort of kind of wouldn't mind if they fall on their faces. This book is aimed at young adults. With my volunteer work I work with a lot of young adults and I can honestly say I could not in good conscience recommend this book to any of the teens I work with. The book is told in slow moving layers with loathsome characters who are either absurd, foolish or apathetic. Carly our most apathetic in the beginning of the book does develop into a somewhat more likeable character she does develop some strengths, but is still coddling a "friendship" or "relationship" that would make the most liberal of parents cringe. And maybe the book is really great and I missed it, and maybe the charcters weren't so awful and maybe the point was to foster a relationship I don't understand. But the fact that I reached the end of the book and wasn't sure what the point really had been or how I was supposed to feel or even why I felt empty about the book means - I didn't like it and I wouldn't recommend it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
18 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A More Intellectual and Literary Gossip Girl, April 10, 2009
This review is from: How to Buy a Love of Reading (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
Tanya Egan Gibson's debut novel How to Buy a Love of Reading is about more than just wealth and snobbery. It's about growing up, struggling with addiction and realizing that "money can't buy happiness" (Egan's character Bree would shudder at such a cliche). Thought Provoking and Entertaining because... - The characters start off seeming very one dimensional, yet as the story unfolds a profound depth appears in many of them. And those that aren't granted depth are denied purposefully- they don't deserve it. - I appreciated the levels of relationship presented in the novel, especially between main characters Carley and Hunter, and the two writers Justin and Bree. They all have faults and do their share to cause havoc, but you can't but to hope that everything turns out okay in the end. - The writing is quite entertaining; Gibson does a fantastic job satirizing many elements of this wealthy demographic. There is also true emotion that makes you sympathetic to people and things you may not normally feel bad for. - The story within a story aspect was amusing (the story Bree writes for Carley is set on a reality show set), but also supported the whole reality vs. false appearances theme. A Few Problems: - The story is a bit difficult to get into; the first fifty or so pages aren't the best representative of the novel itself. Don't quit, just keep going. Forgiveness is a really important concept in the book... - Some people are going to protest that the characters aren't realistic; I had no problem with this, since the characters represent more than just themselves. - There are a few sections that I felt weren't necessary, you'll recognize them when you read them. Luckily there aren't many and they don't last long. This is a novel for someone who is willing and able to peel back the layers and actually see it for what it's worth.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
For the love of Books, April 11, 2009
This review is from: How to Buy a Love of Reading (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
This is not the average teen angst story. Carley Wells has been enticed to become a reader of literature because she simply does not posses the love for great books. Through the process, she engages in an array of escapades that help her to find herself while at the same time trying to pass her English class and prepare for the SAT. And to top that off, she is head over heels over Hunter Clay, a mega bibliophile who lives, breathes, and sleeps with great literature. What is unique about this novel is the premise of Carley's predicament and having a novel written personally for her by author Bree McEnroy. The entire process is a smorgasbord of character references from literature, F. Scott Fitzgerald and the Odyssey, as well as American popular culture, Jackie Kennedy and host of others. And the book is supposedly and personally catered towards Carley's interest, which is displayed in the preliminary stages of the plot that resembles an unusual reality show set during Medieval or Elizabethan times but with a present day twist that does not exactly fall within the lines of "Gossip Girl" or a Joss Whedon series. Through an exchange of emails between Carley and Bree, readers see the tedious and agonizing editing of Carley's novel. But the book is drama in itself, which is humorous and satirical, especially for those who are able to read each passage; there is a small tinge of Joycean pattern that journeys to the unconscious mind of understanding. Overall, HOW TO BUY A LOVE OF READING is an exciting book. One of the interesting aspect of the story is the relationship between Carley and Hunter. Indeed, it is a long and winding road that leads readers through the unpredictable conclusion. The story is almost like the cliché of how literature imitates life, and Carley's novel happens to fall within that category.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|