11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wonderful!, December 31, 2009
This review is from: Lovers' Knot: An M/M Romance (Paperback)
I thought this book was wonderful! It's set in a small Cornish village, and there's a gripping plot that involves ghosts and revenge and the return of a demon lover from our hero's past to bedevil him just as he's beginning to nerve himself up to confess his true love to the sunny young gentleman who is his guest at his newly acquired Cornish farmstead. A lovely meaty plot and a lush, evocative setting - banter and obvious ease between the two heroes, and a dangerous sensuality and threat from the lover of the past who is not as dead and gone as everyone might have hoped... It's a real classic of the genre in a similar vein to The Phoenix by Ruth Sims - a serious, literary book, but a delight to read. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Touching love story, January 8, 2010
This review is from: Lovers' Knot: An M/M Romance (Paperback)
THERE IS A MINOR SPOILER IN THIS REVIEW.
I do apologize but I really could not come up with how not to mention it, especially since the blurb about the book mentions the ghost anyway, so maybe it is not a spoiler after all :)
This novel has all that I am looking for in m/m romance - sympathetic and likeable characters, interesting and rather complicated plot and a **love story**.
I was so so pleased that I found this gem. The setting is lovely, the language seems to be authentic to the period (not an expert here, but I love that it does not sound the way we talk today, even if it is not hundred percent true to the era).
I admit that while I did not have it in me to give four stars, because then I would have to give zero starts to so many books, my grade is probably 4.75 stars, because when I read this story for the first time, there was a point in this story when I felt that I was pulled out of the story, I felt that realistic setting and ghost did not really mesh together. I would have much preferred that "reality" of the ghost would have left more to reader's imagination, that maybe he was just part of the character's imagination if that makes sense. But honestly and truly that did not really influenced my enjoyment of the story overall, so maybe it was more my problem than writer's.
Thank you Mr.Hardy and I will certainly be buying your books in the future if you decide to write them.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An auspicious debut, January 16, 2010
This review is from: Lovers' Knot: An M/M Romance (Paperback)
This easily one of the best M/M romances I have read. The plot was inventive, the characters multidimensional, and the writing was extremely engaging. I particularly appreciated that it avoided many of the tiresome cliches of romance novels-- the purple prose, the generic sex scenes, the obvious villain-- as well as most of the tiresome cliches particular to the M/M genre-- the "Seme/Uke" or worldly/naive or buff/frail pairing, the character who thinks he is damaged but can be redeemed by the power of Twu Wuv, the blackmail angle, etc. I was particularly pleased to find characters who felt their fear and pain and needs deeply, but in a masculine, understated fashion. They felt very real to me, and that's a nice change from many of the stock characters readers get stuck with in this genre (and in all genre fiction. which, I suppose, is why they call it genre fiction.)
That said, I had a couple of quibbles that kept me from giving this a 5-star rating, one of which is specific to this book, and one of which is a more general frustration with the M/M genre universally-- so perhaps it's not entirely fair to isolate Mr. Hardy in this.
***SPOILERS BELOW!***
1) As much as I like supernatural stories, I had a hard time reconciling the supernatural element in this particular story. It was a wonderful historical novel, and so very realistic to me that the ghostly element didn't quite jibe with me. It never felt seamless to me, and I had a difficult time sustaining my disbelief as a result. I would have loved for this to either have had more supernatural elements from the start-- leading, perhaps, to a moodier, more atmospheric piece-- or a straightforward period piece. Mr. Hardy clearly has the talent to do both.
2) I wish the writers in this genre would find another plot device aside from rape and/or abuse!!! Seriously, people. Enough. It has come up in nearly every M/M story I have read. There has to be another way to get the characters together. It's not that I'm offended or disturbed by the topic (which, when you think about it is actually sort of problematic when you think about it), I'm just bored to tears by it. Please, authors! Find some new turf to tread!
But all complaints aside, this was a solid read. The relationship with Nat was wonderful and terrible and poignant, and Rose was a complicated antagonist. Alayne is a staunch friend and will be a wonderful partner for Jonathan. I would eagerly read anything else Mr. Hardy puts out based on this first venture... I just hope it'll be something that sidesteps the rape tropes.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No