13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Just Not as good as "Fifteen", February 9, 2005
This review is from: The Luckiest Girl (An Avon Camelot Book) (Paperback)
Beverly Cleary rightfully occupies the pedestal of supreme excellence; her books were my girlhood favorites (I'm 49) and my daughter's girlhood favorites (she's 14). Beverly Cleary's characters are more real to me than some people, along with Elizabeth Enright's Melendys and Eleanor Estes' Moffats. No one writes books like these anymore...a tragedy! Like many Beverly Cleary fans, I'm sure, I remember all of her books vividly, and though I'm a library mom all the way, I actually BUY Beverly Cleary books because I want to own them for all time. But this one fell a bit short. First, it's so dated, unusual because her books mostly transcend time. The dialogue sounds so stilted, maybe because there are precious few contractions used. Has our speech really become that much more casual? Also, I agree with the reviewer who observed that Shelley Latham's experiences are a bit too perfect. New girl... instantly popular...snags the coolest guy in school...it seems like such a cliched and dated definition of success/happiness. My daughter told me, though, that girls still become popular through the boys they attract...guess we haven't come that far after all! I noticed also that most of the kids reviewing this book gave it glowing 5-star reactions, which makes me think girls today probably long for a more innocent, more civil time, when they weren't expected to be sexualized by 5th grade (chiefly by the media's relentless bombardment). I still felt like Shelley, Philip, Hartley, etc. were very real people, just antiquated and living in a world long gone, whereas Jane, Stan, Marcy, etc. from "Fifteen" seem to ring more true even today. Oh well, like all Beverly Cleary books, this one had me looking forward to reading each night, and I finished it this morning when I should have been cleaning the bathrooms! The master still retains her magic touch, even if a bit off kilter in "The Luckiest Girl."
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
I LOVED IT!, March 18, 2005
This review is from: The Luckiest Girl (An Avon Camelot Book) (Paperback)
I adored this charming book! relates alot to teen/ preteen girls. It shows what things are to come in the teen years, i loved it! STRONGLY RECCOMENDED! No sexual scenes NOT EVEN KISSING! No violence or anything! I LOVE Beverly Cleary's books and i feel this one is her best to date! ;)
Sincerley,
Amanda [14 years old]
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Good Book, August 14, 2002
This review is from: The Luckiest Girl (An Avon Camelot Book) (Paperback)
The Luckiest Girl by Beverly Cleary is a good book. The main character is Shelley Latham, who is sixteen. Shelley lives in Oregon, but her mother's friend from college, Mavis Michie, has sent a letter inviting Shelley to spend the school year in California with the Michies. Shelley goes to California. She feels like she is in fantasyland. Oranges are growing on trees, and flowers are blooming in the winter, and there are palm trees! And now she is going out with Philip, the cute star of the basketball team, and the other girls are all jealous. To find out what happens to Shelley, read this book, which I would reccomend to anyone who likes to read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No