I am really surprised that no other reviewer seems to feel that the father's bashing his four year old son's head in with a whiskey bottle is a CRIME. No one even thought of calling the police. There was not one moment of consequence for the father.
No other reviewer seems to have any problem with a 17 year old boy getting 13 year old Sam drunk and then trying to have sex with her in her compromised/half conscious state, or that he was coming on to her at all, or that other boys were getting her further drunk and assaulting her. Date rape and statutory rape are CRIMES. No one even thought of calling the police. It might be argued that he didn't know she was only 13 but he also never even asked her age, and had to know she wasn't close to his age. Sam didn't have the experience to know what she was getting into, and AJK should have told her. He knew she was not in high school. I also cringed to read that Sam, still too young, didn't realize the depth of what Drew had done, and was talking about still being attracted to him.
I also felt that it was unfortunate that AJK turned out not to be an older girl. There was not one positive female depiction in the book, except for Charlie's mother, possibly. Sam's friends were typical junior high girls, supportive of her when they felt like it, and turning on her when they felt like it. There was no female depiction of anyone Sam could really turn to, and feel listened to and guided by, and this is also not a positive message for girls.
Sam's dad is sent off to rehab for 28 whole days, and at the end, just like on every page of the book, Sam and Luke are just supposed to be there and be supportive of their father, whether he has stopped drinking or not. Their mother is far more concerned about the father than about being a proper parent to her children, or demanding that her husband be a proper parent, or leave. He bashed her baby's head in, and she is welcoming him home with open arms?
I was appalled at the messages this book sends to the young teens who will read it. It says that if you are assaulted or raped, even if you tell your parents, they will do nothing, and that is okay. It says that even if you are abused and neglected by your drunken parent, it's your problem and you just need to be there for the parent. Your needs don't matter. If you have an enabling mother and grandmother, your needs don't matter. I wish the book had indicated in any way how a child reading it could feel a ray of hope, ways to find resources, ways to find people that they can talk to.
The thing this book has in common with "Speak" by Laurie Halse Andersen, is that it is NEVER appropriate for a girl in junior high to attend parties with or hang out with older teenagers.
I gave this book two stars for the love and care that Sam gives to Luke. I liked their relationship.That is the only thing I liked.