32 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
"No merchantman shall be sunk without warning", May 3, 2002
This was the time honored tradition that governed war at sea. Britain and Germany were at war since August 4, 1914, when WWI commenced. Nevertheless warship captains were in the habit of signalling or firing warning shots, allowing crew and passengers of merchantmen to disembark before consigning ship and cargo to the watery depths. Rewards were for tonnage sunk not the numbers of persons sent to "Davey Jones' Locker". This wouldn't apply to the RMS Lusitania anyway. At 785 feet and displacing nearly 40,000 tons with a capacity of carrying 2,000 passengers and 850 crew, she was no mere merchantman but a luxury passenger liner advertised as the "Queen of the Seas". She sailed with impunity, without escort, and according to a well publicized and regular schedule. This was no doubt the mindset of Captain William Turner as he got the Lusitania underway on the morning of May 1, 1915 for the return voyage from New York to Liverpool; the ship's 202nd Atlantic crossing. Turner would also be comforted in knowing that the ship had thirty-four electrically controlled watertight doors which made her "virtually unsinkable" (the same words used to describe a certain ship involved in an earlier titanic catastrophe at sea). Lusitania was popularly known as the "Greyhound of the Sea" due to a top speed in excess of 25 knots and this seemed to have given Turner great confidence as he declared "a torpedo can't get the Lusitania - she runs too fast."
This gripping account by Diana Preston shows the false bravado of that statement and the truth of LUSITANIA being instead known as "An Epic Tragedy". On May 7 in broad daylight the ship was torpedoed and sunk by German submarine U-20 within sight of the coast of Ireland. The ship went down in under twenty minutes with the loss of 1,201 lives including 291 women and 94 children. There was utter shock and disbelief and the repercussions were immediate with worldwide condemnation of the sinking. There were 128 Americans among those lost including Alfred Vanderbilt. In the US, official complacency and public isolationist sentiments totally evaporated. What made it worse was that there had been no warning whatsoever. Only a trail of bubbles indicated an incoming torpedo.
This book is Preston's attempt to sort out why the usual rules of war were disregarded with the Lusitania "carrying civilian men, women and children". As is true of most tragedies at sea, the sinking of the ship is usually only the highwater mark, there is invariably confusion, controversy, and if it's a big enough event, there's sure to be conspiracy theories about. So it is with the Lusitania. One of the issues Preston looks at is: Did 32 year old Kapitan Leutnant Walther Schweiger - the commander of U-20 - know what he was firing at?, and did he act on his own initiative or under specific orders? This ties in with the larger theme of whether the Lusitania was a legitimate target as the Germans claimed. There are at least three versions offered as rationale (1) The Lusitania was an armed merchant cruiser (2) She was ferrying Canadian troops, and (3) She was loaded with guns and munitions. A conspiracy theory surrounds Britain supposedly setting these events in motion so as to draw us into the war. Preston doesn't find any evidence supporting this idea and it's apparent that conspiracists are imagining machinations by Britain's First Lord of the Admiralty. The events of history that Winston Churchill supposedly single-handedly orchestrated is quite phenomenal!
While Churchill, Woodrow Wilson, and Kaiser Wilhelm II all get due attention, this is as much about the passengers and their survival at sea, and in places it is a richly uplifting story of human courage and dignity. A female passenger Madame de Page assisted children into the lifeboats and was directly responsible for saving thirty-five young lives. Captain Turner stayed at his post and tried to steam on in order to beach the Lusitania. This failed and as the ship foundered he tried to maintain calm and only left when he believed he was the last man aboard. At this point nobody knew that so many were trapped below decks.
Preston offers us a riveting historical account that reads like a nautical yarn. The facts are grim and the loss of life was horrendous but Preston's writing skill allows her to bring the people and events alive. The historical detail remains as an unobtrusive backdrop and the richer and more colorful human interest stories shine through.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Brilliant!, May 16, 2002
Move over Stephen Ambrose! This historian has outdone you with her seamless melding of diaries, public records, newspaper accounts, military records, and her prose as the glue. Read this book, including appendix, acknowledgements and, even the references (!) in two long but captivated sittings! Surpases Ambrose's, Undaunted Courage - my previous favorite. On a par with McCullough's John Adams. Bravo, Mrs. Preston.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Thorough and Insightful, June 24, 2003
This review is from: Lusitania: An Epic Tragedy (Mass Market Paperback)
I believe the comparison of Diana Preston to Pullitzer Prize Winner Barbara Tuchman is quite justified, as Ms. Preston has gone to great lengths to provide intricate detail of the lives and events surrounding the Lusitania's tragic sinking off the Irish coast.
It would be a disservice to say that this book provides too much detail for a reader who just wants the basics of the ship's sinking. I find that it is those details that make the book so engaging and, surprisingly, a fast read. Every good book I've read has typically taken about 100 pages before the author "has" you, and before you know it, Preston will have you on the top deck staring down at that single menacing torpedo.
Knowing how the disaster affected so many lives through the poetic testimony of its survivors adds a much welcome human element to the tragedy.
I was very much impressed by Preston's inquiry into what actually did cause that second explosion on the vessel. She has all the facts up to date and interests you with each new development.
You'll know all there is to know about the Lusitania and more after reading Preston's book. A most engaging read
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No