17 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Beautiful meditation on memory and love, February 17, 1999
By A Customer
Another film from the 1940's that remembers the turn of the century--in this case, after all the characters have grown old, they look back on their lives. Lydia, a headstrong girl, is wooed by a number of men, but there are always complications. Finally she meets a man who sweeps her away, but problems arise once again. What makes this film lovely is its recreation of another time, with its breathtaking winter scenes and evocative plays on memory. And Joseph Cotten and Merle Oberon are excellent, among others.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Elegaic and poetic meditation on love, November 16, 2007
This is an unofficial remake of the French movie "Un Carnet du Bal" made by the same director some 3 years earlier .
It revolves around an aged but still beautiful woman ,Lydia(Merle Oberon)looking back across the gulf of some 50 years on her romances with 4 different men .
There is Michael (Joseph Cotten)a doctor and the son of her wealthy familiy's butler -john Halleday ;then there is Bob (the future TV Superman ,George Reeves)a football hero and Frank (Hans Yaray)a blind pianist/composer.Most important of all there is Richard(Herbert Marshall)a man who opted for a seagoing life and the only one of the 4 she really loved passionately . She has stayed true to their love but a sad and melancholy bitter sweet truth concerning their relationship awaits in the key revelation near the end of the movie .
The movie is episodic and some will find it sentimental .I prefer to see it as an extravagantly romantic movie ,lavish in every way.It is sumptuously mounted ,beautifully photographed and boasts an Oscar nominated score by the great Miklos Rosza at his most sweepingly romantic.The turn of the century gowns worn by the ladies are gorgeous also
Oberon was for me not a strong enough presence as Lydia and I kept wishing that stars like Crawford,Davis or Bergman has been available .She looks ravishing however and the rest of the cast give exemplary performances .Watch out for a nice cameo from Edna May Oliver ,too
This is a wallow in romance ;leisurely in pace and elegant in design it remains a sad ,touching ,serene meditation on the power of love and loss.Studio movie making at -or near-its best
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
