45 of 45 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
One of the 2 best books on MP3, March 28, 2000
This review is from: MP3: The Definitive Guide (Paperback)
O'Reilly's habit of using the word "definitive" in their titles is very irritating - this book is excellent, but it isn't totally definitive. There are chapters on how MP3 works, how to get and play MP3 files and creating your own MP3s (including dealing with playlists and tags), various kinds of software and hardware players, webcasting and servers, and legal stuff. I will focus here on what I see as omissions, but there is much that is good about this book.
The part of this book that is bettered elsewhere is the legal stuff - the approach of Bruce Fries in "The MP3 and Internet Audio Handbook" (using case studies) is a more practical approach to what you may and may not do. However, the explanation of SDMI beginning on p.278 is lucid, and well worth a read by the denizens of the mp3.com board, where there is a debate currently raging about exactly how SDMI works.
The book is cross-platform, so the author treats Win95/98/NT (but not 2K), Linux, and the Mac and BeOS's in all chapters. In the players chapter you get pictures and descriptions of the most popular models (Sonique has an "incredibly trippy" UI) and a following chapter deals with more advanced topics like equalization, digital conversion, ID3 tags and playlists with descriptions of editors, playing MP3 streams, and skins and plug-ins.
Chapter 5 begins with encoding issues including sample rates. Once again Fries' "The MP3 and Internet Audio Handbook" does it better, with a table instead of a verbose explanation. Bit-rates are handled in several places in this book, and only mentioned in passing in this chapter, where the explanation really belongs. Fries' book has several tables on bit-rate, sound quality, and file size. The (very) brief discussion on recording streaming audio doesn't mention either TotalRecorder or Voquette - however, there is an excellent discussion of encoders in this chapter.
Chapter 6 has a cursory description of four portable players: the Rio, Nomad, Lyra and I-Jam, but a decent discussion of the different technologies used in these players. Home and car stereo players are also described, and once again the coverage is patchy - coverage of AudioRequest and the Lyndstrom Songbank, but where's the Lansonic? And where is the Raite - arguably the most talked about home player on the internet? Not a mention.
Chapter 8, on webcasting and servers, is outstanding. The author treats both the commercial sites and DIY, with the emphasis on DIY. A great resource for anyone thinking of running their own ftp, web server, or internet "radio", and working with SHOUTcast or icecast. Awesome!
So to repeat - an excellent but not definitive book - it has its faults but on the whole is a very worthwhile purchase. If you read this and then get the very latest from a message board at a site like mp3.com, you won't go far wrong.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
25 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not for programmers, August 23, 2000
This review is from: MP3: The Definitive Guide (Paperback)
This book will not teach you how to write applications to create mp3 files. If you want to write an encoder or decoder you should get the specification from the ISO standards site.
It does give information on how to use other peoples software and it also gives you information about the law. If you want to start sharing mp3 files or broadcast music using third party software then this book is not too bad.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The author is informed, and writes clearly., March 27, 2000
This review is from: MP3: The Definitive Guide (Paperback)
This is the only mp3 book I've read. The reason I decided to buy it was that it was from O'Reilly & I've read Scot Hacker's other book (The Be Bible) and he describes subjects clearly.
The book covers Windows, Linux and Be (I run all three). It even has MacOS mp3 coverage.
The topic of legal issues surrounding mp3 is also brought up. Hacker was very smart to put this in because everyone, who uses mp3's, should know about what's going on with our law system.
This book is worth your time reading, not just for how to play mp3's on your OS of choice but also to be informed about a serious legal question.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No