From Publishers Weekly
In a concluding note, Sutherland (The Waiting Place) explains that Norse mythology and Celtic folklore inspired both the text and pictures of this allegorical tale. More memorable and complex than the narrative is the art, created by a multi-step process using pastel pencil, acrylic paints, oil paints and oil washes. The larger-than-life, boastful MacMurtrey sets out to prove that he is greatest of all, caging every beast and fencing in the hills to claim them as his own. Still unhappy, he then decides to build a wall to "cage the sea," a painstaking process that strips the hillside bare; all but MacMurtrey sail away from "this sad land." Predictably, even capturing the sea brings the tyrant no satisfaction; nature steps in to set things to rights. The formerly foreboding illustrations then become a good deal sunnier, as smiles replace the villagers' tears, and the once doleful faces that composed the waves in the sea become cheerful. Sutherland's arresting compositions incorporate a range of expressions, patterns and details; for instance, when at last he completes the wall and proclaims, "There are none so great, so great as me!" a giant deified face is visible in the clouds, transforming into the storm itself in subsequent spreads. Some potentially frightening images in these symbolic, somewhat surreal paintings, make this most appropriate for more sophisticated picture-book readers. A feast for the eyes. Ages 4-8.
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Grades 1-4--Although MacMurtrey is "greater than all men who had ever lived," he's not happy. While other people tend to the work, the large man swaggers about, jealous of any other great thing he sees. After he captures all the living creatures of the land, he turns his efforts to building a wall to cage the powerful sea, somehow convinced that he will be happy if he has no competitors. This monumental and ultimately futile effort almost costs the giant his life. Yet, in the end, his own people save him, and as he works side by side with them, using his mighty strength to help, he learns the nature of true happiness. This story has a folkloric, tall-tale quality and, appropriately, there is a monumental feel to Sutherland's artwork. MacMurtrey is a solid man with powerful hands, and all the other figures are short and stocky, with a Brueghel-like peasant aspect. The illustrations also have a surreal quality, with faces in the waves and clouds. Yet even when depicting movement, as in the waves crashing on the shore or the wind blowing, the pictures seem static. An additional purchase.
Robin L. Gibson, Perry County District Library, New Lexington, OH
Copyright 2002 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
