Customer Reviews

Mad Hatter's Holiday: A Sergeant Cribb Mystery

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Lovesey is a wonderful author. This book starts out slow, but the first 1/3 is the best description of holidaying in Brighton in the latter part of the 19th century that I've ever read. Then when Cribb and Thackery are called in to solve a grisly murder, the book becomes a cracking whodunit. The story is complex and has a surprising ending. At first I didn't understand the meaning of the title, but that too becomes clear when it is determined who the initial murderer is. Cribb is wonderful in this book. The more that I read this series, the more I wish there were more books than the seven that were written in this particular series. Mr. Lovesey could teach classes on writing tight plots, and ingenious mysteries. He also achieves a real sense of time and place that you don't often see, especially in murder mysteries.

Albert Moscrop, owner of a London shop which sells binoculars and telescopes, is a voyeur, in the sense that he is a watcher, a man who lives his life vicariously through watching the comings and goings of other people. This summer he has elected to spend his holiday weeks at the seaside town of Brighton. The year is 1882, and the town is alive with the fashionable and the would be fashionable, who spend their days either promenading or taking part in the newly fashionable sea bathing, descending from bathing machines pulled right on to the edge of the water, and delicately immersing themselves for the good of their health. Moscrop becomes entranced by an attractive young woman, mother of a small child and step mother to an aggressive, thoroughly objectionable teenaged boy, and does everything he can to engineer an introduction to her. Her elderly husband, Doctor Prothero, is a flirtatious man who largely ignores his wife, and who makes sure that he is free in the evenings to pursue his amorous attentions to a local beauty, by insisting that his wife takes a dose of Chloral to make her sleep soundly. When the dismembered body of a young woman is discovered, buried in the sand of the seashore, the local police call on the services of Scotland Yard veterans, Sergeant Cribb and Constable Thackeray, and not only are the members of the Prothero family involved, but Albert Moscrop's voyeuristic tendencies come under the attention of the police.

This Victorian procedural is set in the seaside town of Brighton during summer holiday. The book spends the first 100 pages inside the mind of voyeur named Moscrop as he stalks, spies, and fantasizes about hot babes seen through the end of his telescope. It has been tedious reading 100 unadulterated pages from the perspective of a lunatic wherein the plot is not advanced. In the 2 prior Lovesey works I have read and reviewed THE DETECTIVE WORE SILK DRAWERS, and WOBBLE TO DEATH

I was not confronted with this odd style. Sgt. Cribb and Constable Thackery have just arrived on the 2:15 train from London. I am in suspense as to whether they can redeem this mystery from mediocrity. About 100 pages later Cribb has tied a bow around this package and solved the riddle. This is my least favorite Sgt. Cribb so far. The first pages are an elaborate red herring. There is little compelling action. My fave THE DETECTIVE WORE SILK DRAWERS explores bare knuckle boxing under THE LONDON RULES; is a better place to start. This one is good for an old ladies tea party.

Alfred Moscrop is looking forward to his holiday at Brighton. Like many other middle class Victorians, his two week stay by the sea is the high point of his summer.

But Moscrop has an unusual hobby. Today we might call him a Peeping Tom, but he would describe himself as an "optical enthusiast." He enjoys trying out his newest telescope on the bathers. He's not really looking for sexual secrets, he's just sort of, well, peeping. (Which honestly, how many of us do? You know, taking a look in someone's window as you drive by.)

This time, his spying has gotten him involved a little too deeply. He sees a remarkably beautiful woman. He can't help wanting to know about her. He follows her. He spies on her. He follows her stepson, her maid, her husband. And the more he watches, the more he gets tangled up in her life. He contrives a meeting with the family. He's convinced she's in the victim of a plot by her cheating husband. He sees himself as a rescuer.

What I enjoyed about this book was that I really couldn't tell where the story was going. Is Moscrop to be trusted? Is the woman? Are any of the characters really who they seem?

This is from a series featuring Victorian detectives Sergeant Cribb and was on the PBS show Mystery! But it wasn't quite like the others I had read in the series. I don't want to give too much away, so let me say that I really enjoyed it. There were some loose ends at the end of the book, but it felt like a realistic conclusion. Well done.

First Sentence: Brighton this year!

Albert Moscrop sells fine telescopes and binoculars. He is on holiday in Brighton, assessing the quality of some instruments he has brought when him watching others on holiday. He is becomes fascinated by a young woman and arranges to make her acquaintance. The more he gets to know her and her family, the more distasteful things he learns.

When the woman disappears and a dismembered body is uncovered, he contacts the police. Sargeant Cribb and Constable Thackeray on are the case.

Although written in 1973, this is a gem of a Victorian-era book. Lovesey has captured the societal restrictions as well as the richness and formality of the language of the time. Where else does a character admire the perpendicularity of a pier. I loved Cribb's analogy of the pier to the city, being all sparking and fresh on top while slimy with weeds and black water underneath.

The story is very much plot driven, and well-plotted it is with some very good twists along with way. This was the fist Lovesey I had read, but it is not going to be my last

THE MAD HATTER'S HOLIDAY (Pol. Proc-Sgt. Cribb-England-1882/Vict) - VG

Lovesey, Peter - 4tht in series

Soho Constable, 1973, Trade paperback - ISBN: 9781569475607

This is an odd book. It took a long time to get to the point and the main character is a sleazy weirdo with an creepy "binocular" hobby. If you read it you will know exactly what I am talking about. Not a book I would ever pick up again and read. Plus, not sure what the title has to do with the book, other than the main character spends almost the entire book on a seaside vacation.

In 1882 the Brighton Beach Resort is a beautiful place to visit, relax, and do some sightseeing; at least that's what Albert Moscrop was hoping to find. Through his sightseeing and wonderings about the resort, Moscrop finds himself slowly becoming fascinated by a family of vacationers, the Protheros. As Moscrop becomes more acquainted with the Protheros, he becomes inadvertently involved in a gruesome murder that sends the whole town of Brighton into an uproar. In the shock of this horrible murder, Scotland Yard is called, and they send in Sergeant Cribb and Constable Thackeray. As the two begin to investigate, it becomes clear that this will be one of the most challenging, and definitely strange, cases they've ever had.

Follow Cribb and Thackeray on another adventure of baffling proportions. This story will keep you turning the pages and you won't want to put it down until everything's resolved. Another excellent Victorian-era mystery from an author who does the genre so well.