24 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Courtesy of Teens Read Too, July 26, 2008
I finished reading MADAPPLE last night and, for the first time ever, I sat staring at the book in shock. For fifteen minutes. I was ready to laugh, to cry, and to scream in frustration. Never before have I read a book that left me feeling that way after finishing it. Sure, there have been books where I've laughed, cried, and been frustrated at different points as I read it (HARRY POTTER AND THE DEATHLY HALLOWS comes to mind) -- but to experience them all at once at the end of a book? Never.
Once the shock wore off, I began wondering how I was ever going to write a review of this book. Because a book that can cause emotions like that definitely can NOT be summed up in one paragraph, no matter how long. I could say that MADAPPLE was about flowers and plants. I could also say that it's about a girl who's a prisoner in her own life. I could also say that it challenges the religion of Christianity. I could say all of those things and so many more, but none of them would be correct. Yes, MADAPPLE is about flowers and plants. It's also about being a prisoner in your own life and it's even about Christianity. But it's also about so much more than that. More than even my mind can comprehend.
But I must warn you - MADAPPLE is NOT for everyone
Told in alternating chapters of the present and of testimonies being held at Aslaug's trial, MADAPPLE challenges the reader. It informs the reader. I, myself, though not a strong Christian, know by now that most Christians are offended when their religion is challenged. MADAPPLE does that. But I don't necessarily think it's a bad thing, for it never states that Christianity is wrong, and every single character has their own opinion on it. Heck, one of them even runs a church. But what it does do is explain how the birth and story of Jesus that the Christians follow is not the first in history. I'm not going to say more on that subject in fear of giving too much away, but I'll say this - if you're a Christian who is easily offended, I wouldn't read this. If you're a Christian who can handle a reasonable amount of things, pick up the book.
My feelings about MADAPPLE changed throughout the entire book. At first, I was intrigued, then confused, and then bored. Actually, I think I was confused up until the last page and then some. Even at this moment, I can't say whether I love or hate MADAPPLE. But I'm going to say that I love it because it's left me speechless, and the only other books to have done that are my favorites. The one thing, however, this book didn't do was make my stomach hurt. The character emotions just weren't there to make my heart break. All other aspects, besides that, which I love in books were there.
So do I recommend MADAPPLE? Definitely yes! But only if you're up for a challenging read. Only if you're mature enough to handle speculations about virgin and premarital birth. Only if you're ready to be blown away, because you will be, whether it's in a good or bad way. Only you can make that decision.
Reviewed by: Harmony
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Most Accomplished Debut Novel I've Read in Ages, May 14, 2008
It's hard to know where to start in the praise for this amazing story of Aslaug, a teenaged girl who, having been raised by a reclusive mother, finds herself--after her mother's death--in the unfamiliar world of her minister-aunt's church. Meldrum cuts back and forth between rapid-fire courtroom testimony of Aslaug's trail and beautifully lyrical sections detailing the events of Aslaug's life that land her in court. Each of the more lyrical chapters is titled with the name of a plant, and Meldrum's weaving of a rich wealth of information about each plant's medicinal qualities with a deep knowledge of religions of all sorts adds more to this book than I ever could have imagined--without ever slowing the pace of the story. I'm only left wishing there were a second of this author's books to pull off the shelf, and hoping there will be soon!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
I'm torn between one star and five stars, December 31, 2008
I would give this novel five stars for the sheer audacity the author has invested in what is clearly a huge amount of research, of life experience, and of honing a complicated writing style. I would also give the novel one star because I believe it fails across the board at everything it wants to be: YA, romance, historical fiction, mystery, you name it. But I'm not giving it a 3-star middle ground. I think the work fails more often than it succeeds.
Other reviewers have commented on the originality of this story. Sadly, I don't find it so; I see a huge number of parallels to 'White Oleander,' by Janet Fitch, right down to the Scandinavian protagonists. With every page I waited for the book to break free of everything that was dragging it down: the too-true-to-life courtroom scenes (which are probably interesting to an attorney, such as the author, but i can't imagine a teen wants to slog through what are basically court transcripts), the uneven character development (Aslaug is basically a wild child, but her language, actions and even thoughts are not consistent with such a character) and the laborious botany and religion lessons. I am a huge fan of many works with an academic slant, but even I found myself skimming because I didn't see the relevance in having to swallow a huge dose of medieval philosophy along with my teen novel. And, fundamentally, I felt the author had a tough time keeping her book reined in. The plot veers in too many directions and has trouble with even simple elements, such as making sure characters are introduced clearly.
As with other books, I was suckered in by the excellent art direction and by the CV of the author. My expectations were fairly high, since I think teen readers need to expand their oeuvre beyond 'Gossip Girl.' But I don't think I'd recommend this work to any. Whatever the author's original clarity of vision was with this story, it became too muddled in the telling.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No