From Booklist
The signed essays, written by "independent scholars" and college, university, and law school professors, vary in length from 250 to 3,000 words. Each begins with a short definition of the subject, gives historical background information and case examples, and ends with a list of cross-references to related articles. Essays of more than 1,000 words also offer a selected readings section. Some essays are illustrated with black-and-white photographs, charts, or tables. Access is provided by an alphabetical list of all entries, an index, and a list of topics by subject category, wherein all essays are placed in one or more of 34 broad categories including attorneys, constitutional issues, defendants, legal occupations, and punishment. Appendixes include lists of important federal laws, important U.S. Supreme Court cases, bar associations, legal organizations, and federal law enforcement agencies; a filmography; and a glossary.
Similar in appearance and format to the same publisher's American Justice [RBB O 1 96], Magill's Legal Guide is written in simpler prose and does not provide the same depth of information. American Justice, in turn, is not nearly as exhaustive as the more expensive 12-volume West's Encyclopedia of American Law (West, 1998). There is a good deal of subject duplication between the two Salem titles: both cover crimes such as burglary and rape; social issues such as affirmative action and child abuse; procedural matters such as the hearsay rule, jury selection, and the appellate process; and constitutional issues such as freedom of speech and the right to bear arms. Magill's Legal Guide does offer more coverage of everyday legal topics, such as landlord-tenant relations, wills, home buying, and name changes. Many of these areas are well-covered in less-expensive resources, such as The American Bar Association's Family Legal Guide (Times, 1994) and titles from Nolo Press. Nolo's Web site [http://www.nolo.com] offers a free legal encyclopedia that covers these topics in as much depth as Magill's.
Magill's Legal Guide is the latest entry into the crowded "law for laypersons" market. Its primary audience appears to be public libraries. However, it will not be an essential purchase for any library that already has either American Justice or West's Encyclopedia of American Law and a fair helping of other legal self-help titles.
