From Booklist
This second edition includes 950 completely revised and updated entries plus 150 new articles. The editors indicate that other enhancements include a nationality and a genre index. Though well intentioned, these guides are not that helpful. For example, almost 750 individuals (out of 1,100) are identified as "American," including those whose works reflect other cultures, such as Naomi Shihab Nye and Jamake Highwater. Conversely, Eve Bunting is identified as "Irish," and Isaac Asimov as "Russian," despite little apparent cultural emphasis in their works. One suggestion would be to designate "Heritage" or "Cultural Background" as alternate identifiers. Some of the genre designations are too broad to be of much use; more than 500 names are listed under "Novels" and about 350 under "Illustrations." Other more limited categories ("Animal Tales," "Horror Fiction," "Music," etc.) better lend themselves to practical applications for teachers and researchers. Another consideration for future editions would be the inclusion of a time line.
However, these are minor concerns, as are a few discrepancies in coverage (Robert Louis Stevenson is included, but curriculum staple Edgar Allen Poe is not; Ben Bova and Robert Heinlein are profiled but not Ray Bradbury, another standard presence in most American literature textbooks). Overall, this resource provides a tremendous amount of reliable and accessible information. Recommended for all public and secondary school collections that do not subscribe to SATA. RBB
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
--This text refers to an alternate
Hardcover
edition.
