Most Helpful Customer Reviews
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
How Not to Write a Graphic Novel, August 6, 2007
This review is from: How to Make Money Like a Porn Star (Paperback)
After reading Strauss's riveting Jenna Jameson autobiography ( How to Make Love Like a Porn Star: A Cautionary Tale), I thought that I'd find something of value in this companion graphic novel. Not the case, unfortunately. The "plot" here is barely cohesive and, quite frankly, disgusting (the main character, a gun-wielding porn star, is kidnapped and raped by her own brother...). Some reviewers have called this book "laugh outloud funny." Maybe if you're in junior high, all of the naked boobies will make you giggle? While I give Strauss's Jameson autobiography my highest marks, this book is at the other end of the spectrum.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
26 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Quite a Departure from The Game.., September 26, 2006
This review is from: How to Make Money Like a Porn Star (Paperback)
I had a chance to sneak peek some of the contents of the book before its release (he released various portions on some private BBs), and was quite surprised at the departure in content from previous material he's released.
Though in a way, I guess I shouldn't be.
Strauss has a writing style/persona that gives him the best of both worlds - to roam among the world he observes and writes of while never quite being OF it himself - able to distance himself from the subject matter, stay above the fray, to remain professionally unscathed.
It worked, to a point, in his last book, The Game. Though strange to some observers - the undertone of that book read like a morality play, and yet he went on to teach and discuss pickup techniques in mainstream media outlets.
I'm not sure he will remain as unscathed with this release. Already the book's subject matter - juvenille at best, (a graphic novel with the artwork done by Bernard Chang, who's work added visual affect in The Game), a patronizing insult at worst - his bifurcation simply doesn't hold up this time around.
Like Pete Townsend's lame claim that he posessed child pornography 'for research purposes,' trying to convince us that this is a high-minded expose squeezed in between silly, obnoxious artwork and titilating characters simply doesn't wash.
Reminds me of those cheesy late night programs on cable TV, showcasing rude/crude sex acts in the form of a documentary. Be a man; pick your path.
Most should see right through it. Save your money and pass.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Somebody's Going to Make Money from This, but it's Not You, October 28, 2006
This review is from: How to Make Money Like a Porn Star (Paperback)
"How to Make Money Like a Porn Star" is a rich concept, but poorly executed. The origin of this idea comes from Neil Strauss' interactions with porn stars from his Jameson project, who all shared their heart-wrenching stories to him as how they came into the idustry. Apparently, he rolled them all into one character, Claudia Corvette. The trouble is the Corvette character becomes more archetypical than fresh--her story (the road to the porn industry, not after) as sad as it may be, is nothing any viewer of "Dateline" (or other journalistic programming) doesn't already know, or can't already guess.
If Strauss set off to show us an unimaginiable underbelly to the pornography industry, he overcompensated with such an over-the-top plot. It is difficult to distinguish between what a porn starlett suffered through, or what is the creation of Strauss' imagination. Would a sultan train women in sexual technique for his harem? Yeah, probably. Could a women crunch a man's penis with her kegel muscles? Maybe. Could there be a "family reunion" as coincidental as this book's ending? I don't know. And what about Corvette's mother planting a butcher knife in a 3rd grader? I would place my money on this actually being fiction, so why wouldn't we believe the rest is also?
Bernard Chang's artwork and diverse styles shines through here, considering the script he had to work with--too fast-paced, sloppy flashbacks, and confusing backstory (Was the "Body Shop" a strip bar or really an autobody shop?).
Not all is lost though. Strauss' stength comes in the mock advertising inserted between acts. The "Porn Nuts" comic strips in the book are gems, particularly "Dirty Laundry" and "Scarred for Life." I would have preferred a "Porn Nuts" collection instead of "How to Make Money."
This is a work of satire, though the themes and messages in the graphic novel would have benefitted from a realistic approach. This would have meant a longer project, and more characterization (The reader feels distant from the characters). Otherwise, it is what it is--satire and fiction.
If you're a fanboy or a Style-monger, then go ahead and make the purchase. If you're not, borrow a copy for half an hour.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|