Making Sense of Illness: Science, Society and Disease (Cambridge Studies in the History of Medicine) [Hardcover]

Robert A. Aronowitz (Author)

Book Description

Publication Date: February 13, 1998 | ISBN-10: 0521552346 | ISBN-13: 978-0521552349 | Edition: 1

Making Sense of Illness is a fascinating investigation into the social and clinical factors that determine what constitutes a "legitimate" illness in the twentieth century. By examining six case studies of diseases that have emerged within the past fifty years--from what we now consider to be "straightforward" diseases such as coronary heart disease, to the currently widely-debated Chronic Fatigue Syndrome--Aronowitz examines the historical and cultural factors that influence how doctors think about illness; how illnesses are recognized, named, classified, and finally, what they "mean" in an individual and social context. The choices that are available to the investigators, clinicians, patients and the processes by which change occurs are factors that all play a great role in "legitimizing" an illness, and these are the roles that are seldom examined. By juxtaposing the histories of each disease, Aronowitz shows how cultural and historical precedents have determined research programs, public health activities, clinical decisions, and even the patient's experience of illness. This is a must-read for anyone interested in public health and the history of medicine in the United States.

Editorial Reviews

From The New England Journal of Medicine

Dr. Aronowitz champions the holistic approach to the care of patients in the face of what he sees as the current science-oriented, reductionist approach to the practice of medicine. For example, he believes that in the past, the creation of new disease categories was the outcome of a largely "social process of negotiation" to which clinical and laboratory expertise contributed but in which they were not preeminent, as they are in the contemporary setting. Aronowitz suggests that by understanding the process by which disease categories are created, we are in a better position to assess all aspects of a disease, its effect on individuals and society as a whole, and the reaction of patients, society, and the health care system to the disease itself. He points out that the focused, disease-specific, scientific (ontologic) view gained ascendancy with the germ theory in the latter part of the 19th century and led to the credo of contemporary molecular biology: one gene, one protein, one disease. The result, he fears, has been a loss of appreciation of the influence of individual characteristics, including emotions, lifestyle, and social class.

However, the picture is not entirely bleak, because of a further development in medical thinking during the past 20 years. This the author terms the "risk-factor approach," which forms a bridge between the seemingly competing ontologic and holistic ideologies. The risk-factor approach combines the rigor of scientific identification of specific disease risk factors with the creation of a profile of the individual patient. That profile is as unique to the patient as risk-factor science is specific and has major implications for preventive medicine. Notwithstanding some of the author's reservations, this theme is well developed in the book and owes much to the discussions with Dr. William Kannel, who, with his colleagues in the Framingham Study, originally coined the term "factors of risk" in the early 1960s.

The book explores the concept of the "social construction of disease" and the factors that have a role. These factors are illustrated by the discussion of five cases in the introduction and again in the conclusion and explored under chapter headings covering the psychosomatic hypothesis of ulcerative colitis, the history of chronic fatigue syndromes, Lyme disease, the changing interpretation of angina pectoris, the development of risk-factor thinking, and the type A hypothesis.

The book is well referenced, and important quotations have been inserted -- for example, on thinking about angina by William Heberden, William Osler, Thomas Lewis, and Paul White; on the importance of diet by Ancel Keys and others; and on the risk-factor approach by William Kannel, William Castelli, and more recent experts. The extensive quotations add greatly to the appeal and clarity of the overall work.

This book will stimulate responses from both the ontologic and holistic camps. No doubt, the ontologically inclined will in the end still question whether one has to treat the "whole person" if one can rid him or her speedily and painlessly of disease and hence prevent the necessity of a long-term "association" with the medical professional. The holistic advocate will still say that no disease is that simple to treat and that much of the research undertaken is so far removed from having clinical application that its chance of leading to therapeutic innovation often borders on the fortuitous.

We are told that Dr. Charles Rosenberg, as series editor at Cambridge University Press, continually challenged the author to be more precise and brief. The failure of the book to reflect this advice fully may act as a barrier to readers whose attention spans flag toward the end of long sentences (sometimes 60 words or more with subordinate clauses). I suspect that few will want to read this book all at once but that many will enjoy keeping it at hand and picking it up from time to time to browse. It should be especially appreciated by the new breed of academics incessantly involved in designing and redesigning the medical school curriculum. Through them the book stands a chance of having an impact on the practice of medicine in the future, especially if it convinces educators that, rather than packing the curriculum with all the new knowledge available, they could provide students with "unstructured" private time, time to think, and possibly even a little time to chat with patients as human beings.

Reviewed by David J.A. Jenkins, M.D., Ph.D.
Copyright © 1998 Massachusetts Medical Society. All rights reserved. The New England Journal of Medicine is a registered trademark of the MMS.

Review

"Making Sense of Illness succeeds as both a medical monograph and a book for the lay reader because it speaks to such deep matters of health and health care delivery, and accomplishes its task in relatively jargon-free language. This is a book for the thinking reader." The Washington Post

"This book will stimulate responses from both the ontologic and holistic camps...It should be especially appreciated by the new breed of academics incessantly involved in designing and redesigning the medical school curriculum." The New England Journal of Medicine

"The author of this very sensible book is no ideologue; he makes us think hard about interactions among social and biological determinants of disease meaning....Making Sense of Illness succeeds as both a medical monograph and a book for the lay reader because it speaks to such deep matters of health and health care delivery, and accomplishes its task in relatively jargon-free language. This is a book for the thinking reader." Harold J. Morowitz, The Washington Post

"Robert A. Aronowitz has written a challenging and most interesting short book perhaps best characterized as medical historicosociologic in scope...I hope that Making Sense of Illness will be widely read and discussed within our profession." Joseph S. Alpert, MD, JAMA

"...a doctor's effort to do justice...bringing us to our (clinical senses) so that we can appreciate the limits as well as the extent of our new knowledge." Robert Coles, The Lancet

"The great virtue of this book is the author's esential even handedness. He is an astute clinician...alert to the way new knowledge can becloud as well as inform..." Robert Coloe, The Lancet

"The author wants us to examine closely the way our thinking about diseases in the abstract effects our relationship with our patients...those broader social and cultural matters as they bear down on the daily encounters that take place in medical offices across the world, and especially among the priveledged, health-conscious bourgeoisie of the western world." Robert Coloe, The Lancet

"...in this century, we have acquired an astonishing body of knowledge about the mechanisms of various diseases, and this book in no way underestimates or undervalues that knowledge." Robert Coles, The Lancet

"...an insightful book focused on 20th-century medical developments and based on his own clinical experiences with chronic disease. ...should be read by everybody who cares for the future of medicine." Inquirer

"His argmumentation is lucid, temperate, and scholarly. His intention is to open his readers' eyes to the historical contingencies and unexamined assumptions that underpin medical knowledge. His case studies wil be substantively interesting to psychiatric audiences, but it would be a mistake to ignore the book's larger imlications for psychiatry. Aronowitz's splendid book points us in this direction." Allan Young, Ph.D., The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease

See all Editorial Reviews

Product Details

• Hardcover: 286 pages
• Publisher: Cambridge University Press; 1 edition (February 13, 1998)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0521552346
• ISBN-13: 978-0521552349
• Product Dimensions: 9.3 x 6.3 x 1 inches
• Shipping Weight: 1.2 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
• Average Customer Review: 5.0 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (1 customer review)
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #404,881 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)

More About the Author

Discover books, learn about writers, read author blogs, and more.

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Making sense makes sense, September 7, 2001

By 

"drvic" - See all my reviews

This review is from: Making Sense of Illness: Science, Society and Disease (Cambridge Studies in the History of Medicine) (Paperback)

This is a clearly thought out and clearly written discourse on how the forces that define and sanction "disease" are strong and operative within social, economic, and historical contexts. Taking such diseases as polio and lyme disease Aronowitz nicely traces these forces at work. His section on caridiology and the evolution of risk factors and Type A personality as similar social constructions and their impact is truly exquisite. Sensibility and perspective without hype or shallow ridicule.