Review
Anyone familiar with young children will recognize their tendency to ask the same question over and over again, which can be either annoying or endearing. In this case, it's the latter; the title question is repeated in the voice of a small child, accompanied by evocative soft-focus paintings of a triad of families: foxes, rabbits, and of course, humans, all peering at the sky and noting the signs of approaching winter. These signs differ for each kind of family: for people, Our jam is made; for foxes, Our fur is thick; and for rabbits, Our brown turns white. The scene is set with just a few words: The wind is brrrr. The bushes bare. The berries picked, and the text's quiet tone complements perfectly the images of a snug farm, a deep blue wintry sky, and the three sets of loving mothers and children going about their business. This simple, beautiful portrayal of anticipation answers young children's desire for reassurance as well as information. --
BooklistThree children - a fox, a rabbit and a human girl - each ask their respective Mamas the title question. Carlstrom's gently repetitive, more-or-less rhythmic delivery abets a sense of inevitability to the proceedings, appropriately...Even though the Mamas' initial answers are in the negative, they help their children see the signs that indicate the arrival of winter. --
Kirkus Reviews
About the Author
Paul Tong is the illustrator of
Some Babies Sleep by Cynthia Cotton and
Pecos Bill by Stephen Krensky. He lives in Berkeley, California.