Customer Reviews

The Mammoth Book of Best New Horror 19

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Last year's volume recently won the British Fantasy Society Award for Best Anthology of the Year, and deservedly so -

- but what about this year's Volume 19, which is one of the longest in the series, a total - from cover to cover - of 640 pages?

Simply put, these are the best short stories you'll read this year, period. In ANY genre. 'Nuff said.

(This review comes from an advance copy bought at the FantasyCon, Nottingham England book launch on September 20th, 2008. Twelve of the contributors were on hand to sign the book. Only 50 advance copies were made available for the launch.)

If you haven't already done so, I urge you to seek out Volume 18, for not only is it itself an award-winning book, but so are three of the stories inside: Elizabeth Hand, Gene Wolfe and Geoff Ryman. Also included in last year's volume are brilliantly blazing stories by Glen Hirshberg, David Morrell, Al Sarrantonio (editor of the massive 999 anthology a few years back), Richard C. Matheson and an 88 page novella by the alwasy consistently dependable Kim Newman!

Volume 19 of "Best New Horror" contains a collection of short stories (ranging in length from around 10 pages to around 60) loosely based around the horror genre. Each story was entertaining in its own right, though some carried more of a punch than others. I will say that while all of the stories were good, none were particularly frightening. This book (and all I've read in its series) are great to pick up used.

The first handful of stories in this massive book were entertaining, but then it turned into a bunch of nonsensical drivel. Many of the stories in the latter half of the book almost turned this into an aviation anthology as I was tempted to hurl it against a wall. If you don't have enough good material to make the book 800 and some pages, cut it back a little for crying out loud.