From School Library Journal
Grade 2-5-After a brief explanation of the Ice Age, the team that created Giant Shark (2000) and Dinosaurs with Feathers (2001, both Clarion) introduces the various mammoths and their relatives and then describes some of the most important fossil finds and what scientists have learned from them. Arnold doesn't shy away from the difficult names and vocabulary required by this topic, but her clear explanations aid readers in understanding the time period, the relationships among the various species, and the scientific processes involved in studying fossils. Caple's watercolors are realistic, detailed, and surprisingly beautiful. A soft sunset behind a row of traveling mastodons, the hint of a stand of evergreens glimpsed through snow and mist, the glow of torchlight on the face of a prehistoric painter all draw readers into the mystery of these lost animals and the humans who saw them. An index makes this a useful research tool, but fans of prehistoric mammals will read the book cover to cover. Barbara Hehner's Ice Age Mammoth (Crown, 2001) covers some similar information but focuses on the discovery of the Jarkov mammoth.
Ellen Heath, Orchard School, Ridgewood, NJCopyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 3-5. New discoveries of mammoth fossils continue to tell us more about the behavior and world of these fascinating beasts. Arnold introduces the subject in six accessible chapters that consider the first and last mammoths, their relatives, and the value of mammoths to prehistoric peoples. The information is brief but thorough, with realistic watercolor illustrations depicting the giant animals and their surroundings. Scientific names appear in italics, and pronunciation guides are in parentheses. In contrast to the ecological approach in Aliki's
Wild and Wooly Mammoths (1996), the emphasis here is how researching mammoth bones helps us learn about the animals' behavior, surroundings, and the reasons they became extinct. An informative presentation, not overly scientific in tone and sure to appeal.
Julie CumminsCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved