1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
An impressive story, yet without much evidence, March 14, 2001
This review is from: Man As The Prayer: The Origin and Nature of Humankind (Paperback)
Lee's book, "Man As The Prayer", offers interesting speculations into the origins of humankind. He explains the importance of rain and horses in the evolution of humans as signs that the annual mating season (he believes that males and females lived separately for much of their evolution) of these hominoids was near. He further tells about how these signs became incorporated into the prayers of the males who were hopeful to meet with females. Therefore, he interprets what most archaeologists term "Acheulean hand axes" as stone raindrops made to supplement their prayers. He also says that the European cave paintings of horses (among other animals) depict the males' prayers for horses to come because the females traveled with horses in search of food and water. Although reproduction is obviously important to the survival of a species, I personally believe that ancient hominoid lives were more difficult Lee interprets them. Why wouldn't males use tools to hunt (which would be beneficial considering their decreasing body and canine size) instead of to attract females? This explanation (and others that Lee's book contradicts)seems much more plausible to me.
Lee's book is an interesting and impressive story with sufficient documentation for the points that have evidence to back them up. He also shows knowledge of modern non-human primates, which can be used to infer characteristics of ancient hominoids. However, for much of the information in the book, there is no evidence. It seems that Lee has used some sparse archaeological evidence to make inferrences that should not be made from that little evidence. Much about how ancient hominoids lived cannot be suggested by fossil evidence, and many of Lee's speculations cannot be proven by studies of non-human primates (such as the use of flowers and the beginnings of language being based on mating).
"Man As The Prayer" is an interesting book that contradicts many of the suggestions about ancient hominoid lives. It offers a refreshing view on human evolution; however, there is not much evidence to back up Lee's speculations.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Uncommon Speculations About Human Evolution, February 20, 2001
This review is from: Man As The Prayer: The Origin and Nature of Humankind (Paperback)
How and why did humans evolve differently from baboons and chimpanzees from our common ancestor?
The common nature of evolutionary science is to establish a hypothesis, and then develop a methodology to test it. Generally, the brilliance is on the testing side. Daring hypotheses are few and far between. In this interesting book, Mr. Yup Lee develops daring hypothesis after daring hypothesis and stops short of formulating the tests. I have graded the book for the intelligence of its hypotheses, and not graded it down for lack of tests.
Having recently read a great deal of Dr. Jane Goodall's popular works about chimpanzees, I feel just barely adequate to consider Mr. Lee's work. This book is very thoroughly footnoted though, so you can use the references to locate many scientific sources if you want to learn more. That will be valuable to those who lack formal training in this area, but find the subject interesting.
One reason I like daring hypotheses is because they stimulate my imagination. Mr. Lee is an extremely imaginative thinker on human evolution.
He uses three primary methods to come up with his ideas. First, he imagines the circumstances that could have led to creating isolated populations that could have evolved in genetically independent paths (like happens on isolated islands, such as in the Galapagos) for humans, baboons, and chimpanzees. I thought this was a valid approach and his conclusions seemed quite plausible.
Second, he looks for common word roots around the world to detect connections between ancient populations. This was very interesting, and raised my sensitivity to patterns that I, too, had noticed in the past. I was not always as comfortable with these conclusions as Mr. Lee is. Maybe I'm just dense, but I could come up with many alternative conclusions from the ones presented here that seemed just as plausible or more plausible.
Third, he considers the differences among baboons, chimpanzees and humans in terms of how these serve a biological purpose and tries to develop a set of circumstances that would have let these differences prosper. I thought that his arguments in this regard about the different degrees of obviousness about females being fertile was well done and a useful extension of my understanding of evolutionary biology.
The most imaginative part of the book is that he connects the obvious dots of human evolution in new ways to form a different chronology, and a different cause and effect cycle. He sees that tool making, art, and spirituality probably evolved out of mating rituals rather than as a focus of hunting. In fact, he argues (and persuasively) that mating is more central to human evolution than is usually appreciated. Certainly, this perspective is an accurate view of chimpanzees, our closest genetic relative. Why should it not be very true of humans also? I suspect it is only our tendency to glorify our species as being different and better than other species that causes us to underestimate the mating instinct's role in our progress.
My own reaction was that I found it rather nice that mating could have so many positive benefits (at least potentially in this scenario).
I do hope that some who read this book will have the knowledge and skill to develop tests to check these ideas, help better hypotheses see the light of day, and increase our rate of learning about human evolution.
I suspect that this way of thinking would be helpful in solving current human problems as well. For example, how did environmental factors contribute to creating the problem? What does the language we use about the problem reveal about our conceptions of the issue? How did the current situation evolve our of basic human instincts?
Be open to new ideas by conceptually connecting the dots in new ways, and seeing if they make sense! Then test your ideas in practical ways.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting reading, February 19, 2001
This review is from: Man As The Prayer: The Origin and Nature of Humankind (Paperback)
In the three years I have been reviewing there are occasions when I get a chance to go outside the normal channels and find something that peaks my interest and the book Man as prayer is one of those times.
Lee takes the reader on a journey through man's origins in a spiritual way that makes the reading both fascinating and enjoyable. The book is very well written and easy to read and follow along, there wasn't any real lag to the book.
I was treated to the growth of man and the origins of how spirituality became the foundation of everyone. The author is able to convey ideas that are convincing and his arguments are well documented.
The book stays away from the "meaning of life" premise and delves deep in the mind and sole of spiritual awareness. You need to have a very open mind in order to truly understand what the author is trying to explain.
There are no slow parts to the book and after reading this you may have a whole new outlook on things.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No