22 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Kindly Portrait of Julius and Ethel, January 7, 2002
This review is from: The Man Behind the Rosenbergs (Hardcover)
There is much more to this book than the story of Julius and Ethel Rosenberg, but it is for the Russian viewpoint of this story that I bought the book. Having read the recently published book The Brother I wanted to read this book to compare the two. Alexander Feklisov paints a kindly picture of Julius Rosenberg as being an individual who sympathized with the plight of the Jews in Germany during World War II. Julius felt the Russians bore the brunt of the fighting against Nazi Germany and he wanted to do whatever he could to help them. Since Russia was an ally of America during World War II he wanted to do what he could to be of assistance since he wasn't in the front lines fighting the Nazis. Julius comes across as a rather kindly and meek individual and a genuine friendship between him and Feklisov developed. Rosenberg's biggest contribution to Russian intelligence was in providing them with the proximity fuse in which an explosive shattered when it neared an airplane causing damage instead of having to score a direct hit on the plane. Julius's wife Ethel was aware and sympathetic of her husband's activities, but was otherwise not involved. Whether she actually did any typing of her brother's, David Greenglass', notes is still questionable. It may very well have been David's wife, Ruth. David worked at Los Alamos in a machine shop and provided what information he could on America's efforts to develop an atomic bomb, but his childish sketches of a lens was of no value according to Feklisov. David Greenglass agreed to turn against his sister and brother-in-law in exchange for immunity for his wife Ruth and a prison sentence for himself. The Rosenbergs could have fled to Russia when things got "hot", but they wanted to remain close to Ruth because she was in a hospital recovering from burns suffered in an accident. From reading this book and The Brother I conclude that the Rosenbergs' hatred was against Nazism and their treatment of the Jews and not against America. As he saw it, Julius was helping an American ally (Russia) to fight an American enemy (Germany). The book is also interesting in showing the precautions spies take in their meetings. At a time when Communism was a hot topic in the early 1950's it is questionable whether the Rosenbergs received the fairness they deserved. The book covers much more including Feklisov's role along with John Scali during the Cuban Missile Crisis, but I'll limit my review to the case of the Rosenbergs since that is the part of the book I was most interested in.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Especially recommended for students of "Cold War" era, January 9, 2002
This review is from: The Man Behind the Rosenbergs (Hardcover)
The Man Behind The Rosenbergs is the personal and candid memoir of Alexander Feklisov, a KGB spymaster. This fascinating, compelling account in Feklisov's own words relates his claims of a close friendship to Julius Rosenberg (whom Feklisov felt was wrongly executed) and his duty as a secret messenger who helped bring to an end the terrifying tension of the Cuban Missile Crisis in 1962. Especially recommended for students of "Cold War" era, The Man Behind The Rosenbergs is a revealing, gripping narrative, impossible to put down from first page to last!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Written by an unapologetic secret policeman, July 22, 2010
Feklisov, an NKVD agent involved in spying on America and Britain during WWII and the years immediately afterwards, has put together a book detailing his first-hand knowledge regarding Klaus Fuchs, Julius Rosenberg and other spies who helped the Soviets copy the atomic bomb. Feklisov portrays the spies in a sympathetic manner and makes the case that Rosenberg was not instrumental in the construction of a Soviet bomb and should therefore not have been executed. He paints a portrait of the spies who helped the communists as being "progressive," "interested in humanity above nationalism," "seeking solidarity with the Soviet Army which was taking the brunt of the fighting."
Yes, I suppose to people who are not students of WWII this sounds very plausible but in fact when Hitler invaded Poland he had a secret ally in Stalin, who invaded Poland from the east. NKVD agents like Feklisov murdered the majority of the Polish army officer corps in the woods of Katyn by shooting them one by one in the back of the head. And before Hitler attacked the USSR the USSR was practicing its own brand of imperialism by invading Finland (with disastrous results), Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania and forcing Romania to give up Besserabia. Indeed, Stalin is rarely mentioned by Feklisov and the purges only in passing.
Communist agents who betrayed their countries on behalf of the USSR are certainly treated with kid gloves in this book. I would be interested to hear Feklisov's opinion of General Vlasov, whose Russian Liberation Army fought the Reds on the Eastern Front, or the nationalists from Estonia, Latvia, the Ukraine, Lithuania, Georgia and Tartaria who opposed Soviet domination. And Feklisov seems to be genuinely surprised that the attitude in the US and Britain towards the USSR changed following the war, despite the fact that the Soviets were busy installing puppet states in eastern Europe and causing trouble in occupied Germany. This is nothing, however, to his amazement at the "spy mania" in the two countries, even as he busily handled several agents who were doing what they could to help a foreign power hostile to democracy and freedom.
Feklisov's excuses for Rosenberg fall rather flat. Julius Rosenberg saw fit to provide the Soviets with a working proximity fuze, something they had failed to develop for themselves and probably would not have had for years if not for cockroaches like him. He assisted the Soviets in radar and more importantly recruited several agents involved in the Manhatten Project. Rosenberg was asked to swear an oath to the U.S.... if he wanted to help the USSR instead he should have refused, get denied a clearance and hop on a ship to Leningrad where he would have been used as cannon fodder and earn his wish to die for communism. Instead he betrayed America and not only is it right that he be executed for treason but I'm sure there are dozens of others who should have been as well.
Despite its point of view and its warped view of the world there are some interesting bits and pieces about communist subversion which are worth wading through. Illustrated with some photos.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No