Customer Reviews

Management 3.0: Leading Agile Developers, Developing Agile Leaders (Addison-Wesley Signature Series (Cohn))

5 star:		(14)
4 star:		(7)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I came to Jurgen's book with the hope of learning something new in the world of management, Management 3.0 (what ever that means).

What I found was a restatement of many tried and true principles. Few new practices, some cleaver pictures, and some misinformed notions around the examples he uses to support his thesis.

First to the thesis, as I can best deduce it. This appears as Jurgen says in the "Story of This Book," to be a personal story, taking ten years to write. A personal set of anecdotes and experiences informed by some references. These references are a source of disappointment. At the bottom of many pages are links to suggested supporting materials. These look like references, they are not. Regarding references, most of the bibliography is solid restatements of the agile thesis, all good stuff. Where Jurgen goes off track is when he tries to connect science to his thesis of management. The science analogies are simple minded and as a biased reader with a physics (practicing for some years) background I wince at the naive approach. Getting past that, I found some of the thoughts compelling.

There is solid evidence that management needs improvement. But there are many advice books already in place. Nearly every chapter starts with a slight put down of what didn't work in the past, then a weakly connected set of references for the 3.0 ideas, which are a re-statements in Jurgen's parlance - of ideas, practices and principles already in print. So the question is "why read this book, when there is really not much new there?"
Well the answer is in the nuggets that can be found sprinkled in the 400 or so pages. And there are some nuggets.
The notion that management is a complex adaptive system is well developed; this is not new of course. What is useful here is the connection of the processes in simple picture. Page 13 starts the process.

But the downside of this approach is that the book does not build on the past, but instead attempts to distance the thesis from the past and replace it with a new paradigm. The 3.0 approach. There no problem in doing that. Many authors do exactly that. Collins, Norton and Kaplan, Osterwalder's Business Modeling. But take a look at Eccles, Beyond the Hype: Rediscovering the Essence of Management. Use that book as a window into any 3.0 suggestion.

What is troubling with Jurgen's approach is that it is essentially a personal narrative of how to improve the management of software development. It reminds me of David Schmaltz's book, "The Blind Men and the Elephant, another personal journey through the domain of management. Entertaining reading perhaps, but unlike David's book, Jurgen's is 400 pages and lists for $45. Not a good return on investment for restating other people references.

In the end there are good things in the book, but you've got to work hard to find them. The writing style didn't resonant with me. It's filled with quips that make no sense except maybe to Jurgen. One of my favorites of about managing the system not the people (page 154). This is around self-organization. Jurgen's reference is Prigogine's discovery, which of course has been hugely expanded since the 1984 publication. This is typical of the references. A seminal work 30 years ago, that obviously influenced the author, but not a lot of follow up on the evolution of those ideas to today's interpretation.

On this page Jurgen states "a football team self-organizes with the boundaries of the playing field and the rules." It dawned on me that the word "football" is not the same word I use for "football." Meaning the American Football, because that football team is not self-organizing on the field and follows a strict play book (expect in the broken play). This became my understanding of Jurgen's approach - it's through his eye, his culture, his experiences. It's a dairy of his journey to "Management 3.0"
So in the end when I discovered the underlying theme - personal experience and narrative - I was able to step back from my hope that the ideas in the book were tested in some way outside that personal experience.

If you're interested in sharing Jurgen's journey this is the book. If you're looking for academically sound, field tested processes this probably isn't it. Collins' Good to Great, Shenhar and Dvir's Reinventing Project Management, and an much more practical book, Goodpasture's Project Management the Agile Way: Making it Work in the Enterprise.

Like many books in the agile domain these days, they are personal anecdotes, because that's what they are intended to be. So I'd recommend the down loaded version (cheaper) and look to Goodpasture as a better source for managing agile projects and read Beyond the Hype to get calibrated.

As the editors of the platform for agile management we were curious to read Jurgens book. That's what we think of it (the full review can be found at: http://p-a-m.org/2011/03/book-review-management-3-0/):

Jurgen's book offers a considerable amount of knowledge, combining agile and complexity thinking. It provides an overview of many theoretical elements, tries to inspect and adapt scientific theories and uses interesting imagery and analogies to better understand systemic interrelations. While appreciating Jurgen's compilation of various building blocks, we can't help asking what's actually new in it. Neither can we see a creative combination of these building blocks, nor do we understand how it justifies the label of supposedly future-oriented management 3.0. We understand how this book raises interesting theoretical challenges, but we ask ourselves how these are to be resolved by applying well-known not to say old-fashioned principles, guidelines or checklists?

Furthermore, what is the specific link between Jurgen's management approach and the agile approach to team-based leadership? If complexity is best dealt with by teams (as proposed by agile methods), why does the author seemingly deal with the complexity of management as such all by himself? How does that translate into the advice he's giving, e.g. "how do I select an authorization level?" (p.129)? Is that indeed necessarily an (arbitrary) solitary decision by one manager? Why shouldn't management be team sports as well?

What we got out of the book:
1) a broad overview of many relevant theories and sources that could be helpful when it comes to clarifying current challenges.
2) a lot of basics that could serve as a kick-off for beginners or students.
3) the challenge for us to think more in-depth about management in agile and other environments.
4) the challenge to inspect and adapt what Jurgen offered in order to keep the discussion about the future of management alive - whether this future is agile or not.

Sigi Kaltenecker and Thomas Spielhofer

Jurgen managed to write a book that links the tons of books he has read. Although there were a few moments I did not agree with him, I loved the way this book challenges my thinking. This is the perfect book if you want to know how to create your own answers in this complex world.

As a Master of Change management I am always keen on books about change & leadership, how to bring people and their organizations to the next level. Although the book is easy to read and funny the content is solid. I highly recommend this book to senior management, because it gives a great opportunity to reflect on personal experiences. Jurgen Appelo proves he understands chaos & complexity, especially by providing very valuable suggestions for daily practice.

This book was recommended to me by Mike Cohn at his Agile Product Owner Training in Silicon Valley. I am impressed with the depth, richness and intelligence of this book. It takes the concepts of Agile and it's predecessors in the studies of Cybernetics, Complexity Theory and Adaptive Systems. The narrative then expands these ideas based on the author's personal experience to provide a full management framework.

This book clearly defines the logical next step in the evolution of Agile development: combining Agile methodology with classic organizational management theory to help leaders build teams that are dynamic, motivated and relevant. As a manager of Internet product development at a multi-national company with web properties in over 50 countries, I am already using what I learned in this book to transform the way my team works.

Jurgen's book is right on and I strongly recommend it. I have seen other reviewers comment that to an extent it was re-packaging and nothing original; however, I disagree. First of all I am not aware of any other book that approaches leadership (not limited to Agile) through the lense of complexity theory. This is a unique lense and one that has allowed me to look at problems differently. I feel that the overview of past literature was more of a process of building up to and laying the foundation for the final concepts. At any rate this is in my top 5!

Jurgen Appelo is an insightful leader and engaging author. In Management 3.0, he combines these strengths to illuminate many of the most fundamental principles that influence successful delivery of software in our modern and unpredictable climate where agility is a must. But this book is not about software development, per se. At its core, it's a book about leadership - about management. Upon a foundation based on the science of Complexity Theory and recognizing that organizations are Complex Adaptive Systems, Jurgen delivers practical and pragmatic guidance for getting the most out of our teams. This guidance combines rock solid research with tried-and-true practices across an array of critical management concerns including Empowerment, Competence, Communication, Constraints, Change Management, and Structure. Realistic and down-to-earth, I don't remember any recent work that stands to have as great an impact on the performance of organizations across the globe.

Jurgen Appelo made a bold move. Being an experienced IT manager and entrepreneur, he wrote a book that goes far beyond the agile software development realm, and dances with other disciplines such as complexity theory, systems theory and management. It is not rare then that, as many other works that dare cross borders, his book is sometimes criticized by experts from the other fields (complexity, management) that see his approach as naïf. On the other hand, many people see his book as a collection of ideas that are not necessarily original, but rather taken from thousands of other works (e.g. motivational theory, among others).

Now, is the book naïf on complexity theory? Maybe, but I think it does not intend to be heavy on the subject, but rather use complexity theory lightly to help understand what happens in most software development settings. Is the book completely original in what respects to management theories? Maybe not, but again, is it necessary to reinvent everything?

I think this book is a useful handbook for everyone that intends to "agilize" an organization. I reinforce the word "handbook", since a "handbook" is neither necessarily a scientific piece of work nor a 100% original contribution to the field, but rather a value-added compilation of techniques useful for a particular situation. Classics such as McConnell's Code Complete or Rapid Development are in this category, in my opinion. Jurgen's book has more individual contributions that most handbooks, but anyway, I like to have it in this category.

I think Management 3.0 is both useful for experienced managers and for techies recently turned managers. For the first group, it will serve as a way to refresh concepts seen in MBAs or management books, but with an agile flavor. For the second group, it will serve as a very practical, down-to-earth, guide to management concepts.

Still, there are a few things I didn't like that much of this book. On the first place, it's heavy emphasis on "left brain thinking": I think there is a lot of "right brain" thinking in software development that must not be avoided. On the second place, the narrative style is a bit "Jurgen centric" and maybe too informal for more traditional managers. Finally, the name "Management 3.0" is just too generic and pretentious ... less criticism would have arisen with a bit less bombastic name. :)

All in all, I recommend this book to managers interested in making their organizations and teams more fertile for agile approaches.

What a fascinating, deeply-technical and well-researched read on agile management. We bought a copy of this book for every manager in our group and all have enjoyed the journey they've taken with it. I personally took quite a bit longer than originally expected to get through the book, but that's part of what is so great about it. Appelo takes his time diving deep into each chapter's subject matter, taking a highly technical and pragmatic approach to the topic. He ends each chapter with a call for Reflection and Action and I encourage all to take some time on these activities to immediately apply these theories in practice.

This was such an interesting book that really helped me form some of the ideas that I was grasping at while leading a team of 4 managers and their direct reports through an agile transformation. I continuously heard the question, "what are we managers supposed to do now?" This book provides 400+ pages of answers and follow-on questions to that question and so much more.

What I love about this book, beyond the book itself, is that I found Appelo through the book and have continued to follow his insights on his blogs at[...] and [...], as well as on Twitter @jurgenappelo.

A fabulous contribution to aid understanding of Agile Management against the background of Complexity Science. Thoroughly researched and referenced - but written in a style that reads easily and aids understanding. Jurgen's diagrams are brilliant - emphasizing that there's no need to become arrogant about what we understand and that the journey continues.