Customer Reviews

Manna from Heaven

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

This is a great movie about real people from a real neighborhood. It showed what can happen when a bunch of ordinary people pool the skills - and their love - to work on a common project (raising the money) that most of them thought they no longer had the drive/passion/whatever to do because they had become resigned to living in their limited ways.

As for for the reviewer who said it was unrealistic, they probably don't understand a few things, such as:
1. In real life, a lot more money ($1 mil plus) fell out of the back of a Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia truck and was recovered in a neighborhood. They also made a so-so movie out of that story.
2. If you're 57 like I am, you know that $3,300 apiece could have bought you a new Cadillac in the late 1950s-early 60s, so it was enough to finance educations or trade school tuitions. And a doctor's visit did cost under $20.
3. The emotional parts were very realistic. Some of the people argued to keep the money and some argued to give it back to the police -a realistic difference of opinion. I can't say more or I give away too much of the story.
4. The opening scenes showed people who were taken in to another's home. People did take in other people to their homes more often in those days, helping one another altruisticly. Everyone didn't live 3 superhighway exits away in the suburbs. For example, when my own mother had a gall bladder operation in the 1950s, a woman friend of the family took me into her home for a few weeks one summer.

The writer is a real, middle class person from Buffalo, where the story is set, who raised 5 daughters. She speaks naturally in the DVD special features (and is in the movie as one of the dance school clients with her real husband). She looks and sounds like a Northeastern neighbor, not a fast talking Hollywood writer driving around in a Mercedes that is 3 payments overdue.

I will go so far as to say that if you don't see the spiritual truths from real life in this movie, you are still being affected by a harsh, fearfull, negative upbringing. I suggest you watch the movie again and see what you can learn from it.

Most of the criticisms aimed at this movie are probably accurate, as far as they go. Yes, this isn't a great movie. It's the film equivalent of watching a high school drama club put on a play -- it's not going to be a top Broadway production, but it can make up for its lack of professionalism with a great deal of heart and good intentions.

If you judge this film strictly by technical or artistic merits, it's not going to rate very high. But if you can set aside your regular standards a bit and just sit back and enjoy it, you'll have a good time. If nothing else, it's got a great cast and is a sweet natured tribute to those old "Let's put on a show" movie!

Not all movies have to be Cannes film festival winners. Some just have to make you smile, and this one did.

It's rare that an indie film can leave you smiling. This one has that thing you don't see often in the art houses, let alone the multiplexes -- heart. A movie about families and about doing the right thing.

I grew up in WNY, so it was especially fun to watch this movie, which was filmed in Buffalo.
I'm certainly no Roger Ebert, but I did enjoy the story enough to give this a thumbs up.

I suppose that you could say that this is a simple movie. It doesn't pretend to be some big budget, over the top, award-winning film. It also is not pretentious. It is a movie that simply tells a story of a family that comes into some money in an unusual way, and has to deal with the consequences of that windfall in the future. I enjoyed the story - even when the story seemed a bit farfetched. In fact, I found it to be a charming family-type movie.

Money comes around this family once. They go make their millions,
then give it away again.

It's like that well-known line on that antacid commercial: "I can't believe I ate the whole thing!" In this case, I can't believe I sat through all 120 minutes of this bland cabbage soup looking for any redeeming chunk of beef. Theresa "the saint" had about as much character and persuasion as overcooked spaghetti, and Inez's attempt at slick edginess seemed overdone. Not to mention the nauseatingly awkward sexual references which I'm sure were thrown in only to garner a more mature rating. There was no LIFE in this film whatsoever, from the wooden dialogue to the flatness of the waltz contest. It was impossible to enjoy even for what it was; I recommend you at least rent this before you clear space in your movie collection.

My husband rented this film for me and our eight year old thinking it would be a good "family film." In the words of our daughter, who is a discriminating movie critic - "This movie makes no sense! You can't tell how the people are related to each other - they want you to think that they are all getting to be better people, but really, they are just getting better at lying and stealing." The plot is implusable and confusing, the characters are hard to feel very attached to, and as my husband said, "if the best actor played second fiddle in the dopey sit com "Just Shoot Me," you know the movie is bad. He apologized for bringing it home to us.