Most Helpful Customer Reviews
21 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Extremely Controversal Book and Author, September 14, 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Manson: Behind the Scenes (Paperback)
Having just re-read this book in the wake of the newest controversies regarding the author, I have to admit that most Manson Scholars probably should own a copy if only for the greater understanding that reading it will allow them. For those who do not know, Bill Nelson is a Self-styled Manson Researcher who has put out several self-published books (this one included) on various tangent aspects of the case including a book on Tex Watson. Unfortunately, owing to its self-publication, this book lacks the guiding hand of a competant editor which results in literally dozens of grammatical and spelling errors per page. In addition, names of key players are often spelled three different ways and basic words are misused. This adds to a sense of confusion that permeates the book. Now, given all that.. let me tell you what you can learn from this book: As troubling as the Manson Saga is, troubling still has been the manner in which people have become obsessed with the case to the point where it dominates their lives. Nelson is a prime example of a True-Crime buff so caught up in his research that he himself has become the obsession of other True-Crime Buffs. In his writings, he openly describes enaging in behavior that most readers would find alarming such as dogging the steps of the wives of convicted Manson Family Members as well as injecting himself deeply into the lives of the Victim's families. His chapter on Manson's Son alone was positively chilling in how he pursued this young man and how little a clue he had that what he was doing bordered on abuse and harassment. He gleefully describes taking surveillence photos of Tex Watson's wife and then sanctimoniously spouts off about his alleged Christian values as if this excuses such actions. For this reason alone, anyone studying Criminal Psychology should read this book. Keep in mind that is appropriate for a reviewer to comment upon the author because the author so carefully makes himself the center of the story he is telling. This is genuine criticism of the BOOK. The other reason to read it is the unfortunate fact that no other writer has addressed the subject of what has happened to the far flung members of the Family. One interesting thing to note is that if an Ex-Family member cozies up to the Author, they are protrayed as reformed members of society no matter how heinous their past behaviors and if the former member seeks to avoid these troubling intrusions, they get lambasted as unremorseful miscreants. Considering the power and influence of Nelson's huge Former Website on the murders, anyone unfortunate enough to have been associated with Manson becomes doubly unfortunate if they refuse to let this author delve deeply into their personal lives. There are myraid reviews here, most of them negative and with good reason. However, given the fact that Nelson himself has now become PART of the Manson story through his own actions, it would be foolish NOT to read this book and maybe even own a copy. Further, it is likely that this book will be even harder to come by in the near future than a copy of Ed Sanders' THE FAMILY with the all important excised chapter on The Process. Call me perverse, but I must admit to finding Nelson's material strangely compelling. If only for the unsettling tale of La Bianca's step-daughter "forgiving" Tex Watson and going on the Christian TV circuit, the book has it's strengths. If you want to read a less ethically challenged book on Manson and his crimes which encompasses Bill Nelson's research, you should look up Greg King's excellent and even-handed account of the crimes as they interwined with Sharon tate's life. It's deservedly selling very well and is the most complete telling of those sad crimes avaliable to date. What makes THAT book strong is that King documents every fact he cites by source in a strong and lenghty appendix. He takes what is useful from Nelson's research and leaves behind all the creepier aspects of it. Seriously, look up Greg King... he is an author on the brink of greatness. (by the way, I had no competant editor for this review, but I bet I still made far fewer typos and errors than in one entire chapter of MANSON BEHIND THE SCENES!)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
very weak book, July 2, 1999
By A Customer
This review is from: Manson: Behind the Scenes (Paperback)
This book glows of an author completely enamered with himself,snapping photos of innocent children, stalking people to get an interview for his book, and other mental sicknesses. The spelling errors are atrocious,he blocks out swear words throughout the book,then adds in blunt crime scene photos that make your stomach turn,what sense does that make? This "author" is almost as weird as the killers themselves.He seems to worship at the temple of his own narcissism. Dave
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Wealth of Manson info buried beneath a huge private agenda, December 24, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: Manson: Behind the Scenes (Paperback)
This is a very troubling book and one that is not easy to review. It is a unique book, in that it alone attempts to bring curious readers up to date on the current status of the far-flung members of both Manson's Hardcore Family following as well as those who were loosely associated with the group. Bill Nelson, the author, is a self-publishing researcher whose enthusiasm for digging up Manson-minutia is unparalleled. However, the means to which he has stooped to gather this info is troubling - very troubling. A self-professed Christian who thinks nothing of using specialized databases of Private Investigators to ferret out home addresses of people who wish to remain forgotten and who then parks outside their homes with cameras does not to me appear to have a greater grasp of Christ's message. However, occasionally Nelson does succeed through these abhorrant methods in bringing to light truths that are even more troubling than his investigative techniques. For instance, Nelson alone has dogged Tex Watson mercilessly to expose how he he has built up a So-called Christian Ministry whose sole purpose seems to be to gather donations which are then funneled to cover his Wife and kids' living expenses. Even more disgusting is the revelation that Tex, who made sure Roman Polanski's first child died days before his expected birth was granted sexual visits in prison which resulted in his wife conceived numerous children long after he had been sentenced to death. Nelson further exposed how the State of California then had to support these children of a child-killer. As bizarre as Nelson's personal motivations seem to be, one has admit that no other journalist covering the Manson Family behind bars has done more to expose this disgusting set of privileges (to marry, to have sex and to procreate all behind bars) that were at one time extended to convicted murderers. He also chronicles the outragious love lives of the Manson Women behind bars. Getting back to this book, it is a must-have book for anyone who is attempting to discuss the Manson Family in their own research simply due to the extraordinary detail present in the book. If one get past the hundreds of mispellings, the faulty Grammar, the overexploitation of exclamation points which borders on the absurd, then one can glean a great deal from this book. As wrong-headed as his analysis of the Doreen Gaul Murder is as it related to the Zodiac killings, his discussion of Doreen's murder is important and as detailed as possible. Her murder along with that of James Sharp was rather callously forgotten and miscategorized due to her quite innocent (for the times) interest in Scientology. Oh, one picking point: Nelson misidentifies a symbol she was wearing around her neck as a "scientology symbol" when in fact it was nothing more than an Egyptian Anhk (symbol of life) which was extremely popular with girls of her age during that era and in no way associated with the Church of Scientology. He also casts a undue sinister light on Doreen's use of well-known Scientology jargon which I found terribly offensive. Even so, I find myself thinking of Doreen who hailed from my own hometown and praying for her and her family. There's fodder for an entire book right there in the discussion of her sad demise. As mistaken as Nelson is about Scientology, he does manage to put forth the tragedy of her death. I do wish he had left out the photos of her naked and abused body. though, if at least out of respect for the family members he obviously plied for info. Perhaps the most startling info in the book deals with Suzan LeBarge's embracing of Tex Watson. Suzan was the daughter of Rosemary LaBianca and stepdaughter of Leno. His chronicles of her bizarre life are fascinating. Another freaky factoid contained in the book is Nelson's commentary on his friendhsip with a woman named Lisa who at one time inhabited the Guest House that William Garretson lived in during the murders. That fact that this woman later became intimate friends with Sharon Tate's sister and in fact lived with her until her death is just too strange. Check out Nelson's website for further weirdness involving Garretson new claim to have married the now grown child that Sharon Tate was carrying who claims she was spirited away from the scene after birth! Finally, this is certainly NOT the 1st book you should read to follow up on the Manson family. However, if you are a serious student of the times in question, one has to cave in and buy this highly personal book. If you can set aside the sour taste that Nelson leaves you with as he assasinates various characters, you will find that flawed though he is, Nelson is actually attempting in his own way to truly shed some light on the larger story. As for Nelson himself.. pray for him.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|