29 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent book on NCLB, July 28, 2005
The nationwide No Child Left Behind (NCLB) Act is the latest attempt to reform American education. It is supposed to do this through enforcing a system of standards and accountability through standardized testing. According to the authors in this book, NCLB actually hurts, instead of helps, children, especially urban children.
The biggest problem is that NCLB has been underfunded, by anywhere up to $12 billion. The states have all sorts of new federal mandates, but not enough money to pay for them. Standardized tests are valuable as a measure of a student's progress, but they should not be the only measure, which is the case with NCLB. Portions of the school curriculum that don't directly deal with testing, like art, phys ed and field trips, will be dropped, as schools become little more than test-prep factories.
A school can be classified as Failing if even one subgroup in the school, like Asains or disabled students, don't do well enough on the test. The school must then pay to bus its students who want to transfer to a non-failing school. If it is an inner-city school, their resources are already thin enough. There probably aren't any non-failing schools nearby, and besides, they have no incentive to accept students who might bring down their test scores. Urban schools, and urban communities in general, need a lot more help than to be told, "Raise your test scores, or else." Many schools have gotten in the habit of making students repeat a grade, raising the chance that they will eventually drop out, only because they might negatively affect the test score for the upper grade.
The most well-known non-education provision in NCLB forces schools to give student contact information to military recruiters, or face a cutoff of federal aid. Any policy that prevents participation in prayer in public schools, as well as any policy that prohibits the Boy Scouts or any other "patriotic society" access to school facilities. For these and many other reasons, the list of states refusing to follow NCLB is growing.
This is an excellent book. It shows that the public pronouncements about NCLB are much brighter than the reality. It's short, easy to read and highly recommended
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
31 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
NCLB is a "test and punish" mandate from the government., April 23, 2005
What is a well-educated child?
Is it one that can bubble in correct answers on a skills based test? Is life "multiple choice?"
Don't read this book if you don't want to become incredibly angry about what the NCLB is doing to our children. In an attempt to further the agenda that public schools are failing children, NCLB mandates (without adequate funding) are making teachers focus on basic skills to the detriment of higher level thinking. Teachers are being forced to focus so much on "drill and kill," students are hating school at an early age. Then, if schools don't perform adequately, they are punished and lose funding. If schools perform too well, they are scrutinized and suspected of cheating. As all of the powers that be argue over test results, children are the losers.
School districts are giving up such "fringe benefits" as recess, P.E., music, art, and performing arts, to make more time for worksheets. There is nothing for the soul anymore. Take a moment and reflect on one of your most positive memories as a child in school. Are YOU thinking of a worksheet? A test?
If your child is hating school, you have great cause to worry. Children that do poorly on standardized tests are considered for retention, after school programs, and other "interventions" that will make them hate it more. The testing only gets worse as they get older. Threatened with the possibility that they won't pass the tests for high school, many children give up and drop out. Then, your child really will have been left behind.
If you are wondering why your child doesn't love learning, and how come they feel like they are never working hard enough, you need to find out more about NCLB. This book is a great start!
While it is obvious that Melissa J. Chapman (apparently after reading my response to her review she deleted her comments) has an opinion that doesn't agree with the premise of this book, it is apparent in her review that she has not read this book, and therefore cannot give a valid opinion about its contents. I would say that if she actually did read this book, she should take the time to make a better argument for her statements. She obviously supports the ideology of NCLB because she is educated about testing, statistics, and measurement. I don't know if that qualifies her to say how NCLB is impacting classrooms. She qualifies anyone against standardized testing as engaging in "impassionate ranting."
I have been an elementary teacher for 16 years, hold a Master's Degree in Education, and hardly consider myself an uneducated and impassionate ranter. Statistics and measurement courses were a required part of my college degree. I am educated first hand by the detriment to classrooms that is the NCLB law. I have watched the curriculum in my classroom change students from energetic and enthusiastic learners to frustrated and defeated failures. I feel pressure from administration every day to eliminate the "fluff" of art, performing arts, P.E., social studies and more because of pressure to teach what will be tested. If our test scores don't improve dramatically, we will lose funding.
I am all for holding teachers accountable for their performance in a classroom. I only recently removed my daughter from a classroom where the teacher clearly had her own agenda to dismiss the teaching of writing because she obviously lacked the skills to do it. She didn't teach reading to the more capable students because I guess she felt they didn't need it. This is a teacher whose test scores were actually quite good. Why? Because capable students will score well on these tests anyway, in spite of a poor teacher. Were the tests an accurate reflection of the quality of teaching going on in the classroom? I think not. My child was coming home crying nearly everyday and for the first time saying that she hated school.
I agree with Melissa that we should educate ourselves before coming to a judgement. Actually reading this book and making some valid points about its premise is something that Melissa should do. Then we could read her review and hold some validity to her statements. If there is any impassioned ranting going on here, I would say that Melissa is the only one engaged in it.
Let's hold teachers accountable for not only teaching kids what they will need to know, but also make it a positive and fun experience going to school and feeling some level of success. NCLB only addresses half of the equation. Sadly, the more important half is missing.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Everyone should read this book!!, February 24, 2006
I am a teacher at a small rural school. The horrors of the way this law is implemented is far-reaching, even to our area of strong local control. The NCLB law is going to do the opposite of what it's well-intentioned (hopefully) authors wanted - destroy public education and create a wider chasm between the haves and have-nots. All good teachers know that this law leaves very little time or energy to teach the way we know REALLY attends to the development of children and is forcing the best teachers to consider leaving the profession. Many of us won't because we care about the kids so much.
This book, written by true experts in the field of educational research, explains so beautifully the reasons why the law is no good for our schools, and like the child in the EMPEROR'S NEW CLOTHES it tells the truth and screams to be heard. Somebody...PLEASE...send a copy to Mr. Bush.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
