Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Thomson fails to enlighten us, October 24, 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: Marlon Brando (A & E Biography) (Hardcover)
This biography is superficial and unworthy of its subject. David Thomson has his face pressed up against the glass of the window to Marlon Brando's life but fails to gain entry. His attempts to trivialize Mr. Brando's life, work, political opinions and involvement, reveal his own inability to see anything except through the prism of his own opinions. His constant digs about Mr. Brando's weight show a lack of compassion and understanding about such health problems. A more compelling analysis of Mr. Brando's films can be found elsewhere. Read Schickel, Bosworth, Grobel, Marlon's own autobiography, and newspaper and magazine accounts of his political activism. But skip this. Marlon Brando has long since proven himself as the greatest actor of our time. His continued courage to explore his own emotional limits has given us a wealth of inspired stage and film performances. He is by most accounts a compassionate, caring individual who has walked the walk of his convictions. Like the rest of us he has made some mistakes in his life, but on balance his is a life worthy of our praise.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
One long sneer from an intellectual snob, July 29, 2004
This review is from: Marlon Brando (A & E Biography) (Hardcover)
Marlon Brando was, according to David Thomson, brilliant and a genius when it came to acting but, the reader is repeatedly told, not very smart intellectually. In fact he was rather dim. So dim that he didn't really understand his own films or indeed his own life. So it is a good job we have film critics like Thomson to explain how wrong about everything Brando was. For example, when Brando said his childhood was rather unhappy because both his parents were alcoholics he was mistaken. Why? Because when Thomson looks at Brando family photos young Marlon is (albeit in a rather dim way) always smiling.
The only evidence that Thomson gives for Brando's lack of intelligence is his academic failure at school. The fact that he was dyslexic (a condition which wasn't even known at the time) is dismissed out of hand as a possibly relevant factor. Elia Kazan, on the other hand, was a college graduate so obviously he can't be dim. No he is, instead, ugly - again the reader is told this repeatedly.
Brando's weight problems, another cause of constant sniping, also appear to be connected to his lack of intelligence because, apparently, he was too dim to realise that he should be seeing nutritionists rather than psychiatrists. Which brings me to my main objection to this book: the constant sneering at Brando as a self indulgent fool because he went to see psychiatrists. What is the self indulgence in a person with mental or emotional problems seeking professional help to overcome them?
I have always thought that Brando suffered from some form of Bipolar disorder (which is to a large extent genetic). If he did it would explain so many of the things that happened in his life. It is also a condition which is almost invariably associated with above average intelligence.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
bad, just plain bad..., August 24, 2005
This review is from: Marlon Brando (A & E Biography) (Hardcover)
The one star is for the DK format, which is neat and nifty with good photographs and interesting captions that provide a historical and cultural context to Marlon Brando's time. The rest of the book is an unbearable read, no more than a hatchet job of writing and supposed "insights" into the life and work of Marlon Brando.
Using a present-tense narrative voice and a prose-style that would make an editor cringe, Thomson attempts to guide us through the highlights of Brando's life and career, providing not only stories and anecdotes but also "insights" into the inner-workings of Brando's troubled mind. Yes, Thomson gives us Brando's motivations. But he guesstimates more than anything else. He questions young Brando's nervous breakdown in New York; saying that it could be more Brando "acting up" than really a result of being overwhelmed by his mother's alcoholism and sadness. We find this type of condescension and conjecturing throughout the book. In addition Thomson pulls up gossipy muck such as possible abortions and homosexual encounters. We all know that Brando was no saint and downplaying his womanizing and tragic personal life would be irresponsible, but this book isn't worthy of the lowest porn movie extra, much less to one of our greatest acting talents and cultural icon. It has the tint of yellow journalism in glossy hardcover.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
