Most Helpful Customer Reviews
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Clever SF Ideas, Really Big Dumb Objects, Solid, not Great, December 11, 2000
The versatile and prolific Robert Reed is back with Marrow, a big novel about what is sometimes called a BDO, or Big Dumb Object. The BDO in this case is a huge spaceship, the size of Jupiter. Humans happen across it, and find it empty of life. They claim it, and turn it into a sort of tourist attraction: almost a cruise ship for cruising the Galaxy. Many separate species are hosted on the Ship, the passengers sometimes using the Ship to travel from star system to star system, but other times staying on for centuries or millennia, even joining the Ship's crew. The crew itself consists of a diverse variety of modified humans, including the Remoras, who live on the outside and repair the Ship's shell, and who have adapted to a lifetime spent in spacesuits; as well as the Captains, essentially immortal (like most humans), able to survive any injury that doesn't vaporize the head. The Master Captain has been with the Ship from its discovery, some 100,000 years. In all this time, nothing significant has been learned about the mysterious Builders of the Ship, or about the Ship's original purpose. But a great new discovery has been made: there is a strange, iron, world at the very core of the Ship. This world is named Marrow, and a picked crew of the Ship's best Captains, including the Master's right-hand woman, Miocene, and a very talented Captain called Washen, are assigned to find a way to reach Marrow, and to explore it. With great difficulty, they manufacture a path down to the surface of Marrow, only to find it destroyed soon after they reach the surface. Thus begins a 5000 year effort to find a way back to the ship: and even that is only part of the action, as the plot takes numerous twists and turns, and several ideas are advance to explain Marrow and the Ship: all culminating in an action-filled conclusion. The "Neat Idea" content of this book is impressive indeed. The Ship itself is a cool notion, and so is Marrow. Such inventions as the Remoras are also very fine, as are several of the alien species on the Ship. The plot drags a bit in the center portion, the long period spent on Marrow, but it is resolved pretty well, and with lots of excitement. There is a certain way in which things are almost too big, almost exhausting, and almost easy, in a way. This is a particular problem when considering the characters, Miocene and Washen and the others, who live for millennia but seem much like contemporary people. The magical tech which allows them to survive almost anything seems overconvenient at times, as well. But that's pretty much what you get when trying to consider such huge concepts: the characters are dwarfed, and so too are our usual standards for action and danger. For the most part, Reed delivers on the promises of this book: he promises Big Cool Ideas, and Action, and a satisfying resolution with at least something of an explanation for it all, and by and large, that's what Marrow has. It isn't fully successful, or fully involving on the character level, but it's pretty good.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Stands on its own, if you like audacity, October 17, 2000
Okay, first an editorial comment: I hate it when people review books on the basis of superficial resemblences to other works. This may have a big world ship, but that's where the resemblence to Rama ends, folks (nor was Rama the first: Heinlein's Universe, anyone?) -- if you want another Rama book, you should direct your comments to Clarke and Lee. Now, if you can get past that, this is a work that has, I think, a genuinely audacious storyline. Perhaps TOO audacious for some tastes. We are talking about a storyline with hundred-thousand year old characters who are entirely willing to, among other things, wait five-thousand years (building an entire civilization in the process) in order to rescue themselves from being marooned. The story is certainly an example of that grand old genre known as Space Opera. The science may be a tad "harder" than the old E.E. "Doc" Smith books, but only a tad. The sweep is epic and the characters are (quite literally) superhuman. People who are looking for either fine characterization or for hard technical science really should look elsewhere, because it ain't that sort of book. But if you can read it for what it is (especially if you are a fan of the old genre), I think that it stands up quite well. Certainly, it's not the perfect story -- the characters could have been rendered better, and the resolution seemed a bit forced -- but it is a GOOD example of what it is. The book only "fails" if one judges it on the basis of what is not. At least that's my (not all that humble) opinion.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
My First Exposure to Reed, October 13, 2000
Okay, I've read the other reviews...all bad and so I am in the unique position of offering an opinion at the opposite end of the spectrum. First why should you believe me over the masses??? Well I've read almost everything ever written by Niven, Bear, Brin, Benford, McDevitt, Card, Gibson, Stephenson, Herbert, Bova, Vinge...and so on. Thus I believe I know a good story when I read one. The idea of a large alien ship floating through space, with the builders long since vanished, has been tried before. I will say that this book is much better than the first Rama book, which at times read like an encyclopia. The last (3) books in the Rama series were great due in no small part I'm sure to input from Gentry Lee. Now back to Marrow. What I liked about the book was that it did include reference to aliens on the ship. The author does go into some detail about (2) of the species, the Remoras and the Harrum-Scarums. True the character development isn't anywhere near what David Brin does with his Uplift saga, but it's good enough to hold your interest. What I liked is that the plot was like an onion. On the outside you have this vast ship, then if you look deeper you find a planet inside called Marrow, and if you look deeper inside Marrow there's something else...and so on. The plot unravels just like this, and at no time does this book become predictable..something I'm sure the critics of this book would have to agree. When I rate a book I compare it to other books not only in writing styles and how the book flows, but does it put forth new ideas. The idea of a ship in space isn't new, but having 200 billion travellers from various races is unique. The idea that people can live forever and sustain incredible amounts of damage and still live (they grow new bodies for you), is new to me. The concept of Marrow itself is new as is the super strong material "Hyperflux" which holds the planet in place. Was the book great? No, but its certainly better than the last (3) bookes written by Jack McDevitt. I'd give this book 3.5 out of 5.0 stars and will certainly read more of Reed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|