Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Read Martyrs' War as a tribute to Michael Kelly, December 28, 2003
Accomplished journalist Michael Kelly died as an 'imbed' covering the war in Iraq. The Humvee he and his military escort were traveling in lurched facedown into a dike. I decided after hearing of this tragedy that I would honor his bravery by seeking out "Martyr's Day," described by his colleagues as *the* master work of Gulf War reporting. I was not disappointed. This is fabulous writing...and reporting. Reading 'War,' it comes as no surprise to know that Michael died in the middle of action. The book is rife with passage after passage of Kelly routinely putting his safety in jeopardy to get a story. Far from being a chonicle of simply Kuwait and Iraq, 'War' moves from Iraq to Jordan to Israel (via a complicated route through Cyprus - read the book to do this intricate travel itinerary justice) to Egypt to Saudi Arabia to a newly-liberated Kuwait. The book stays strong throughout. In fact, the two most powerful passages are towards the end: the first depicts - in shocking detail - the carnage on the so-called "Highway of Death" (the road back to Basra from Kuwait City); the second takes us deep into Kurdistan, where Kelly shows us what befalls those areas once the U.S. pulls its support for the post-Gulf War Kurd uprising. Kelly follows the ramifications of Saddam's lash back at the Kurds through to a set of refugee camps on the Iranian border. Kelly himself picks up and battles as nasty bout of dysentery from his treks through the camps and experiences first-hand how one could get so sick so quick. The book ends with his personal tale of escape through a smuggler's route and into Turkey. Other journalists traveling that same route are not so lucky: three that preceded Kelly are later found murdered. In addition to the inherent splendidness of Michael Kelly's writing, the reason 'War' remains a compelling read 12 years after the fact is due to the numerous threads that tie these events to what transpired in Iraq in 2003. For example, there are a couple of horrifying pages on Uday Hussein's thuggish domination of Baghdad nightlife in 1991. Obviously, things would only get worse from there.
|
|
|
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A war souvenir that is now an epitaph, May 21, 2003
As you probably know, Michael Kelly was killed in Iraq during the late war, at the height of a truly distinguished journalistic career.This book was written in the aftermath of Desert Storm. It is, as Kelly states in the forward, an impressionistic account of his experiences during the run-up to the war, the hostilities themselves, and the aftermath. With politics and military science largely excluded, it all adds up to a superior piece of travel writing. Kelly had a great eye for scene-setting, for the telling anecdote, the incongruous detail, and the contrasting pair of viewpoints. Also for the pithy description: he describes a gorgeous couple he met in an elevator in Israel thus: "She looked like Darryl Hannah, and he looked like money and tennis." The people's tales he tells are sometimes funny, and sometimes haunting. The funny ones often involved himself, as when he records himself gaping across a restaurant in Baghdad for a glimpse of the TV news. No one else shows any interest, and it dawns on him that it's because the Iraqi TV newscast is just a series of Saddam's Great Leader proclamations, boringly familiar to everyone. Some scenes are funny and haunting, as in one where a British TV crew is filming an interview with a Kuwaiti man who is describing his torture ordeal at the hands of the Iraqis. The tearful man is repeatedly interrupted by the blasé producer, to amend some technical difficulty or other. It's a fine wartime travelogue, and it is a great pity that there won't be any more such from Michael Kelly.
|
|
|
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Gulf War Behind Enemy Lines, May 8, 1999
By A Customer
Mike Kelly's account of the Gulf War in Martyr's Day: Chronicle of a Small War, is informative and interesting. The Gulf War was carefully planned, undertaken and won by the United States in little over a month. Kelly has carefully written about the war from behind the lines and places we weren't able to see on CNN. I am quite amazed at one point, that Mike Kelly actually swam across a river into Turkey with smugglers. Courage and bravery Mike Kelly must be commended with. His book should be given the same credit for what he went through to write it.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Michael Kelly
by Bing West
by Dexter Filkins
by Evan Wright
See all Editorial Reviews
