Customer Reviews

Mary, Mary

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Based on the hardcover 1992 edition...

This book is this reader's first exposure to author Ed McBain... even though an older writing, tucked amongst all the books owned by this "biblioholic", it begged to be read regardless of its age!
"MARY, MARY" is Mary Barton -- a teacher by occupation; a outstanding flower & plant gardener by hobby, as witnessed by neighbors of the glory of flora in Mary's yard. Mary Barton is accused of killing three young girls, whose bodies are found buried within her floral domain.
Defense Attorney Matthew Hope, and assistants - Toots and Warren - believe in Mary's innocence - most of the time... With a few credible and non-credible witnesses for defense and prosecution alike, the court game of winning the jury's favor is played to the hilt. Witness, neighbor Charlotte Carmody swears that she saw Mary Barton digging at night, burying bodies in her floral paradise garden. A denim dress and a pair of sneakers come into play and question as to the validity of ownership. Meanwhile, a former student of Ms. Barton's - Melanie Lowndes, from England, comes forward to pay the defense expenses, and to support the "gentility" of Mary, testifying that Mary loves children and would never commit murder.
Although this reader at first did not favor the flavor of the rapid-fire, gunshot writing style, I would do the author an injustice by negating the author's book "MARY, MARY" as a bad read -- IT IS A GOOD READ!
Albeit a sound-story premise, I found it awkward to "digest" the author's method of sliding in non-premise scenery and activity, personal and otherwise, as an interruption to the flow of the story.
After getting used to the "he said", "she said"; and the clipped-style format, I found myself being absorbed into the story, and imaged placement in the jury box and court observers section. Readers will find that author McBain allows for lengthier, vivid descriptions of script in court processes as informative & entertaining, inclusive of the judge's actions, the pro and con attorneys arguments, and the orders to the jury of their duties to reaching a viable verdict.
Any reader knows that an ending is not an ending--- until the story actually ends!
I recommend this author and look forward to reading additional Ed McBain writings.

What a simply thrilling book. I doubt if I was the only one who found it not only a great read, but also sort of spooky as well. Once again Mr.Mcbain has succeeded in giving a very well written performance. I would recommend it to anyone who loves a little bit of suspence in thier lives.

In my opinion, the book is nothing more than an exposition of machismo self-indulgence
and self-consciousness that rides (or mounts) on the back of a mediocre courtroom
drama.

It's a relic.

I've forced myself to read many books because I've started in, found it to be questionable, read a few reviews and decided to go back and give it another try. Usually I've been well rewarded. This time, however, I just couldn't get past the obvious writing from the lower regions.

Come on, did you really think I'd believe that an attorney would be hopping into bed with the DA knowing damn well it'd put the hot case in jeopardy? Far more suitable for Hustler. I'm not a prude by any stretch of the imagination, but I found this to be so incredibly far-fetched I ditched it and picked up a great little ditty: "Pornified."

This novel is a fascinating read. But, in comparison to "Three Blind Mice" it is anticlimatic. And one is left wondering exactly why Mary's twin sister decided to show up at Matthew's house and attack his daughter after the verdict was announced when all she had to do was disappear.

Mary, Mary is a fascinating courtroom drama....except for the ending. The ending is contrived and just plain silly. But then, if one must run out of gas, I suppose it is better to do it near the end rather than the beginning.

THIS BOOK WAS GREAT!!! AFTER READING A FEW PAGES I GOT TO THE POINT THAT I WAS TURNING THE PAGES HUNGRILY,I WANTED MORE AND MORE. IT WAS ALSO CONFUSING, WELL THAT WAS THE IDEA AND MC BAIN IS A MASTER AT THIS. BELIEVE ME, YOU WON'T BE DISAPPOINTED WHEN YOU GET TO THE END.