Customer Reviews

Mastering French-With Book (The Foreign Service Institute Language Series)

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(3)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

I currently live in France but only on the weekends and had been a little embarassed at my stagnating level of language skills, so I went for these. I should also mention that I previously went through all three levels of Pimsleur courses; ~$750 worth! Barron's course is a far, far better value... but that's not why I got them; I don't care about the cost. I got them because there's an upgrade path: Barron's sells levels I (15 hrs) and II (25 hrs) and other companies (Audio Forum, for example) sell the remaining 2 levels (54 more hrs!) in the original FSI series. So, it's pretty clear that you're going to be able to get very deep with the language. Having said that, the Pimsleur courses are best if you want to get as much useable minimum, essential French ASAP and you can afford it.

I'm almost done French level 1 and I'll say that they are great. Yes, the technique is brute-force, but it does work. It greatly removes one's hesitancy to speak (improves confidence) and perfects pronunciation. Best for me: it's already smoothed over several tenacious problems I was having what had seemed to be "tricky" grammar points -which the Pimsleur ones didn't cover adequately-... to me, this seems a sign that it's very well designed to get students through the rough spots.

I should also mention that the instruction book doesn't come out any say it, but the way to use it most effectively is: (1) totally memorize a dialog, then do the drills... (2) if you can respond "in time" (i.e., before the answer comes) at least 80% of the time, you move on. Otherwise, go back. I would strongly recommend that when using these (or any audio course) that you respond at full speaking volume, if at all possible... there's a big difference between "responding" to a question in your head and actually responding.

Lastly, years ago I used the Barron's Korean and had two observations: Again, they totally perfect pronunciation, etc... my offices colleagues were totally blown away when a non-asian walked in speaking their language. However, I gave them up thinking the technique was "too boring." In fact, I don't currently have that issue with the French ones. Moral: if you really like the target language, it makes all the difference in the world.

Will try to post a followup.

Yes, yes, this old course belongs to the trite "listen andrepeat" category of self-study language courses. But it's reallythe only way to learn and absorb and "live" a foreign language. Some other courses claim to make you learn a language in record time by simply listening on your Walkman-style tape player while you're exercising or cleaning house. Listen up, fellow Francophiles: It can't be done. A fair amount of actually studying the course material is still required. In other words, technology hasn't yet replaced (eliminated) old-fashioned studying.

I really like this venerable old course, the very same one used to train government agents in the Foreign Service. What sets it apart from more modern, streamlined courses is its emphasis on spoken French. If you're not fortunate enough to live in France or any other French-speaking country, the next best thing is to listen, and listen, and listen some more. There's just no substitute for training your ears in listening comprehension, and these cassettes serve that purpose more than adequately.

This course originally came out in 1960! Not surprisingly, some of the French used is a bit dated and overly formal for today's quick-fix crowd. But if you make a conscientious effort with this course, it still delivers results. And if you're especially ambitious in your studies, you'll acquire the coveted spot-on French accent without even realizing it. How many courses can deliver this kind of aesthetic result?

But the main reason why I'd strongly advise purchasing this course is that Barron's offers it at a truly bargain price.( ). Need I say more?

A time-tested, dependable, flexible course that delivers results--and at an affordable price, too. Sounds like a good deal to me. Purchase this course, apply yourself, and you'll be amazed with the results.

I have tried many fancy language learning products. Many of them are indeed wonderful. The problem is that while those programs may make you think that you have learned a lot, they don't drill you enough so that you can respond instinctively in a real life situation. The FSI tapes, while repetitive and boring, do drill you so thoroughly that, when you have to talk, the words pour out of your mouth before you even know it. My suggestion:Use whatever methods to keep your interest in the language going, but grit your teeth and do FSI drills. Your efforts will be richly rewarded.

This is a great course to help you quickly grasp the French language. Too many language courses seem to overemphasize grammar and fail to really teach the student how to speak confidently and fluently. The approach this course uses is almost total immersion into the language. Extensive drills and repetitive exercises are utilized so the student can practice an endless variety of sentence structures with hundreds of combinations of words. The end result is that one learns to adapt to almost any situation instantly without having to remember what the correct vocabulary was and how the grammar was supposed to work, etc. Plus, the various speakers don't hold back and say the words overly slow and distinct. They say it exactly as it should be, so a beginner has to just jump in and go with it. The beauty of the tapes (or CD's) is that you can review a section as many times as you need to in order to learn it. The second part to this course also follows along the same lines and offers more advanced materials.

If old-school style rote drills and model sentence imitation works for you this course will be a great value. It's a bit dated (the course was developed in the early 1960's) but it works well. Unlike Barron's "Mastering German" tapes they there aren't as many translations of the drills and they don't slow down their dialogs for the student to grasp pronunciation; you'll be hearing them at normal conversation speeds right from the beginning. Six types of drills are presented along with some grammar notes and written exercises. There is also a Level II course with 12 ninety-minute tapes. The dialog portions are repeated with the student playing different roles in the dialog so the tapes do repeat themselves but are nonetheless a good value for learning French on your own. If you intend to use this course as your primary means of learning French on your own purchase a French grammar book to go along with it. A cheap option is Schaum's Outline Series "French Grammar" by Mary Crocker but there are many others.

I have the CD version of this course, and although I did not pay full price, it was still too expensive considering the content. The repetition is helpful for pronunciation, but the same sentences are repeated over and over in every exercise ... so you walk away knowing how to say three sentences in varying forms, with little useful vocabulary.

In addition, the recording quality is quite low, with other conversations often audible in the background of the dialogue and a constant hiss.

While perhaps a passable foundation for someone with time to spend, it is certainly not the best course to prepare you to travel in France. At the least, it would need to be combined with a course that teaches some minimal vocabulary useful for travel situations. I just returned from several days in Paris, and found myself essentially dependent upon sign language, even after completing 10 of the 13 CDs in the set.

This is a very good way to start really speaking French. At first I found it difficult to get started, but before long I found that I was actually making progress, and this helped me to move ahead (and not give up). The course is very well constructed to give a good basic grounding, but should, I think, be supplemented by additional tools (for instance, vocabulary learning). I have been using the Level One course for about 7 months now. I have to drive about 1 hour a day, and try to get through about half an hour each day if I can (except at traffic lights, where people give me strange looks). I find it better to go over the tapes a good number of times, switching out tapes after about a month. Maybe this is excessive, but I am at least familiar with everything the tape has to offer. This is not a miracle course, but will certainly give you more command and fluency. I look forward to starting Level 2 soon.

I thought this product was excellent. It's not a phrase book, and there aren't any color pictures. The course strives for correct French pronunciation and usage through repetition, conversion drills, and substitution drills. And it works. It does take time, and it can be dry. But the results are worth it, I have found, in both France and Quebec. French speakers notice when you don't sound like the typical tourist.

This course is not a shallow treatment of French--it covers everything you need to know to begin learning French--and begin actually speaking the language. This course is long and intensive, but if you are serious about learning French and you plan to use it, this is the tool to do so.

I had 30 hours of college French courses and studied very very hard, yet I never could say I was fluent in French. By the end of just the first unit of this tape series, I gained more fluency than I did in all those college courses. If you REALLY want to learn to speak French, I can think of no better way than these tapes.