Most Helpful Customer Reviews
13 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
recipes for indirect cooking, July 10, 2010
This review is from: Mathematica Cookbook (Paperback)
The title suggests that the reader is already acquainted with handling the ingredients: the core programming language plus one of its five possible programming styles. Procedural programming, functional programming, rule-based programming, object-oriented programming, or recursive programming. When you then work on a larger program and get stuck because you forgot about the details of an implementional task, then reaching for a ready-to-use recipe from a cookbook should solve your task? Yes! Nice idea. The book offers hundreds of fine recipes, always in the typical Mathematica one-liner program format and all classified into easy-identifiable subject areas. So the problem is not finding out whether the book covers the implementional task or on which exact page to locate it. You will very quickly figure it out - the book is perfectly organized this way, for this purpose. And once found, the interested programmer should be able to adopt the recipe's code or idea. No. The true problem with the book and its collection of recipes is ..etc.. Anyway. I welcome Mangano's work. In an indirect way it teaches a lot of wisdom on practical and every-day-use programming, even if the suggested codes not always represent the most efficient codification possible. In comparison, if efficiency and code perfectionism matters, another notable new book in this area (Programming with Mathematica 6.0/7.0, Mathematica As A Programming Language) is Leonid Shifrin's publication (googel, wiki) which, too, contains collections of 'Recipes' (in an effort to be fair and overly modest, he calls them simply 'examples'). Shifrin explains more the intermediate steps (typical one-liner programs) how to get to the final readycode, and in addition, presents several(!) alternative implementations (written in the same programming paradigm with a refined or optimized algorithm/idea, or written in one of the four other programming paradigms) of the same 'Recipe' which are much more efficient and thus, suitable to RL large-scale applications. Shifrin starts where Mangano stops! Depending on your level of programming expertise the one book or the other suits your needs better, so check them out both :) I highly recommend Mangano's book, and even higher Leonid Shifrin book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
book is available in *.nb-format, too!!!, June 18, 2010
This review is from: Mathematica Cookbook (Paperback)
Mathematical scientists probably prefer Weisstein's The CRC Encyclopedia of Mathematics, Third Edition (3 volumes incl. code for Mathematica 7.0) for their research work, true fans adore the sheer thoroughness of Trott's Mathematica Guidebook and study the details page-after-page by working the way up from the bottom through all 4 volumes, total beginners and hasty users are content with a shallow but broad(!) introduction found in Mathematica Navigator, and for all remaining Mathematica practicionists Mangano's tome comes in handy as a helpful complement to the existing Tutorial Collection, see bit.ly/TheMathematicaBook . I've been knowing the software for quite some time and for my engineering studies it never meant more to me than an overpowered calculator but since the book is currently being sold in mass quantities at our campus bookstore I got re-interested too! About the contents: Each recipe has the same setup structure (problem,solution,discussion,reference) and is independent from other recipes apart from incidental crossreferences within the book. Some recipes (there arent too many in total actually) are more general (true recipes), some just explain the use of important key functions (because many users still would not know their use or meaning ;), and some are solutions to very specific problems, so all in all a good mix to learn from! Much material has been compiled and quoted from others but the author would always mention the references in detail or link to them (i didnt know bit.ly before, thanks! ;). The book offers everything a modern book should offer: a personal book webpage with additional and updated contents, a publisher's webpage with eventual typographical errors, the software itself (a Mathematica version is included!), a *.pdf-ebook version, a colorful fulltext *.nb-Mathematica notebook version, support by the makers, etc. So. I dont think that I will actually put the recipes into practice for my mundane mathematical calculations in place of some old TI calc but simply reading and understanding the refined tricks is so instructive, enjoyable and inspiring. All persons involved did a fantastic job with this product release, congrats!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Don't lose time, just pick out your code!, June 15, 2010
This review is from: Mathematica Cookbook (Paperback)
The story doesnt end with the printed paperback (USD 64.99 original price, ouch!), the author has launched a homepage at mathematicacookbookDOTcom to accompany the book. An excellent idea to support (the interest of) its readers for the time to come. The book is basically a compilation of the most important Mathematica HowTo's (selected from the original source/resource: guide/HowToTopics!!) and spiced with the author's original recipe codes in an applied manner. If you want to use the recipe codes from the text you will have to rewrite most/all of it from scratch while adopting the idea or core algorithm from the examples. The main difference between the original Mathematica guide/HowToTopics and the Oreilly version is that the latter features longer, more complicated and full solutional codes to a specific task (or 'problem'). As just mentioned, you cannot just copy the code, change a few Bytes and ready you are. No. You *must* rewrite everything. By doing so, you will learn a lot though.. especially if you had some trouble understanding other books on the same topic. I agree with some other amazon reviewer in that, if time permits, first and foremost reading should be the amazing installed 'Virtual Book' ( which includes howto/* and tutorial/* ). After that you can choose between the 'Function Navigator' ( guide/* and ref/* ), the Trott Guidebook, the Mathematica Navigator, and Mathematica Cookbook. Both references are equally wise choices! Btw, included with this book is a free 30 day trial of the latest Wolfram Mathematica® v7.x software. Maybe that's why de book is so expensive. Anyway, go'n get it now, it's currently the bestselling Mathematica book on amazon! Thanks to the author for publishing an Oreilly cookbook for Mathematica 7, i love it!! :x
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|