Most Helpful Customer Reviews
68 of 70 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Important Read, May 11, 2009
This review is from: A Mathematician's Lament: How School Cheats Us Out of Our Most Fascinating and Imaginative Art Form (Paperback)
Once in a while we read books that we just know are especially important, and that we know we will be thinking and talking about long after reading them. This book is one of them for me.
I am a returning adult student, and I am about to finish my training to become a math teacher. Having gone through my education program, my enthusiasm was just about completely drained, and I've been having trouble remembering why I ever wanted to become a math teacher in the first place. Why would anyone?
Paul Lockhart knows, and his book has reawakened my desire to help students discover the joy of mathematics. His argument is concise, and he makes it forcefully. His book is a joy to read, mainly because his understanding of the subject and his passion for it are clear in every page. He reinforces ideas I already had about how school sucks the life out of math (and all subjects), but he also challenges some of my opinions. I think this will happen with most people who read it.
Once he finishes making his argument about math education in about the first two-thirds of this short book, he devotes the remaining section to describing what he finds wonderful about mathematics itself. This section should make just about anyone want to become either a mathematician or a math teacher.
I want people to read the book for the specifics of his arguments, but I want to discuss one important point that he makes. Many people in math education claim that in order to make math more understandable and interesting to students, we need to show how practical it is and how it is used in everyday life. I've always felt like this idea was wrong, or at least limited in its usefulness in that regard. Well, Lockhart demolishes the idea, essentially claiming that practical uses are simply by-products of math, and that the real excitement and beauty of mathematics is in the abstract, imaginary, and creative world of mathematical ideas that have no specific connection to the everyday. By-products and applications can make math seem boring and secondary to the uses it serves. I agree with him--and much more now after having read his argument.
I honestly think just about everyone should read this book. Of course math teachers should, as should anybody involved in math education in any way. But I think people outside of math education should read it too. The specific mathematical ideas discussed in the book do not require a strong mathematical background, and I can't think of a better book that so concisely conveys the nature of the subject and the way it is viewed and misunderstood in society. I'm still not sure I agree with Lockhart's every point, but I love this book. (And I might agree with his every point after more thought and experience in the classroom.)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
44 of 45 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Brilliant and a little devastating, June 15, 2009
This review is from: A Mathematician's Lament: How School Cheats Us Out of Our Most Fascinating and Imaginative Art Form (Paperback)
When I began to read Lockhart's Lament, I was skeptical -- particularly with his view of mathematics as more of an art than a science. I am an applied mathematician, and I most enjoy teaching applied mathematics, but after serious and humble reflection, I came to fundamentally agree with Lockhart. Mathematics was developed as an expression of human creativity, and teaching it as such is really the only viable option for most students to be able to appreciate it and therefore fully apply it (if they ever need or want to).
As a relatively new mathematics teacher, I appreciate Lockhart's observations of the mathematics curriculum. I taught (college) trigonometry just before reading his Lament for the first time, and I was blown-away (and a little devastated) by the accuracy of his scathing description of that course:
"Two weeks of content are stretched to semester length by masturbatory definitional runarounds... students must learn to use the secant function, 'sec x,' as an abbreviation for the reciprocal of the cosine function, '1 / cos x' (a definition with as much intellectual weight as the decision to use '&' in place of 'and.') That this particular shorthand, a holdover from fifteenth century nautical tables, is still with us... is mere historical accident... Thus we clutter our math classes with pointless nomenclature for its own sake."
This book is an absolute necessity for anyone who wants to make sure their students actually enjoy mathematics. But be warned, if you view teaching mathematics as just a job, this book probably isn't for you.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
34 of 37 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Math is fun, after all., May 1, 2009
This review is from: A Mathematician's Lament: How School Cheats Us Out of Our Most Fascinating and Imaginative Art Form (Paperback)
Paul Lockhart is a mathematics teacher. He obviously loves the subject that he teaches. He is also a writer, and a good one at that. In his delightful little book, Paul explains why mathematics is so interesting, and what is wrong with the current curriculum in our schools.
What many of us have accepted as a "fact" our whole lives is patently false: Mathematics is neither boring nor difficult. Rather, it is creative and fun. Anyone can do it, if only shown how. And they would enjoy it, as much as if they were painting or playing music.
Paul laments that mathematics is not taught like painting or music. It has instead evolved into something unnecessarily dreadful, with rigid terminology and pointless memorization. Is it any wonder why so many otherwise intelligent people think they are bad at mathematics?
I would recommend this book to anyone who "knows" that mathematics is difficult or boring. It is neither! And while we're at it, let's throw out all those boring textbooks...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
