I ordered two of the frosty shower curtains and one arrived with a hole in it, so I caution anyone who buys it to examine it carefully before hanging. I have used the clear shower curtain with mesh pockets before, and found that the clear plastic was much thicker than the frosty curtain, although two of them developed holes after a few months use with very little in the pockets. The plastic material of the frosty curtain is very thin, so I'm not sure how it will hold up. I kept one frosty curtain and I'll report back on how long it lasts before a hole develops, if any. I think I'll be ordering the clear one next time, as the material is thicker and stronger. I love the mesh pockets, but I just wish the plastic would last a little longer.