1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Fair enough collection of femme fatales, but not essential., July 5, 2011
This review is from: McBain's Ladies Too (The 87th Precinct Novels) (Hardcover)
'McBains Ladies Too' is basically a companion piece to the first 'Ladies' book, featuring excerpts from earlier books of the long-running 87th Precinct series, but this time it focusses on the female antagonists and Bad Girls from the series. Included are some fan-favourites such as Virigina Dodge, who tries to blow up the 87th building with nitro, and the un-named "Girl" who ties up and taunts Steve Carella in 'Doll', as well as a few women who aren't genuine villians but still end up getting into bed (literally!) with baddies, such as Naomi Schneider from 'Eight Black Horses'.
It's an enjoyable enough collection for new and old fans alike, but is much less essential than the original 'Laides'. The first book dealt with characters that are present throughout large parts of the series (Teddy Carella, Eileen Burke), and whose backstory and development was scattered across many different books. So there was some merit in collecting all these disparate character moments from earlier novels into one single, logical narrative. No problems there.
In contrast, each of the characters from 'Too' were present in only one book, and there is no connection between any of them, so there's no real advantage in buying 'Too' instead of going out and getting the original novel. If you're intrigued by Virginia Dodge, you might as well read 'Killers Wedge' in its entirety, which fleshes out Virginia's story and gives it a context that these brief extracts lack. Likewise, you should read 'Doll' in full to properly understand why Steve has been imprisoned and what the Girl is after. If you're a more serious fan....yes it's nice to reconnect with some memorable Bad Girls, but the fact is you'll probably have already read the individual novels and know how the stories play out.
'Too' was not a bad idea in principle, but in practise it doesn't work as well as the original 'Ladies', and really you're probably better off just buying and/or re-reading the individual novels.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No